Former Christian
Member
Jethro Bodine
I don’t usually quote an entire post. But in this case, I made an exception. I want people to read it again and see exactly where you’re coming from.
You say,
But you qualify that with,
Twice,
It’s just like the Catholics who think they’re the “True Churchâ€. Like the Eastern Orthodox who think they’re the only ones who are “truly orthodoxâ€. Like the Jehovah’s Witnesses who think they’re the “true organization of Godâ€. Like the Churches of Christ who think they’re the “true restoration of the first century Churchâ€. Like the Recovery Churches of Witness Lee who think they’re the “true recovery of Christianity todayâ€.
It’s like the Lutherans, Reformed, Presbyterians, Baptists, and a myriad of other Protestant denominations who have chosen to follow a long standing historic practice in Christianity, also practiced by Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, and don’t leave out the Evangelical Protestants. The practice of closed communion against everyone else for the sin of doctrinal disagreement. Those that claim not to practice closed communion, practice shunning, which amounts to the same thing.
I realize you can’t even include me among the honest doubters. But you can number yourself as an example of why I am what I am.
I won’t go so far as to call you an apostate, or Satanic. I won’t even say you’re not a Christian. I will say that you’re very denominational in your thinking. That I don’t believe in your religion. I believe in the unity of all Christians in Christ and by the Spirit. Not unity in a private club that refers to hemselves as “true Christiansâ€. Sorry. I am one who won’t be coming together over you.
NC
Originally Posted by Former Christian
In the bible, an apostate would describe one who has left following God, left following Jesus Christ. Today, it just means someone who disagrees with the doctrines of a particular denomination.
It may certainly be misused that way. But among us true Christians it is understood to mean someone who has departed faith in Jesus Christ altogether. It does not mean the honest doubter still clinging to the forgiveness of sins they have received through Christ. It does not mean the saint struggling with temptations. It means the person who has rejected faith in the forgiveness of Christ altogether, usually signified by their return to their old life, and of course their own confession of having rejected the gospel of Christ's forgiveness.
Originally Posted by Former Christian
To Evangelical Protestants, Roman Catholicism and Jehovah’s Witnesses are apostates. To Roman Catholics, all other denominations are the apostates, and need to come back to truly following Christ through the true Church. The Jehovah’s Witnesses see “Christendom†in a similar light.
Now measure each one of these by what I just said. Only Jehovah's Witnesses are wholly suspect as to whether or not they truly teach salvation through the forgiveness of sins, apart from works, by the blood of Christ (I'm not ready just yet to put Catholicism into the 'wholly' category).
And even then, you will probably find young misguided souls among them who just haven't learned enough yet to know J.W.'s probably don't line up real well with the gospel I just described. If they really belong to God, He will lead them out from them and into a proper fellowship...unless they choose to become apostate.
Originally Posted by Former Christian
According to the definition using 1 Timothy 4:1, all deemed apostate are also deemed Satanic. Which would make all of Christianity Satanic, depending who you talked to.
Or maybe it depends on which Christians are actually adhering to those 'doctrines of demons'? I am a Christian not ashamed of that name (as Peter exhorts us to be) and I do not believe, or adhere to those doctrines of demons. You can't broad stroke all Christians into that category. It's impossible to decide one can not be called a Christian anymore because of doctrines of demons when there are still real Christians in the world who do not follow doctrines of demons.
You have to get out of the church of the world (the major denominations in Christianity, generally speaking of course) to know there is still true Christianity, and that there are still true Christians in the world today. Don't throw it to the dogs just yet.
I don’t usually quote an entire post. But in this case, I made an exception. I want people to read it again and see exactly where you’re coming from.
You say,
I am a Christian not ashamed of that name (as Peter exhorts us to be)
But you qualify that with,
among us true Christians
Twice,
You have to get out of the church of the world (the major denominations in Christianity, generally speaking of course) to know there is still true Christianity, and that there are still true Christians in the world today.
It’s just like the Catholics who think they’re the “True Churchâ€. Like the Eastern Orthodox who think they’re the only ones who are “truly orthodoxâ€. Like the Jehovah’s Witnesses who think they’re the “true organization of Godâ€. Like the Churches of Christ who think they’re the “true restoration of the first century Churchâ€. Like the Recovery Churches of Witness Lee who think they’re the “true recovery of Christianity todayâ€.
It’s like the Lutherans, Reformed, Presbyterians, Baptists, and a myriad of other Protestant denominations who have chosen to follow a long standing historic practice in Christianity, also practiced by Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, and don’t leave out the Evangelical Protestants. The practice of closed communion against everyone else for the sin of doctrinal disagreement. Those that claim not to practice closed communion, practice shunning, which amounts to the same thing.
I realize you can’t even include me among the honest doubters. But you can number yourself as an example of why I am what I am.
I won’t go so far as to call you an apostate, or Satanic. I won’t even say you’re not a Christian. I will say that you’re very denominational in your thinking. That I don’t believe in your religion. I believe in the unity of all Christians in Christ and by the Spirit. Not unity in a private club that refers to hemselves as “true Christiansâ€. Sorry. I am one who won’t be coming together over you.
NC