What's new
By:
Filters
Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • Are you receiving an "error" mesage when posting?

    Chances are it went through, so check before douible posting.

    We hope to have the situtaion resolved soon, and Happy Thanksgiving to those in the US!

  • Desire to be a vessel of honor unto the Lord Jesus Christ?

    Join For His Glory for a discussion on how

    https://christianforums.net/threads/a-vessel-of-honor.110278/

  • Taking the time to pray? Christ is the answer in times of need

    https://christianforums.net/threads/psalm-70-1-save-me-o-god-lord-help-me-now.108509/

  • Ever read the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ?

    Read through this brief blog, and receive eternal salvation as the free gift of God

    /blog/the-gospel

  • Have questions about the Christian faith?

    Come ask us what's on your mind in Questions and Answers

    https://christianforums.net/forums/questions-and-answers/

  • How are famous preachers sometimes effected by sin?

    Join Sola Scriptura for a discussion on the subject

    https://christianforums.net/threads/anointed-preaching-teaching.109331/#post-1912042

  • Focus on the Family

    Strengthening families through biblical principles.

    Focus on the Family addresses the use of biblical principles in parenting and marriage to strengthen the family.

    Read daily articles from Focus on the Family in the Marriage and Parenting Resources forum.

The Best OS Contest!

V

Vince

Member
WHICH IS THE BEST OPERATING SYSTEM? Introduction


For weeks now, I have been enjoying Windows 10, Chrome, and Linux every day. And while I still have lot to learn, I can discuss which one is the best. Online “tests” of these operating systems show varied results, with accusations of “Foul!” from fans of the losers. But I like all three systems. However, someone has to come in last, so:

1) I will go through various categories, giving 1 point to the winner, 0 points to #2, and -1 to the loser. In case of a tie, the tied OS's will each get a 0.

2) To be fair, I will only use a limited criteria. You can easily fake the results by dividing one OS you like into several groups (with your favorite OS winning every time), while uniting an OS you don’t like into one group.

3) My criteria assume that the user is familiar with Windows, and therefor knows how to operate a computer.

And of course, courteous disagreements are welcome.
 
WHICH IS THE BEST OPERATING SYSTEM? Part 1 GAMES

This one isn’t debatable—Windows has the best games. Not only does it excel in high-tech games, but it has far more mid-level and simple games than the other two systems combined.

I find that while both Chrome and Linux have some excellent games, Chrome has more. Plus, many Linux games require installing an “engine” before you can play.

Score: Windows 1; Chrome 0; Linux -1
 
Vince said:
WHICH IS THE BEST OPERATING SYSTEM? Part 1 GAMES

This one isn’t debatable—Windows has the best games. Not only does it excel in high-tech games, but it has far more mid-level and simple games than the other two systems combined.

I find that while both Chrome and Linux have some excellent games, Chrome has more. Plus, many Linux games require installing an “engine” before you can play.

Score: Windows 1; Chrome 0; Linux -1
Click to expand...
I concur! I would add only that, not being a true gamer but playing many mid-level games and most of them are Windows games played, mostly, on Wine and one requires Crossover and they all play as native. I like to play Zuma Games and they run perfectly.
 
WHICH IS THE BEST OPERATING SYSTEM?

Part 2 THE INTERNET

It is widely-believed that a Chromebook’s strongest point is that it goes onto the Internet faster, cheaper, safer, and easier that Windows. Critics point out that Windows gives you a wide choice of browsers, but Chrome is better regardless of what browser Windows uses. When we have Mexican kids come over to use our laptops, they usually choose the Chromebook first, because it gets them to Facebook and YouTube better than Windows does. Chrome gets 1 point.

With Linux and Windows 10 on the same machine, I see no difference in speed. So? Linux is safer from malware, so it comes in #2, getting 0 points. Windows does go well on the Internet, but its vulnerability to malware gives it a -1.

Total score?

Chrome 1
Windows 0
Linux -1
 
Last edited:
I might be all wet because I am no longer testing but in the past, I would agree with your placement of windoze and linux but when I Stop Watch Tested the dual booted systems I found IE to be extremely slow on both windoze and linux and Firefox and Chrome ran better than twice as quickly on any linux flavor than on any windoze OS. I can't compare the Chrome OS because I'm nearing the end of my run and will not drain the bank my wife might need.

But, also, as I said, I'm no longer testing and I, also, do very little IT or building these days. This looks like you did a good bit of work to find the info, first hand.
 
Part 3 LEARNING CURVE

I admit that I had done my research first, but when I got my first Chromebook, I got started with no problems. Everything else was easy to figure out, although I did learn some fancy tricks by asking online. 1 point for Chrome.

I was dismayed at the learning curve of Linux, but it was still easier than Windows 10 (and I am an experienced Windows user who writes on Windows forums). But I was able to find online help easily, and I have benefited from downloading a free, well-written book. 0 points for Linux

I can run Windows 10 very well. But there are so many problems that on their forums, most of their solutions don’t work. And in my early days, starting with Windows 3.11, I had a much harder time than I do with Linux. Windows gets a -1.

Total score:

Chrome 2

Linux -1

Windows -1
 
Part 4 BIBLE STUDY

Hey, this is a Christian site, right?

Windows leads the pack, and it isn’t even close. Free programs such as e-Sword are far superior to anything offered by the competition. Even using bookmarks to use online Bible programs are not as good as the free downloads that Windows has. Windows gets 1 point.

Linux is better than Chrome, but I still reject it in favor of Windows. Linux gets a “0.”

I installed the best Chrome Bible program I could find, but it is so unimpressive that I never use it. -1 here, Brethren.

Total score:

Chrome 1

Windows 0

Linux -1
 
Vince said:
Part 4 BIBLE STUDY

Hey, this is a Christian site, right?

Windows leads the pack, and it isn’t even close. Free programs such as e-Sword are far superior to anything offered by the competition. Even using bookmarks to use online Bible programs are not as good as the free downloads that Windows has. Windows gets 1 point.

Linux is better than Chrome, but I still reject it in favor of Windows. Linux gets a “0.”

I installed the best Chrome Bible program I could find, but it is so unimpressive that I never use it. -1 here, Brethren.

Total score:

Chrome 1

Windows 0

Linux -1
Click to expand...
Being a devoted Ubuntu Linux operator I defer to Vince, trusting Vince because I am not testing Chrome. And being an e-Sword devotee, I would be very hard put not to have my favored study program. I suspect the others will, also run on Linux through Wine and/or Crossover. But I have not tested nor have I researched the usability and I might in the future but not now. If one needs to know the documentation is refreshed often and is easily available on line.
 
Part 5 CROSS-PLATFORM COMPATIBILITY

Don’t laugh. As hard drives get bigger and computers get more powerful, virtual machines and partitioning are becoming steadily more common. A growing minority of users have more than one operating system.

And Linux is the undisputed champ! Most Linux users are using a Windows computer, and Linux works fine on them. And although I haven’t tried it, Linux works well on Chromebooks. Installing Linux on a Windows or Chrome machine rarely causes problems.

But install Windows on a Linux machine, and you’ll have to go through a complicated process to re-enable Linux. Putting Windows on a Chromebook is a complicated process, and for a little more money you could have bought a budget Windows laptop.

However, sometimes an older version of Windows can be safely and legally installed on a Windows machine. I have a 32-bit version of Windows XP legally installed on my 64-bit computer, and it runs well.

Chrome cannot be installed on another computer. There is a freeware version of Chrome called chromium that I’m not evaluating here.

Linux gets 1 point, Windows gets a 0, and Chrome gets a -1.


Total Score:
Chrome 0
Linux 0
Windows 0
 
Part 6 PRICE

Pesos don’t grow on cacti, and cost has to be considered.

Linux has a very attractive price:free. It is sometimes better to pay a small price to have someone install Linux for you, but it is still cheaper than Windows.

But someone cries “Foul!” You still have to pay for a computer before you can install Linux. But if you pay for a Linux computer, you must purchase EVERY version of Windows that you add to it. If you pay for a Windows computer, though, you can install several different versions of Linux for free. And while most newer versions of Windows can only be installed on one computer, a thumb drive with Linux can be used on as many different computers as you want.

My desktop has legal copies of XP, 8, and 10 ( in addition to Linux). Only XP can be legally transferred to my next computer, and I am legally required to delete it from my current computer first.

Chrome is free, but you have to buy a Chromebook. It cannot be transferred to another computer. On the other hand, Chromebooks are cheaper than Windows machines.

Linux gets a 1; Chrome gets a 0; and Windows gets a -1.



Total scores:
Linux 1
Chrome 0
Windows -1
 
Vince said:
Part 6 PRICE

Pesos don’t grow on cacti, and cost has to be considered.

Linux has a very attractive price:free. It is sometimes better to pay a small price to have someone install Linux for you, but it is still cheaper than Windows.

But someone cries “Foul!” You still have to pay for a computer before you can install Linux. But if you pay for a Linux computer, you must purchase EVERY version of Windows that you add to it. If you pay for a Windows computer, though, you can install several different versions of Linux for free. And while most newer versions of Windows can only be installed on one computer, a thumb drive with Linux can be used on as many different computers as you want.

My desktop has legal copies of XP, 8, and 10 ( in addition to Linux). Only XP can be legally transferred to my next computer, and I am legally required to delete it from my current computer first.

Chrome is free, but you have to buy a Chromebook. It cannot be transferred to another computer. On the other hand, Chromebooks are cheaper than Windows machines.

Linux gets a 1; Chrome gets a 0; and Windows gets a -1.



Total scores:
Linux 1
Chrome 0
Windows -1
Click to expand...
In all fairness there is the free Windows XP Black. It is not nor has it ever been maintained by MS. From having tested it I know it is maintained by an Independent Group and had some very nice Desk Tops. I, because of my, personal, preference would leave Linux where Vince has it but would be hard put not to place, being specific, Windows XP over Chrome here. The sad thing here is I have better than three thousand dollars of XP Software that is no longer useful to me.

Another good assessment, Vince!
 
Part 7 DOING SERIOUS WORK

The newest version of Linux comes with Libre Office installed. It opens quickly and runs well. And once I figured out how to use Linux’s “Workspace Switcher,” I could easily switch between four desktops, leaving internet on one, and Libre Office on another, making it easier to type up my research.

The same Libre Office opens slowly on Windows 10. (Both operating systems are on the same machine). It does work well. And although I have never done it, Windows is the leader in high-priced and unnecessary word processors.

Chrome opens Googledocs quickly and it works well. It automatically stores my documents in the cloud. But its smaller screen, while still adequate, is not as good as Linux on a large screen.

Linux gets a 1, Chrome gets a 0, and Windows gets a -1.

And so my contest ends with this final score:
Linux 2
Chrome 0
Windows -2
 
The very best OS is Windows XP Pro SP3.. safe and secure with no infections in 5 years, I've been using it from day one.. Linux is O.k. because its free..

*Edit: Oops' i forgot.. IMO
 
i should have added that you can still install XP Pro if you have a paid version but it has to include SP3 or it won't install..
i found one online.. :)
 
turnorburn said:
i should have added that you can still install XP Pro if you have a paid version but it has to include SP3 or it won't install..
i found one online.. :)
Click to expand...
For people that refuse to move forward, and they can for a short while yet, there is XP Pro Black available, free, online that is not supported by MS but as UEFI is becoming stock, replacing BIOS, all of us will change or operate dinosaurs that will never run the software needed to keep the functional.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top