• Love God, and love one another!

    Share your heart for Christ and others in Godly Love

    https://christianforums.net/forums/god_love/

  • Wake up and smell the coffee!

    Join us for a little humor in Joy of the Lord

    https://christianforums.net/forums/humor_and_jokes/

  • Want to discuss private matters, or make a few friends?

    Ask for membership to the Men's or Lady's Locker Rooms

    For access, please contact a member of staff and they can add you in!

  • Need prayer and encouragement?

    Come share your heart's concerns in the Prayer Forum

    https://christianforums.net/forums/prayer/

  • Desire to be a vessel of honor unto the Lord Jesus Christ?

    Join Hidden in Him and For His Glory for discussions on how

    https://christianforums.net/threads/become-a-vessel-of-honor-part-2.112306/

  • Have questions about the Christian faith?

    Come ask us what's on your mind in Questions and Answers

    https://christianforums.net/forums/questions-and-answers/

  • CFN has a new look and a new theme

    "I bore you on eagle's wings, and brought you to Myself" (Exodus 19:4)

    More new themes coming in the future!

  • Read the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ?

    Read through this brief blog, and receive eternal salvation as the free gift of God

    /blog/the-gospel

  • Focus on the Family

    Strengthening families through biblical principles.

    Focus on the Family addresses the use of biblical principles in parenting and marriage to strengthen the family.

Does man have authority to forgive sins?

I just asked "The Google" and got this (in part) as a reply:
Who Can Forgive Sins? by Dr. Max D. Younce,
He's a Pastor at Heritage Baptist Bible Church (according to the first page). So I skimmed the article and didn't any doctrinal or moral errors. Hope it edifies!
 
Sorry Mike, but this is to convoluted for me to follow. What is it exactly you are having a problem with?
 
I just asked "The Google" and got this (in part) as a reply:
Who Can Forgive Sins? by Dr. Max D. Younce,
He's a Pastor at Heritage Baptist Bible Church (according to the first page). So I skimmed the article and didn't any doctrinal or moral errors. Hope it edifies!

Thank you for sharing, I read through the whole thing. He never mentioned James though. He mentioned a whole lot about absolving people of sins that only Jesus could do. More against Catholics and Lutherans.

https://bible.org/seriespage/12-authority-forgive-sins-matthew-91-8
Now this will raise a fundamental theological issue that will have to be dealt with somewhere in the study, probably when Jesus is speaking to the teachers of the Law. What is the connection between healing and forgiving, or, more basically, what is the connection between sickness, disease, and death, and sin? This could become a rather involved study, but one that you need to do sometime. Good biblical theologies will provide you with basic discussions on the subject.

In sum, the Bible teaches that all sickness, disease, pain, contamination, pollution, and death is the result of the presence of sin in the world. In the beginning when sin entered the world and the curse was announced as the natural result of rebellion against the living God, the world and the human race was from that point contaminated. Death and dying now reign where life was created. And all sickness and disease, physical or mental, is part of this dying. The human existence is characterized by pain, conflict, disease and death
.

This is more in line with what I was talking about. Sin(s) that have gave entrance to destruction in someone's life. To be healed, the sin can't be there under the curse.

This is not talking about eternal life, that is one sin of not accepting Jesus as Lord.
 
You're very welcome, Brother Mike. But you should intro me to your friend here -OR- I could just toss the formality (like we always do) and introduce myself.

Greetings, StanJ. I'm a grandpa that loves this forum and I understand that you're a pastor? Very nice to meet you and I'll look forward to lurking and hearing what you have to say some more. It's getting time for me to pick up my grandsons from school so I gotta do a hit-and-run.

~Sparrow
 
I just asked "The Google" and got this (in part) as a reply:
Who Can Forgive Sins? by Dr. Max D. Younce,
He's a Pastor at Heritage Baptist Bible Church (according to the first page). So I skimmed the article and didn't any doctrinal or moral errors. Hope it edifies!

I did read through it and have no problems with his POV, but he is either naïve or deliberately missing what he should know about James 5:16 (NIV) and doesn't really properly exegete John 20:23 other than to deny it's application to the RCC doctrine of confession. I didn't see anyone here expressing that application either. I therefore have to disagree with his conclusion on this link.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You're very welcome, Brother Mike. But you should intro me to your friend here -OR- I could just toss the formality (like we always do) and introduce myself.

Greetings, StanJ. I'm a grandpa that loves this forum and I understand that you're a pastor? Very nice to meet you and I'll look forward to lurking and hearing what you have to say some more. It's getting time for me to pick up my grandsons from school so I gotta do a hit-and-run.
~Sparrow

Thanks Sparrow. I am a Papa as well, and now have 5 with another girl on the way. That will make 4 girls and two boys!!!
LOL...no I am NOT a pastor, so I'm not sure where you got that impression?
So you're a lurker? Not me...I get right in there IF I have something to say.
Puleezah, don't hit, just pick and run. :wink
 
You're very welcome, Brother Mike. But you should intro me to your friend here -OR- I could just toss the formality (like we always do) and introduce myself.

Greetings, StanJ. I'm a grandpa that loves this forum and I understand that you're a pastor? Very nice to meet you and I'll look forward to lurking and hearing what you have to say some more. It's getting time for me to pick up my grandsons from school so I gotta do a hit-and-run.

~Sparrow

Sorry Sparrow, I was Rude. StanJ is a new member here that seems to really want to be part of the community. We are thankful for him.

My take is that when Mentioned "Sins" And Jesus connection with Sin and healing it brings me to the curse of the Law by which all sickness came.
To say God might not want you well, is to say God is also OK with with the root of what caused you not to be well, and that is disobedience. (Isa 28)

So, going to God and asking Him to have mercy on someone not saved who is being destroyed by the curse and the devil having a place so that they can have time to get things right. Is something I believe as part of the Body of Christ is what we should be doing.

It's based on my understanding of the Curse, Sickness, giving the devil a place, and what disobedience brings.

Has nothing to do with imparting eternal life on anyone.

blessings, glad to see you posting.

Mike.
 
Your a Pastor at a church, I am working with you and you and

LOL...no I am NOT a pastor, so I'm not sure where you got that impression?
So you're a lurker? Not me...I get right in there IF I have something to say.
Puleezah, don't hit, just pick and run. :wink

Pastor StanJ (congrats on your promotion - but if you're a grandpa and Christ follower - you're automatically an honorary Pastor, right?) But to answer your question - it was my mouse scroll wheel that caused me to buzz by so quickly that I formed a quick impression. That's why I asked for an introduction - because of the title (also because you're fun to talk to, of course).
Sorry Sparrow, I was Rude. StanJ is a new member here that seems to really want to be part of the community. We are thankful for him.
it's the internet. it would be weird if our old fashioned rules still applied.
My take is...
So it seems like you have the position that is the least enviable, the underdog, so to speak. You're defending the "We can forgive sin," side. Okay, I'll try to put my two Berean cents in: :twocents
 
Brother Mike, remember what you said earlier about who really does the forgiving? :)

I'm not sure when you say we can forgive sin if you actually mean we can prey to God to forgive others or you are actually saying we have the power to forgive sin ourselves other than to those who sin against us?

Are we just miscommunicating or are you back to saying humans can forgive any one who asks/has faith, just as God and Jesus can?
 
That was easy (whew). My two cents, that is. Here it is again: :twocents

But here's a little more. I was on my way to pick up the grandkids at their bus stop and when I got there I saw my son standing dutifully and watching for the bus. Huh? I thought he wanted the grandpa babysitter?!? But his friend had injured himself and he had just canceled plans and got home just in time to pick them up but also while I am driving you can't get me on the cell. That did give a chance to discuss the subject pretty well. Can we forgive sins??

I started by mentioning the sandal and dust and how we are given authority in this. Seems pretty clear that we can retain sins but I don't think it would be forever. I'm not sure what God plans for all these things and I dare not say what has not been given but that's the start that I used when I presented the question to my son. So then, and from there, the idea is that if we are equipped to do that? To take off our sandals and remove the dust from our feet? And since we know that God is good and that he is reluctant to punish, taking no joy in such things... well... it follows (maybe) that the compliment to that authority is also ours.

But that is a long way short of coming up with Scriptural proof of the premise. We looked at James and saw what he said with the full authority and unction of the Holy Spirit and concluded that the Word of God that "he which converteth the sinner from the error of his way," is a very specific circumstance. We know that angels rejoice at the covering of sins and that happens at the time of salvation -- and we understand from James that God is at least willing to share some of that by saying here that if any convert they are at least given credit for being part of that covering -- but this too doesn't quite (yet) satisfy as authority. Also, I take note that James was talking about a brother who had backslidden. Our conclusion is that this is a little more difficult than a simple yes or no (apologies to Deborah13 but she knows that it's okay and that there is no risk to take a Berean (noble) approach and try to prove stuff). This is not a "yes" or "no" thing, again, not IMO.

So from the premise that God is Good and given that we do have authority to do the sandal/dust thing (go ahead and give that more scrutiny - I like it when we join in purpose even if the outcome that I support, at the moment, isn't established) --but given that, it is reasonable to think that we would also be able to forgive. Like others have said, certainly we are told to and commanded to forgive those who trespass against us. But that wasn't the new ground we were looking for.

From there the idea developed that we are already joined into the ministry of Christ. There is a call to our hearts in an Isaiah68 way. We are in the ministry of reconciliation by default. That's what is being done and that's what we hope to do. But, and again, my reasoning doesn't quite satisfy. Or in other words, I feel like I'm getting closer to the truth of the matter here (or rather, that my son and I were) but there's still something missing. The slave in the household does not know what the master is doing -- but we are (or are called to be) friends to the master of the house.

Oh! Now I think I might know what the missing part is. And I don't mean to change the subject and I know already that what I'm about to say is controversial (maybe even more so than the presumption of forgiving sin authoritatively - after all, that's what our Jesus got killed for, at least in part - making himself equal with God)... but here goes. Jesus asked that we might be one with the Father even as He is.

And after the first warning, comes another. Meat is not for those just weaned. Take a moment to pray before you contend with me and know that I am putting myself and my deep parts out there and I really don't want to get smacked in the head for doing that -- I've taken pains to trace and then report the trail of thinking. I'm trying to prove what another brother has heard in his spirit as true. At least acknowledge the effort is for a good cause, right? But there is a time that is coming... and is not yet.

Paul tells us to prophecy. He makes no bones about it and says that he wants us all to prophecy for the sake of edification. Paul told us to prophecy because we edify that way. Everbody in the body of Christ. All. But how can that be? Should we all try to tell horoscopes and make up fortunes and stuff like, "You have amazing kindness that flows from within you. Everyone who's experienced it is grateful for you." Is that what Paul meant? No.

We are to boldly go to the Throne of Grace. WE are to live and dwell and remain in Christ and He in us. That's where we are called to, that's why we left our own and forsook all others and that's the whole enchilada. And we're to do that so much that we become more and more like Him. That's what is ours as an inheritance. But have I done this? Frankly no. I have continuously sinned in one way (certain ways more than others) and in other ways also and have never put on that garment that was purchased for me. You know. That white wedding garment which is the righteousness of Christ. I'm in danger of falling (failing?) due to lack of discipline in a 1 Corinthians 9:27 way - and I know that I am slave to the master to whom I submit my members to. There is no "spotless" and pure part of me because of the utterly sinful nature of sin which remains in me. Quick attempt to support would be the admonishment to run the race with the idea of crossing the finish line. So if that's the idea, don't bash me for having it. It came from a good place. Also recall that Paul asked thrice regarding a thorn but was told to satisfy and content himself with the Grace given. But he never said, "Golly, I should not have asked to be perfected... and neither should you." Again we are commanded to run with the finish line instead. Okay - I can't do better than that without going way off tract. Enuf said.

But if that were different and if I were now in the place where we are all called to - in communion with Jesus, and not just like I am right now but constantly and if somebody came and said, "Master, I see that you are a man of God, and I do need forgiveness... What should I do?" Should I take a moment and then rely on the Holy Spirit in me for the answer? But wait, I can almost hear some say... We are told that there will be tremendous deception such that even the very elect would believe the lie - save that God won't let that happen and will cut the time short -- So even this moment, I am to be caution in my proclamation.

You've heard of the patience of the saints? What if we could save? What if our relationship with our Father was so mature and established and what if we were to operate the Gift of Prophecy and what if we were told to be bold and to speak as Oracles, and what if we understood the heart and the mind of God? Well? No man can see the face of God (and live) but what if we had died to sin. It is given man once to die. Once. My answer?

I dunno. Sorry, but I'm not there and am not qualified to answer. If somebody asked for my forgiveness of their sin against God I think I would be more than willing to go with them to Him and to ask for them to say the amen -- and then God would forgive. That's the best I could come up with but I am very willing to hear and think and pray about other responses.

Thanks for letting me share this with you. I'll keeping seeking.

~Sparrow
 
Last edited:
So it seems like you have the position that is the least enviable, the underdog, so to speak. You're defending the "We can forgive sin," side. Okay, I'll try to put my two Berean cents in:

I would add being led first, and asking the Lord to have Mercy and forgive them. To give a person some time to get things right. Paul did not forgive a believer, but turned him over to Satan under the direction of the Lord Jesus.

You can't use the term "Be Forgiven" around here and not have it be misunderstood.
 
I dunno. Sorry, but I'm not there and am not qualified to answer. If somebody asked for my forgiveness of their sin against God I think I would be more than willing to go with them to Him and to ask for them to say the amen -- and then God would forgive. That's the best I could come up with but I am very willing to hear and think and pray about other responses.

Well, good luck with that happening if your not a Catholic priest. Sin brings sickness and poverty all kinds of mess. Going to God on their behalf and asking the Lord to forgive them (Remove the harvest due) Give them time Lord. is more what I had in mind.

Brother Mike, remember what you said earlier about who really does the forgiving? :)

I'm not sure when you say we can forgive sin if you actually mean we can prey to God to forgive others or you are actually saying we have the power to forgive sin ourselves other than to those who sin against us?

Are we just miscommunicating or are you back to saying humans can forgive any one who asks/has faith, just as God and Jesus can?

The Anointing and power is given to us to go to God, and ask for mercy and to forgive them.
Jesus said, whosoever sins you remit are remitted. We do the asking part, not the remitting part.

Jesus also said I give you power over serpents and scorpions. The spirits are subject unto us. He said. Without the Holy Spirit and the power there, we don't have any authority.

Jesus said without me, ye can do nothing. I am pretty sure Nothing, meant everything.

be blessed.
 
Okay, Mike. I gotta remember that I am speaking to a Peter like fellow who enjoys speaking bluntly. That's not a problem. How about this. If I were operating fully in the Gift of Prophecy (even today) I would not hesitate to do what I was given to do even if others objected including and not limited to saying, "You are indeed forgiven."

LOL - at me because I (again) misunderstood and thought that I was supporting your position. I do agree without reservation that IF we see a brother sinning (not a sin that leads to death) we are to ask and God gives life. That's gospel (even if it was found in an epistle, but you know what I mean). That's the good news we all know (more milk than meat though, I'd say).
 
Man does NOT have the authority to forgive sins. The Jews (who were enemies of Christ, and regarded Him as a renegade rabbi) help us to understand this clearly. When Christ publicly forgave people their sins, they questioned that for the very reason that only God can forgive sins. They believed He was usurping God's authority.

The authority given to the apostles in dealing with sins was not a matter of the ability to forgive sins as God does, but how they should be dealt with, once they manifested themselves. And regarding the passage in James, the Greek word means "faults" not "sins". That has been deliberately mutilated to conform to the erroneous Catholic belief that sinful men can forgive other sinful men in the same manner as God does.

As regards those who wrong us personally, yes we have the CAPACITY to forgive those wrongs, but not the AUTHORITY of God to forgive as God forgives.
 
Paul did not forgive a believer, but turned him over to Satan under the direction of the Lord Jesus.

I'm not certain that I would call a person who continued in fornication a "believer" and think that a better term might be a person in attendance at the church in Corinth. Is there forgiveness without repentance? No. So you example doesn't stand up to scrutiny if we look in a very precise and legalistic way. Paul told the church that HE established and worked in as directed by God that they were to kick that guy out -- and part of that was a teaching thing for us too.
Man does NOT have the authority to forgive sins.
So let me ask you. Was Jesus a man? Yes or no, please.

Please also remember that I am still trying to prove something in a noble fashion and that it's difficult for me to turn on a dime. I'm on this train of thought although I honestly believe that it would be very, very presumptuous UNLESS it was directly given to us by God. I am not perfected (mature). I know of nobody who is. If we ever do get to that place then (and only then) may we speak dogmatically on this subject. Neither of us are so it's better to say simply that we may only if God wants us to. In other words, we know that we have all that we ask because we ask according to the will of God. Now the caveat and the problem with this whole line of reasoning is that nobody is there (yet).

Consider though that it has not even entered into our minds what God has planned for those that love Him. He will give (and has promised to give) exceedingly and abundantly above and beyond our petitions. But if you were to bluntly ask me if I have asked for the power and authority to forgive sin? No. I have not and I don't plan on doing that. Ever. Okay?
 
Also this is the LOUNGE on the forum. I'm allowed to speak informally here more so that I would in the Apologetics and Theology forum. That's pretty much why I feel there is liberty to talk frankly. It is my assumption that I'm among friends.
 
So let me ask you. Was Jesus a man? Yes or no, please.
Jesus, unlike any other man who has ever lived on earth, was FULLY GOD and FULLY MAN at the same time -- "God manifest in the flesh" (1 Tim 3:16). I trust that answers your question. If that is a mystery, then that is exacly what it is. It is called "the Mystery of Godliness".
 
And regarding the passage in James, the Greek word means "faults" not "sins". That has been deliberately mutilated to conform to the erroneous Catholic belief that sinful men can forgive other sinful men in the same manner as God does.
As regards those who wrong us personally, yes we have the CAPACITY to forgive those wrongs, but not the AUTHORITY of God to forgive as God forgives.

Ahh, the Italian prophet. Hi Malawchi.

Seriously now, the Greek word hamartia connotes sin or offence. I disagree it has been mutilated but we all know, or at least should, that not all words have the same meaning throughout scripture. I agree with you, as I originally stated, that the forgiveness of sin here only relates to how it was directed at and against us. If we forgive that sin, so does God and if we don't, neither does God.

Ciao!
 
Back
Top