john darling
Member
I believe God will answer all prayers of the believer and to say God will not answer such prayers accuses God a liar. Maybe I've missed something?
There is the possibility that we are misunderstanding each other in that I am suggesting that God always gives an answer to prayer, even if the answer is to not answer. Suggesting that God "ignores" a prayer request implies that he does not care. I do not believe this at all. I believe God deeply cares about our desires and feelings, but it is precisely because he knows what is best for us far more than we ourselves that he chooses not to answer some prayers. However, since the end result is the same, it becomes a distinction without a difference to ask, "did god just not answer the prayer or did he ignore it".
I believe that to invoke the name of Jesus is more than just uttering the name. It involves a trust and faith in Him. Have you any Scripture references that record God not answering prayers from a believer? And by "not answering prayers" I'm talking about God ignoring or turning His back to the petitioner.
Before I get to the example you asked for, I'd like to comment on your very interesting phrasing of "turning his back on the petitioner" because I believe it encapsulates exactly a point which I feel is significant about prayer. Your question, the way you've phrased it, is basically asking, if God, a loving God, dared not to answer a prayer request would it equate to God becoming unloving by "turning his back" on the poor petitioner? The implication seems to be that, yes, he would not only become unloving, but a liar if he chose not to answer a prayer. In other words, God is not allowed to say no without becoming the bad guy.
But is that really consistent with what Jesus said? Is God a liar if he doesn't answer every single prayer? Perhaps there is some confusion because there are two seperate (yet similar) issues here. There is the "belief" part and then there is the question of whether or not God has the right to not answer a prayer request (despite the petitioners belief). First, the belief issue. If we're asking for something which is not consistent with what God wants then it will not matter how strong our faith. I have more to share about possible exceptions to this conclusion but I won't go into that right now.
Next, the "right to say no" issue. More than one person on this thread has already made mention of the clause "according to thy will" in the context of prayer but you don't reference it at all in your questions and conclusions. Instead, you talk of throwing mountains into the sea and withering trees. I'm fine to consider the possibility that God could allow an individual the opportunity to excercise their own wisdom in deciding when such drastic measures may be necessary, but by the time someone reaches the point when they have the wisdom to decide when it's necessary to throw a mountain into the sea they would have learned that God is the boss and he has a right to say no.
The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom, but one wonders if it really is a godly, wisdom-creating fear which causes a person to conclude that God would be a liar if he chose to say no to one of his creations. It is part of "counting the cost" (Luke 14:28) to understand that God is the boss. As Christians we really need to get this clear; before he is a loving God he is a sovreign God. He has the right to tell us to kill our own children and we would be wrong to disobey (Gen 22:2).
Now, for the example you asked for. "Let this cup pass from me, but not my will, your will". Regarding his sacrificial death on the cross Jesus prayed this three times (matthew 26:39-42). In the end we know that Jesus' prayer was not answered but that's okay because he was willing to hear "no". He told the disciples that he could call down legions of angels to save himself if he wanted, but again he chose to hear "no" despite having the faith to make it happen. He understood that his prayer was not consistent with God's will for him.
Personally, I don't think Jesus was upset about the physical torture so much as he was about the prospect of taking on sin, which meant God would, indeed, "turn his back" on him, which is why Jesus cried out, "my God why have you forsaken me". That severed connection is what caused him so much anxiety that he sweat blood (Luke 22:44).