I loved the
"love comes softly" series that was on hallmark but can get in blockbuster. But would think that would be to girly for you, but surprisingly my husband enjoyed it
If you hate waltons etc you won't like it.
"the visitation" by Frank Peretti was quite good if you missed that.
"hangmans curse" by him as well is older but OK.
I might get
"house" out (April 7th DVD) as I like haunted house movies but I did hate the book (not well written) but will work for a movie
"thr3e" was good but not much of a christian message
I don't know if the above technically would fall into "christian movies" but Peretti's movies have an underlying 'christian' theme, albeit it even more dumbed down in some movies.
Those are the only ones I can think of just now apart from "fireproof".
edit: I went into blockbuster online, as that is how I saw them. But you can get them through amazon as well. Don't know if netflix carries them - probably do.