Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

God's Will?

Pizza

Member
I often hear people say that "God is in control".
I disagree. I think that He CAN exercise control, but that He does not always do so.

I often hear "God's will always happens",
I disagree. I think that His will DOES often happen, but not always.

I often hear people say, "If it happened, then it was God's will".
I think that many things happen that are outside of His will.

If the above three italicized statements are all true, then, well, abortion happens. Is abortion, at least sometimes, God's will? (I say no. You will have a very hard time convincing me otherwise.)

See, my position is that God allows a LOT of stuff that is NOT in His will. I MUST take this position, otherwise, I must accept that His will includes some things that I find contradictory to what I understand His character to be.

I do not post here for a debate or argument, I instead ask others to offer me their view, their wisdom. Am I overlooking something within logic or scripture?

Can some of you help me out here?
 
Maybe this will help to explain...

John 19:10 Then saith Pilate unto him, Speakest thou not unto me? knowest thou not that I have power to crucify thee, and have power to release thee?

11 Jesus answered, Thou couldest have no power at all against me, except it were given thee from above: therefore he that delivered me unto thee hath the greater sin.
 
hmmm...this is difficult. I've heard some Christians refer to History as HIS story, an ongoing story of God's work in His world. Thing about that is...

...well, what about The Holocaust? What about ongoing deep poverty all over the world? Child abuse? Spousal abuse? HIV/AIDS?

CS Lewis wrote a book...God on the Dock or something...about how more modern people want to put God on trial because He doesn't fit our moral standards. I get that, to a point, but...

I still have questions. I believe God is omnibenevolent and omnipotent, so I'm wondering if a lot of History (and the world currently) is more a display of unredeemed human nature, plus the evil one. Avarice, violence, hatred, etc...seem to be a big part of our nature. Christ changes us individually. Christian-inspired policies help restrain the worst in people at the group-level.

So...is God in charge? "Where was God?" "Well...where was man?"
 
I'd forgotten the "HIStory" thing, CE. But on that note, we can look back in the O.T. and see how God dealt with Soddam(sp?) and Gomorrah. Killing of a great number of people WAS His will - but they were verified to ALL have given themselves over to sin - that is not true of an innocent baby or even many people suffering in this world. My own sister is CERTAINLY a child of God and look at what she's going thru.

As to "where was God?" and "Where was man?" - well, He is not here, but we ARE. Some things are left up to us, IMO.

But I still question, Just how well we can 'see' or 'judge' what God's will really is.
 
Romans 8:28 And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose.

When I was reading the OP, this scripture came to me. Even through the BS, we can see God. All the devil was throwing at Job, Job still had his eyes set on the Lord. It was the devil's job to get Job to curse the Lord. True faith can see through all the BS in the world. Mercy is a big deal to God, because God is merciful and who are we to not be merciful in a world that has the devil throwing stuff at people.

We have to remember that the devil is working against us all.
 
I often hear people say that "God is in control".
I disagree. I think that He CAN exercise control, but that He does not always do so.

Trying to extract Gods Hands out of actions in His creation can never really compute, can they? John 1:1-3, Col. 1:16-17, Heb. 1:3, Rev. 4:12 all show Gods creation of all things, upholding all things, by Him all things consisting. When we, by our own impositions and suppositions depart from these understandings we have only done ourselves a disservice.

Why would we isolate God from adverse actions? His adverse actions are well set to print just as easily seen as the good. What we are really horrified about is a God that created, deployed and uses evil and death. But that side of the equation is where we are inevitably compelled to look. In the realm of theology it's a subsection termed theodicy. The scriptural studies of vindication of Perfect God in relationship to evil/death/sin in the creation.

When I first started studying this general subject, I was perhaps fortunate to try to engage trying to "define" just exactly what Perfect God really means. I found out I couldn't really define or limit, from my quite limited by comparison perspective, what that really means, because logically, reasonably, we are instantly stymied if we can't see our own limits in such feeble attempts. Understanding my own limits gave me appreciations for the term "eternal." I instantly distrust anyone who says "they captured" the Mystery of God in Christ. It can not be done, legitimately. That's why God is termed A Great Mystery. I might even say "An Eternally Great Mystery." At that point of understanding I left off that side of the ledgers to examine the other side of the equations, as they are more tangible. Every "thing" else must logically, reasonably fall under and below The Eternally Great Mystery of God. Basic hinge point.

I often hear "God's will always happens",
I disagree. I think that His will DOES often happen, but not always.

I'd say His Will always happens, regardless, by reasons of simple Superiority.
I often hear people say, "If it happened, then it was God's will".
I think that many things happen that are outside of His will.

If the above three italicized statements are all true, then, well, abortion happens. Is abortion, at least sometimes, God's will? (I say no. You will have a very hard time convincing me otherwise.)

God is not extracted from matters of death. By His Own Words, HE KILLS. This fact can not be avoided:

Deuteronomy 32:39
See now that I, even I, am he, and there is no god with me: I kill, and I make alive; I wound, and I heal: neither is there any that can deliver out of my hand.

I'd just have to call that Divine Superiority. There is no other way to reasonably see it.

1 Samuel 2:6
The Lord killeth, and maketh alive: he bringeth down to the grave, and bringeth up.

Again, same observation as prior. Divine Superiority.

Deuteronomy 30:15
See, I have set before thee this day life and good, and death and evil;

I haven't found any reasonable way to get past any of the above.

See, my position is that God allows a LOT of stuff that is NOT in His will. I MUST take this position, otherwise, I must accept that His will includes some things that I find contradictory to what I understand His character to be.

Ultimately, IF we see that in His Divine Superiority over "all things" and works "all things" for Ultimate GOOD, I believe God to be completely and totally "exonerated" in any exercises of good and evil. And Paul points us directly to that sight, here.

Romans 8:28
And we know that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose.

IF I didn't believe the above, I'd have given up on God in Christ and theology in general long ago.

We just have to turn up our own dials of understanding His Far Surpassing Superiority over "all things" and not try to drag Him down, to "equalize" Him with His creation, which is a shame, really. What people don't understand is that God can create and deploy any particular thing, power, working, and NOT be the same as that which is created. This is where the theological train wreck happens, when we equalize God to created things or created powers, adverse.
I do not post here for a debate or argument, I instead ask others to offer me their view, their wisdom. Am I overlooking something within logic or scripture? Can some of you help me out here?

Pretty much. I've seen a myriad of believers who try to dissect God away from His Own creation. It doesn't work. And these same all do so on the quite false basis of "equalizing" The Divine Sovereign to "things" in His creation, which is the essence of the problem.

Allow me to provide a very small example of Divine Reasoning, which Paul uses, and I can cite by scripture, but I'll summarize it thusly:

IF God created evil to demonstrate His Eternal Mercy to us by using that adverse power OVER us, IS He justified in doing so?

I say Absolutely He Is Justified in doing so. In this He shows both His Divine Superiority and His Mercy.

We might even see that God in Christ, in the context of unlimited Power and unlimited Authority, can take every evil and make it as if it NEVER even happened. IF it all works out to the good. And, IF then His Superiority over "all things" is demonstrated to us, what a Mighty God we serve.

Christian theological food for thoughts and contemplations. Give God more credit. Thank Him for "all things." Give thanks in "all things." Expect not only a good, but A PERFECT outcome.
 
that makes a lot of sense. I look over my own HIS-story and I think I see God's work in all the good things. If nothing else, He softened the impact of a lot of horrible things for me, even when I was an unrepentant wretch.

On a larger scale...I think you're correct to point out the destructive actions of the adversary. That's one problem I have with the idea that God is directly, 110% behind all things that happen in the world. Say...Dude gets cancer. Dude's church people friends say "well, God's will be done. He has a plan." OK, but...

...what if dude had an occupation in which he was exposed to carcinogens because of slack government oversight and corporate greed? What if dude had a questionable diet because of poverty? And...what if dude man dies from the treatment he receives, but a different treatment could very well have given him 10 more years? Is that "God's will," or is that our fallen, sin marred and scarred world, plus human nature wreaking havoc on yet another person?
 
But I still question, Just how well we can 'see' or 'judge' what God's will really is.

1 John 3:23 And this is his command: to believe in the name of his Son, Jesus Christ, and to love one another as he commanded us.

Let's focus on this, and then his will, will become a little clearer.

His Son is what love looks like and we need to receive that kind of love and then give it to others.
 
that makes a lot of sense. I look over my own HIS-story and I think I see God's work in all the good things. If nothing else, He softened the impact of a lot of horrible things for me, even when I was an unrepentant wretch.

On a larger scale...I think you're correct to point out the destructive actions of the adversary. That's one problem I have with the idea that God is directly, 110% behind all things that happen in the world. Say...Dude gets cancer. Dude's church people friends say "well, God's will be done. He has a plan." OK, but...

...what if dude had an occupation in which he was exposed to carcinogens because of slack government oversight and corporate greed? What if dude had a questionable diet because of poverty? And...what if dude man dies from the treatment he receives, but a different treatment could very well have given him 10 more years? Is that "God's will," or is that our fallen, sin marred and scarred world, plus human nature wreaking havoc on yet another person?

C.E., you are very spiritually discerning. You are such a gift to this website.
 
WOW...

Smaller, post 7, that is a lot to digest, but I will work on it.
CE, post 8 - thanks for that.
 
I agree with your general concept here Pizza, but I would offer a different perspective. Keep in mind the story of Job; how Satan approached God and needed permission to attack Job, his family, his home, his livestock, and his possessions. While i don't believe it is "God's will," directly for suffering, sin and such; it is His will to choose what to allow or not allow; thus making it in a sense "His will." Jesus did allude to the idea, as did the disciples, as do scriptures; that sin in and of itself, in conjunction with the law-is what makes our path to heaven through Christ a necessity. Thus, there had to be allowed....and thus willed...a certain amount of sin, suffering and evil in the world to contrast our need for a savior and prove that we cannot attain justification by our own means.

As far as seeing God's will...agreed. In chapter 55:8&9 of Isaiah allude to the concept that we simply cannot comprehend all that is God and His will. As far as judging what is God's will...LOL..scripture actually says we can; and it gives us a pattern to follow in doing so.

Romans 12:2 And be not conformed to this world: but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind, that ye may prove what is that good, and acceptable, and perfect, will of God.
1 Thessalonians 4:2-4 For you know what instructions we gave you through the Lord Jesus. For this is the will of God, your sanctification: that you abstain from sexual immorality; that each one of you know how to control his own body in holiness and honor
1 Peter 2:13-16 Be subject for the Lord’s sake to every human institution, whether it be to the emperor as supreme, or to governors as sent by him to punish those who do evil and to praise those who do good. For this is the will of God, that by doing good you should put to silence the ignorance of foolish people. Live as people who are free, not using your freedom as a cover-up for evil, but living as servants of God.

These are just a few examples but we are told to "test everything," and to "try all the spirits." The measures by which we can know God's will are by finding its parallel in scripture and the revealed character, words, and acts of God, Christ and the Holy Spirit. Again i would clarify that this doesn't mean we will always be given or granted the knowledge we seek in regards to God's will as some things may simply be beyond our ability or position to receive.

In the end I think we simply do well to exercise caution when we put God's stamp on things. Just because a thing seems "good," doesn't mean it is "God." Every "good thing," comes from our Father, but a thing seeming good and being good are two separate items. I would offer these things to consider: 1) Just because it is God's will to allow an item doesn't mean it is God's will to cause it. 2) Though things do happen outside God's character does not mean they happen outside God's will to allow. (Keep in mind Jesus' reply to the disciples' query as to whom sinned, the blind man or his parents. Christ stated, that it was neither; but was God's will in order to show his power, love and willingness to heal. 3) Keep in mind that we cannot see the outcome, nor can we see how a single item will affect the "grand scheme," thus...much of what we may not think is God's will; may actually be essential in order to bring about the final result.

Just things to consider anyhow.
 
IF God not only allows but causes enemies to offend/trespass against us and we learn from that to forgive as He Forgives, is He Justified in doing so? Again, yes. IF God Himself Longsuffers beings who are less than His Perfection is He Justified in doing so? Again, yes. In doing so He not only proves His Own long suffering, but His Mercy in the process.

Read Gods Eternal Characteristics of Love in 1 Cor. 13. These are Gods Eternal Things, which He SHARES with us. God will give any believer all they care to take on. I'd like to say more please! But that DOES come with some downside. As Jesus so aptly demonstrated on His Cross.
 
I often hear people say that "God is in control".
I disagree. I think that He CAN exercise control, but that He does not always do so.
I think there's a difference between God being in control and God being controlling.
 
Mat_10:28 And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.

`
 
Can some of you help me out here?
God is completely sovereign.
In His total sovereignty, He is able to allow his creatures (the devils and men in particular) to make their own free will choices.
In His complete sovereignty, He can allow anything He chooses to allow.

The scripture says: (2Pe 3:9 RSV) The Lord is not slow about his promise as some count slowness, but is forbearing toward you, not wishing that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance.

It is not God's will that anyone go to hell and so He is patient with sinners and gives them time to come to their senses and repent and have eternal life. But it is completely absurd to imagine that it is God's will that sinners continue to sin and go to hell.
 
God is completely sovereign.
In His total sovereignty, He is able to allow his creatures (the devils and men in particular) to make their own free will choices.
In His complete sovereignty, He can allow anything He chooses to allow.

The scripture says: (2Pe 3:9 RSV) The Lord is not slow about his promise as some count slowness, but is forbearing toward you, not wishing that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance.

It is not God's will that anyone go to hell and so He is patient with sinners and gives them time to come to their senses and repent and have eternal life. But it is completely absurd to imagine that it is God's will that sinners continue to sin and go to hell.
I'm cool with that whole post.

My problem is things like abortion. I know that he ALLOWS it, but I struggle with what His will is concerning it. I do not believe that it is His WILL for abortion to happen, or child abuse, or all sorts of stuff - just like I don't think it is God's will for any sinner to perish in Hell.

THEREFORE, my assertion that the views: "Well, what ever God's will is, it will happen" and "God's will always wins" are BOTH false.
Many things we see around us are outside of His will.

Somehow, your post made that very clear to me - I no longer struggle with it all, I'm right back where I started - in the position that MUCH of what we see in the world today is NOT His will.
 
just like I don't think it is God's will for any sinner to perish in Hell.
As I understand the scriptures, it certainly is NOT God's will that any should perish in hell. (1 Peter 3:9) Anyone who goes to hell goes there because he chooses evil over good.
Jhn 3:19-30 (RSV) And this is the judgment, that the light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. For every one who does evil hates the light, and does not come to the light, lest his deeds should be exposed.
Jesus has opened the door of the kingdom of heaven to anyone who will enter. If anyone does not go in, it is because he chose not to go in and God does not force anyone to love Him. (Probably because it is impossible to force anyone to love. They must choose to love.)
THEREFORE, my assertion that the views: "Well, what ever God's will is, it will happen" and "God's will always wins" are BOTH false.
I agree.
....MUCH of what we see in the world today is NOT His will.
It is referred to by some as God's "permissive" will but, that seems like word games to me.
We are responsible for our choices and God gives us a lot of time to choose to follow His ways. He doesn't force us to go our way or His way but, eventually, our time is up and we get the eternal future we bought for ourselves according to the treasures we built up for ourselves; either a fortune of blessings or a fortune of evil.
Pick one.

iakov the fool
 
Back
Top