Then, if you had died between the time you were "acting entirely by faith in the conviction of the Holy Spirit" and the time you "were justified", would you be in Hell?
Correct.
I had not put my trust in the forgiveness of God yet. Believing that Jesus is a real person, and is even the Son of God, and all these things about Him and the Christian religion are true is not the 'faith' that saves. If that were true, the demons would be saved because they know the truth about the facts of Christianity better than any human. But they do not believe and trust in the blood of Christ for the forgiveness of sins. Their 'faith' can not save them. And that kind of faith will not save you or I either, even if it does get us up out of bed every Sunday to go to church. But a lot of people think that is true.
I know you feel that you weren't saved even though you had faith that acted "entirely by faith in the conviction of the Holy Spirit", but I can't see where this is taught in Scripture. I don't see a two tier faith, one salvific, one not.
This seems to me to be a private revelation.
No. As I pointed out above, James talks about the 'faith' of demons who obviously are not saved by what they
know and believe with certainty to be true about Jesus being the Christ.
The belief, the faith that saves is the faith that Christ's blood has been applied to your sins and you will pass through the judgment safetly. That kind of faith, the faith that saves, faith and trust in the blood of Christ, is evidenced by what it does--namely "love your neighbor as yourself", for when we show the love of God to others we are justified as having already received the love of God in the forgiveness of sins ourselves.
This is not being justified as to being
made righteous. It is being justified in regard to being
shown to have been made righteous by faith in Jesus' blood apart from the merit of works to solicit it. That is why James is teaching it. So that people who think a profession of faith in God that can't be seen in godly love for others is a faith that can save can seek to truly believe in the blood of Christ and not just trust in believing in facts about Christ (facts the demons know and believe are true better than us). The faith that saves changes us into people who love like God loves. That's why love is the signature of saving faith in Christ--the faith that saves all by itself apart from the merit of works. James wants us all to make sure we really have the faith that saves.
We are made righteous by what we believe about the forgiveness of sins through Jesus Christ. We are shown to have that righteousness by what we do, namely when we love others the way God loves.
We are made righteous through the blood of Christ when we believe and trust in that blood. We are shown to have been made righteous (through the blood of Christ, all by itself) by the life of an ever-increasing display of the fruit of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, patience, etc.), not by the doctrines we hold dear, or our faithfulness to external worship procedures and timetables.
Anybody can do that. But it is only the person who has received the forgiveness of God in Christ who grows up into the stature of Christ as seen in the fruit of the Spirit, specifically love, that shows he has the free gift of righteousness through the blood of Christ. That is what James 2 is all about. It is
not a proof text to prove that you have to be water baptized to be saved (or take communion, or be confirmed, or be circumcised, etc.).
"...I will show you my faith by what I do." (James 2:18 NIV1984)
Then this whole chapter is about persevering in faith that doesn't save? Isn't this your contention, that the faith mentioned in Heb. 11 is not a faith that justifies? I agree that the chapter is also about persevering, but it wouldn't make sense for Scripture to teach us to persevere in faith that doesn't justify, would it?
Like I said, I do not know at which point any one person in Hebrews 11 was justified by the faith they had in God's promise of a son made to Abraham. I would be going beyond what is written to say that I do know.
What I do know is they are examples of faith for us to be strenghtened by about staying the course and persevering in our faith in the blood of Christ, the reward of which we will not see in this life, just as the people of faith in Hebrews 11 did not see the (full) reward in this life of their faith for what they were believing in.