I'll grab you some resources when I'm more awake. Work is brutal right now. I'll shoot ya a dm. I simplified post to biology since both anatomy and phys are subjects within biology.
3. That's not the argument that is made sir, if your chromosomes are XY, you are a male and if their XX you are a female. What's "preached" is that if despite the fact I have the natural anatomy at birth of a male and the biological chromosomes of XY (male), I feel like a girl, I like dolls, I like girl clothes, so since I feel this way therefore I am a female. Chromosomes don't care about your feelings. Anatomy doesn't care about your feelings. And you can talk about hormone blockers and other anatomy changers but that's artificial, and thus unnatural occurences caused by human intervention. A man will never produce ovia or milk, neither will a woman ever produce sperm. A man will never get pregnant despite what tik tok or lil nas projects, a man will never have a period. A woman will never be able to impregnate another woman.
This is where we start getting into the weeds. The concept of biological sex ( sexual dimorphism) is where chromosomes come in. For the grand magority of the population your sex and gender match. Gender is the social expression of roles mixed with the genetic foundation. Trans people develope gender dysphoria because for some reason their brains tell them they should be the opposite sex. So far the cause is still widely disputed and being researched, however it's common enough that psychologists recognize its a phenomenon that happens to about 1%of the population.
As far as I am aware (and my position is willing to change as I learn as itvhas many times), that's for trans people it's more about coping with something they can't control and transitioning helps. I think the " I feel therefore I am" is a gross over simplification of the topic consider Trans, gender non conforming, and non binary people tens to get lumped together. I see the 3 groups as different. I see trans people as people that have a medical condition, gender non conformist s as people that buck tends and non binary people as people in-between those 2. Online discourse is a mess because the lines between these 3 are blurry and it's hard to tell when we are talking about which one.
A controversial figure would be Kinsey. I definatley disagree with some of his methods, ethics, and points of view, but he was trying to do a good faith effort into understanding sex, gender, and how these concepts are impacted by both psychology and Biology. A lot of his research is very outdated, but laid the foundation for people to do further research.
[/QUOTE]
1. Alright I guess.
2. You're analysis would be correct if the factors of pressurizing environments weren't existed and autonomous cognitive functions were fully in effect. Meaning the children who are influenced into transgenderism by their lgbt activists parents, teachers, and etc who are molding the tender child into their image. And if it were true that the brain just made decisions on it's own then that would work as well.
I can garuntee this: Raise one child in a regular environment, treat them as their chromosomes are, and live a regular life.
Then raise another child who you constantly try to engrave you're transgenderism ideologies into their unhardenned cement of a mind, give a boy dolls and dresses and a girl tomboy clothes, praise them when they say they are the opposite sex of their chromosomes and see which one "identifies" as transgender or who is more likely. That's why instead of arguing cemented brain grown ups the lgbt movement heads for the children. Just because a 3 year old boy plays with a doll doesn't mean "I knew I was a girls since I was 3", no! A 3 year old will play with anything! If he plays with a socket, does that make him electricity? No. I can have inclinations, but am I to act on them? If my brain tells me I am a frog, do I do so? (Look up videos of people identifying as other things, specifically frog and demon I've seen). Same with homosexuality and heterosexuality, I have urges, everything in my body is telling me to charge, I feel like I can't help it, but do I really have to act on them, I can't just practice self-control/discipline?
I don't respect a movement that tries to overcomplicate very simple ideas as an excuse. Just research any person who detransitioned. It's a choice and usually aided by pressure, because since the lgbt can't reproduce (except for straight bi's) they have to recruit otherwise. Trans people are trans because they want to be trans or they've been indoctrinated into trans ideology not because they just can't help it. And bringing God into the equation, they can't help it because of the sin nature innate into all humans, you, I, and everyone. We get the inclinations, God gets the inclinations as Jesus faced every temptation (Hebrews 4:15), but he overcame them all.
So to reel in all that gibberish. The brain functionality point you brought up is a fancy way of saying they have inclinations, but the question is, do we obey them? The brain has tons of inclinations outside of gender, but do we obey them?
