I didn't argue anything from a theological point, and I didn't attack young earth creationism. I just pointed out that the website makes several errors on the process of carbon dating and I pointed out to Hammer that he was in error about radiometric dating methods.
If by open minded you mean I'm not aloud to point out something as simple as to why Dinosaur bones aren't tested with carbon dating in the first place, then what am I supposed to do when I see someone post simple scientific misconceptions?