It makes you what ever you have chosen to be.
Your story is not that unusual. I too was circ'd as a baby, made a profession of faith in the Church of the Nazarene at age 7, attended an independent pentecostal church, an Assy of God, and a Church of Christ, all before I graduated high school. And during that time I also visited Catholic, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Methodist and Baptist congregations. Even worked one summer at a Fundamentalist Baptist youth camp.
In college I attended a "shepherding" congregation and became friends with several believing Jews. From there I went to a Word of Faith congregation and now am in the Messianic Jewish branch of the Body. (for the last 22 years)