Search results

Wisdom was expounding on Isaiah? And what was Isaiah expounding on when we read about the Suffering Servant? If you discard one, you will need to discard the other, as Christians do not see an "either/or" when reading about the Suffering Servant - Jesus/Israel Why does it matter whether...

You are absolutely correct. Apocrypha is falsely attributed to the book of Wisdom. However, I believe if one actually reads it, one would find there are some very eerie connections in it to what Christians would later believe (an incredible description of the suffering servant and the...

Because the Church said they were Sacred Scriptures, inspired by God, useful for teaching, preaching and living the life of a Christian. They accurately expressed the oral teachings and traditions once given and are said to have come "from" the Apostles, although to the ancient, that didn't...

People need to consider that there was also a series of Deuterocanonical books in the NEW Testament, as well. SOME people also disagreed with their inclusion into the Canon. A number of early Catholics didn't think much of Revelation. Who REALLY wrote 2 Peter? James? We know a famous person...

You must be joking... How do I know you are writing those posts? Please, get real. You call that an answer? We aren't talking about knowing something with a reasonable doubt, which is the bar historians set when making such decisions on who wrote what and whether something is a gloss, etc...

Ha, I think you are comparing apples to orange, if I may borrow your analogy. We both know there is a vast difference between mathematics and history and what can be regarded as UNMISTAKEABLY true. This is another ploy. In math, we can prove theorems infallibly. We can duplicate and...

You continue to fail to realize that humans cannot write infallibly and recognized as such. Your analogy really makes no sense. YOU can know you wrote it, but what good is that to the mods or me - or to another person analyzing the bible from 2000 years ago??? Paul knew what he wrote, but...

You can't, so end of story...

I am quite aware of the variety of transmissions of the written manuscripts, I knew about them long before I came to this show. Is this what you have sunken to, Mondar? Pitiful accusations. I myself have mentioned the variety of transcripts in several posts previously - for the point to PROVE...

["turnorburn, post: 890471, member: 189"]Back in post #12 Barbarian said: This concerning the books of the bible so this council of Trent was made up by men whom supposedly had directions from God in order prescribe the official books of the bible.. i was curios to know if they were doing this...

Muslims say Mohammed had it right...doesn't prove he wrote what we call Romans or it is from God. I suppose you could google an answer to the question, I fail to see the relation to the topic.

So did Joseph Smith and Mohemmed, according to them. What question did you ask me?

I am not ignoring this post, but quite frankly, it is filled with the same lack of appreciation for what "infallibility" means, so there is no point in continuing a detailed response. Your next to last sentence states the problem clearly: You cannot have a fallible view of a book and call it...

WIP, To your question - it would appear that the idea of the contents of the canon was a long process based upon utilization of particular books to explain the teachings of the Apostles. Thus, when we look at the Church Fathers of the first few centuries, we see that they use particular...

The Greek used by Peter refers to "letters", not "Sacred Scriptures". You see "scriptures", which means "writings", and you presume that they are equated to Exodus and Genesis. Clearly, Paul wrote a number of things that we no longer possess. Most Scripture scholars recognize that we do not...

I don't know anything about the variety of Greek manuscripts? Really? You think that? Wow, maybe it's time for me to leave again, I don't need such comments. I clearly stated several times in this very thread that there are a variety of manuscripts TO PROVE MY POINT about knowing whether a...

As I mentioned to Mondar, "Scriptures" in the above citation does not necessitate the same meaning you are implying, but can also refer to any writing whatsoever. Furthermore, a more careful reading states this: Some of Paul's writings are difficult to understand. This misunderstanding...

Thanks for your input, but you fail to see my point - that you are using circular reasoning... Is the Bible the Word of God? Yes... How do you know? Because the Word of God is in the Bible... Just the simple existence of a collection of books that we call the Bible proves nothing...

Reba, What would make this a "dead thread"? I ask because I was asked to return to this forum after a long time and give my particur Catholic input on the subject. I did because I see this subject as utterly DECISIVE. All the talk about faith/works or the Eucharist or the Trinity is...