Born Again Poll HELP!

  • Thread starter Thread starter IndianaEnoch
  • Start date Start date

Everyone in Heaven must have been born again.


  • Total voters
    3
I

IndianaEnoch

Guest
Jesus said in John 3 that, "Unless one is born again he can not see the Kingdom of God."

Some of the attributes of a born again person are: faith, righteousness, justification, good works, having one's name wirtten in the book of life, and ect.

Since Jesus said one must be born again to be in the kingdom, then one who exhibits these attribute and will be in the kingdom, this one must at some time have been born agian.

e.g.

Abrahams faith was credited to him as righteousness. Abraham will at some time be in the Kingdom of God, AKA Heaven. Everyone in heaven must have been born again.

Therefore, Abraham must have been at some time born again.

Agree or Disagree?
 
You haven't defined what exactly being reborn means to you.
 
Born again

There seems to be a lot of confusion on the term "born again" - I believe I wrote a post under Apolojetics on the bottom of the second page called John 3:1-7 Explained - I think that may help clear some air if you are into some study - the post was orignally to answer water baptism but I included the term born again because it was in the passage. I trust it helps :-?
 
I agree with what totentanz said:
Maybe you could define what the actual process/event etc of born again means - and where it fits into the work of Christ upon the cross (if at all).

WyldCyde
 
I can not believe how difficult it is to communicate this simple idea.

I will try once again.

If one has faith in Christ, if one has been justified by Christ, if one's name has been written in the book of life, if one will be in heaven, then this one is a new creation in Christ, born again.

If this still didn't help, then go read John 3 and explain to me what you think it means. But please pay attention to verse 7 where Jesus says not to wonder to much about exactly what it means.
 
If one has faith in Christ, if one has been justified by Christ, if one's name has been written in the book of life, if one will be in heaven, then this one is a new creation in Christ, born again.
ok, i'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you can prove all that from scripture - though i dont see all that in john3.

So, Abraham, Moses & David had faith in Christ and were new creation in Christ even before Christ's advent?

Is being born again a specific event in spiritual realm or simply a description of someone who has faith in God?

If born again simply means someone who believes in God then I will agree that Abraham & Moses were born again.

And yes, i've heard the 'they look forward to the cross, we look back at cross reasoning'.

Jesus doesn't really describe what being born again entails in john3 he rather just tells nicodemus that he must be born again.
he ends off by talking about the wind.

Can you at least admit that perhaps other believers dont see being born again the way you do?
I know for a fact that your teaching of born again is contrary to what many teach - even within charismatic & pentecostal circles.

WyldCyde
 
I have scripturial proof of ones who have faith unto righteousness, and that is far more proof than one comming to this saving faith in the next age. So I can not see how you balk at what I was saying, but have no problem with scripturial evidence for UR. BUT I am willing to say that just because it is not there does not mean it couldn't happen.
 
maybe we can for a minute forget about UR.
can you answer some of my questions above - this would really help my understanding of your viewpoint.

WyldCyde

<side note>
Even if you conceed that old testament saints weren't born again or regenerated or born from above - it would be a REAL stretch for me to say that just because abraham wasn't born again YET he was righteous THEN that means that people in future could be righteous also even though they're not born again - that is NOT where my reasoning is headed.
whatever i do or dont show here indiana will not have bearing on whether you doubt your stance on UR & ES.
that is not my purpose. i genuinely am seeking to understand what being born again entails and how it relates to eternal destination if at all, and where it fits into God's plan.
I'm actually gonna look elsewhere for answers cause i dont seem to be getting conclusive ones here - perhaps my questions are bad.
perhaps i need to read my bible more & spend less time on forums, hehe.
 
We will find angels of God in heaven--none of them have been born again!

God Himself is eternal--He never has been born again!

The original question was not thought out well!
 
agreed evanman - the original question was ambiguous and did not take many things into account.
A definition of 'born again' would help and also where it fits into the salvation plan of God.
ie: is being born again an event that happens to believers in their lifetime, or is it something that happens when they die, or is it something that happens over a period of time, or something else?

WyldCyde
 
You guys really take thing to the extreem don't you, it is clear that the question was about humans not angles nor God, clear I say because the guy refered to a verse that was about humans in his question.

I mean really do you have to go off such a bunny trail over such a simple question.

what is bring born again, is that really a hard question? Can you say you are a christian and not know that simple matter? what is the problem.

Jesus said that you have to be born again to get to heaven, he taught us that we born of the flesh then born of the spirit, which really means form above.

If you read the bible, you know that we are born into state of sin that has caused our very spirit to be dead, and only by the new breath of life that is of God can our spirit become alive and know God.

This is not only true of the NT but in the OT as well, Ezeikel told us that God says, "I will take out their stoney hearts and put in them a heart of flesh, and cause them to walk in my statutes"

What is being born again, well we are born once into a sinfull flesh nature, then by the grace of God and the regeneration of the Holy Spirit we are born form above, born not of flesh nor the deisre of men, but of God. we are become lliving souls again.

Now talk of God not having been born again and the angels and all that is just foolishness, the question was very clearly about humans sheshhh, can you guys ever talk with out starting a big silly issue of every thing?
 
evanman said:
We will find angels of God in heaven--none of them have been born again!

God Himself is eternal--He never has been born again!
The original question was not thought out well!

No, you are carring it out to a ridiculus conclusion. Where si you ever see it said that angels or God must be born again?

Thanks Henry, I am about to bang my head on the desk trying to deal with how complex some are trying to make the simple!

It no wonder some are so easily lead astry by fine sounding arguments/
 
One needs to bear in mind when posting on forums such as these that we all come from different backgrounds.
What may seem plain & simple to one person is a new teaching to someone else.
It is downright disrespectful & condescending to belittle people because they do not see as you do - especially if they have never been taught as you have been taught.

Some people dont believe in the immortality of the soul so their concept of heaven is different - they dont believe any man is currently in heaven except Jesus.
Others dont believe in a specific 'born again' experience that essential in order to claim you are saved.
Just do a search on google or checkout come commentaries and you will see that their are MANY different beliefs regarding being born again.

For myself, I have heard the mainstream teaching concerning the need to be born again.

I still do not see how anyone can show from scripture that OT saints were born again in their lifetime.

I see that you believe being born again is a specific event in someone's life - fair enough, my current understanding lines up with that.

I do not necessarily agree that the phrase 'see or enter the kingdom of god' is synonymous with entering a spiritual location called heaven as opposed to going to a spiritual location called hell.
I think people read their doctrines into scriptures like this.

May I ask what your motive behind this thread is IndianaEnoch - what are you trying to find out or what specific questions do you have?

Although I agree that evanman went too far I do think your question is ambiguous. Now that you are henry have defined what being born again is then perhaps you will get better answers.

WyldCyde
 
Born again

Regarding “born again†- Let’s throw out the commentators and tradition for a minute and look at the scriptures for this I think we can agree on. Basic premise – the term “born again†in John 3 and “salvation†today are two different doctrines for two different groups of people for 2 different ages. I sought to stay away from the forum but I saw this discussion going on and wanted to try one more time to clear up this important doctrine. I know this may be long but give it a read.

First – Context for the setting where term is used: Jesus confronts a leader of the Jews before Calvary. Basically still under Old Testament theology where God is still dealing with Israel as a nation. Let’s put ourselves in Nicodemus’ shoes and forget what we know now with advanced revelation. Nicodemus knew nothing of Calvary (the disciples didn’t either - Luke 18:34 And they understood none of these things: and this saying was hid from them, neither knew they the things which were spoken.). Why did Jesus tell Nicodemus “ye must be born again� One must go aback and remember what God’s propose for Israel as a nation was. Israel as a nation was to be a kingdom or priests representing God to the other nations in the ages to come. Israel was to be used as the nation to dispense the blessing of God to the rest of the world. In the Old Testament it is evident that Israel failed in God’s plan as a nation and God cast them aside for the time being. God’s plan was to restore them as a nation in a one time miraculous event (Isa. 66:8, Ezek. 37; Heb. 8:8-10), bring them into the land and then they would fulfill God’s purpose for them. God had to restore them miraculously for they could not do it on their own because of sin.

When Jesus confronted Nicodemus Israel was in rejection because they had failed in being what God had called them to be as a nation so Jesus told him that “ye†(Israel) must be born again in order to be the nation that God called them to be. Remember, that Jesus’ first coming could have been his second coming if Israel had accepted him as their Messiah (Matt. 11:14). Since they didn’t his first coming became the first coming and his restoring of Israel would come at his second coming. Remember, some thought John the Baptist was Elijah for Elijah was supposed to come before that notable and great day of the Lord Mal. 4:5, and Mat 11:14 And if ye will receive it, this is Elias, which was for to come..

Before Jesus comes back the second time He calls the scattered nation of Israel (James 1:1) back to the land, the Lord comes back and does the miraculous work – they, as a nation, become born again in a day (Isa. 66:8) and God leads them into the land with His word written in their hearts and finally they will fulfill the purpose God had planned for them which was to be a kingdom of priests and dispense God’s blessings to the nations.

Why the term “born again� Because they will basically be the same people but with new hearts and spirits but essentially still be people. Now there is what born again means. It applies to the nation of Israel at the end of the tribulation.

Second - Now what about us? After Calvary the door is opened to the Gentiles and the mystery that has been hid, Eph. 3:9; Col 1:26, is revealed to Paul and then God has Paul write it down so we today can get it. Paul does not ell us we are “born againâ€Â(In fact he says he was one “born out of due time†but he was different than us) – he tells us we are “new creatures†II Cor. 5:17 created in Christ Jesus – Eph. 2:10. This is something that nobody before has been partaker of. If you have been called of God and have trusted Christ then you are redeemed, regenerated, glorified, saved, sealed, spiritually circumcised, adopted, raised to sit in heavenly places, member of the body of Christ physically (bone of his bone flesh of his flesh – Eph. 5) and much more. This did not happen to anybody prior to this age. Being “born again†and being made a “new creature†are two different things for two different groups for two different ages. The salvation of Old Testament saints is a different subject but suffice it to say our salvation today is far more blessed that what they had in the Old Testament.

Be careful in taking “born again†and generically applying it to a general term for salvation to anybody in any age – It only applies to Israel at the Second Advent before they go in to the kingdom. Paul is very clear on what terms we are to use for our salvation today. You have let the media dictate doctrine to you. Ever since Jimmy Carter used the term born again the populace has used this term to mean NT salvation. In other words “born again†has been tossed around to represent all kinds of unscriptural things.

No Jew in the OT was “born again†– they may have been “saved†in the OT sense but not “born again†for this can only be doctrinally applied to Israel as a nation at the end of tribulation when God will call his people from the four corners of the earth, do the miraculous work, Eze. 37, Heb. 8:8, and then bring them into the land.

Please, when you want to try to figure out if OT people are “saved†then fine but don’t try to use the term “born again†as applying to salvation today or even to OT saints. Use the terms that Paul used for the saved saint today (created, saved, redeemed, justified, etc.). Why would you to talk about Jews in the gospels being saved when Christ hadn’t even died yet and Christ’s own disciples didn’t even understand Calvary - Luke 18:34 And they understood none of these things: and this saying was hid from them, neither knew they the things which were spoken.

Summary –
1. Are people born again in the Old Testament?
Ans. – No - Israel will be born again in a day at the end of tribulation.
2. Are people “saved†in the Old Testament?
Ans. – Yes, but not the same way we are saved today. All are saved based upon Calvary but the message we all have to believe is different. The Jews in the Old Testament had to believe that God would accept them based upon their adherence to he law. They were forgiven based upon their faith in the message regarding the law. God had Calvary prepared to finally do away with their sins, which he was overlooking (Acts 3:19,20). NO individual Jew knew anything about Christ dying for their sins – Isa 53 was hid from them.
3. Are people born again today?
No – we are saved according to what Christ did at Calvary and the results of that salvation are mainly found in Ephesians and Colossians. We have been created a new creature for what do you call a being that has been made partakes of Christ’s body described in Eph. 5:30?

God was calling out a nation in the Old Testament – Today God is calling out a body.

I know you may not agree with this but if you take your Bible (and you know which one I’m referring to for the cross references are lost with the new translations) and concordance and run the references you should see this. If you still don’t then I can do no more. I’m sure if I had more time I could make it simpler and shorter but on the spur of the moment this is all I can come up with so forgive me. I’ve spent more time on this subject than I ever planned to spend. The words of redeemdbygrace are ended on this matter. :-?
 
Born again

Final thought - forgot to mention - I'm not stupid enough to think that I have all the above down pat - I am still studying like most of us. I'm a little vague on the Old Testament salvation issues. But I feel confident that the part on what born again means is sound - I'm sure you can find some flaws in there but God will work these things out with my reasoning. But I can't answer questions regarding things in the Old Testament that I'm just not sure of and I'm sure anybody has that down' pat anyway. May God bless! :-?
 
Wydecyde,

My motive has been palin and straight forward from the begining. You can not look at it because you would also have to look at the ambigeous facts of UR. If you can not accept that all men in heaven were at sometime born again, then it is even more difficult to say that there is another time when men are born again. I started this poll to show that my question was understandable despite what you were saying. So far only you and Evanman have had a problem understanding it. Evanman was trying to make himself look wise and turned out looking foolish. You can not admit to understanding what I an saying because of the implications it has concerning UR.

Perhaps there are many believes about being born again, but what we believe does not make it true. There are many believes about Jesus, but not all are true.

Jesus said 2 things concerning being born again. First, everyone must be born again to enter what we commonly call heaven. Second, He said not to marvel over that he said we must be born again.

You are marveling over the technical aspects of it to avoid the implications it has for UR.

I can find people in the Bible who demonstrate the attributes of one who has been born again. There is nothing to be found to give any indication of one being or having been born again in a later age than the age of grace.

So far the poll is showing that it is not me who has not been clear in what I am saying, but you who do not understand. Not considering Evanman's extreme, you are standing alone. Maybe thats some idication for you to consider just how certain one can be of UR.

God Bless
 
Born again poll

I vote for "to go to heaven one must be a new creation".

"Born again" is an over used expression not applicable today. Jesus wasn't crucified yet when He said that to Nicodemas. The need for all Israel to be 'born again', literally 'begotten from above', to see the kingdom of God was promised in Ezek.36:24-28. Israel, who is scattered among the nations will be returned to their land and given a new heart, and a new spirit will put in them.

Bick
 
Back
Top