Featherbop
Member
I just read the first three chapters in genesis, and found some things that are problematic, confusing, contradictory, and just plain bizarre among other things. Thought I would ask what others think of some of these things. I will stick close to chronological order:
Genesis 1:4-god divided the light from the darkness
Genesis 1:5-god calls the light day and the darkness night
Problematic: Genesis 1:16-god makes the greater light to rule the day and the lesser light to rule the night. The only way I see a problem can be avoided here is that this does not refer to the sun and moon. If it does, then light existed for the earth without the sun before this. Also, the moon does not emit light of itself, but if this verse is a reference to the moon, it is called a light.
=========
Genesis 1:11-12-god creates plants.
Problematic: god creates the sun later.
Interesting: These verses indicate that the earth brought forth plants, which would be god using abiogenesis to create life.
=========
Genesis 1:20-21-god says for the waters to bring forth living creatures and fowls.
Interesting: This verse also indicates god using abiogenesis
Bizarre: Why did fowls emerge from the water? (Edit: It seems this is also worded sometimes as just mentioning the fowls but not saying they emerged from the water, in which case, it wouldn't be bizarre)
=========
Genesis 1:24-god says for the earth to bring forth life. This is another instance of abiogenesis.
=========
Genesis 2:17-god says that Adam will surely die the day he eats of the eats of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. However, later in the story, he eats the fruit of that tree and yet lives.
Problematic: If this is literal, god did not know what he was talking about, or lying. If god meant that Adam would die spiritually if he ate of that tree, then that was not literal, as god never mentions a spiritual death. And thus this would then seem to indicate that this is not literal but metaphorical.
=========
Genesis 3:8-says that Adam and Eve heard the voice of god walking in the garden and so they hid. I thought this was odd. If god is a spirit, why is he walking? And also, why is he talking to himself? (Edit: It seems this is also sometimes worded as they heard the sound of god walking in the garden, in which case it isn't strange)
Genesis 3:14-god curses the serpent to eat dust the rest of its days. Snakes do not eat dust.
Genesis 1:4-god divided the light from the darkness
Genesis 1:5-god calls the light day and the darkness night
Problematic: Genesis 1:16-god makes the greater light to rule the day and the lesser light to rule the night. The only way I see a problem can be avoided here is that this does not refer to the sun and moon. If it does, then light existed for the earth without the sun before this. Also, the moon does not emit light of itself, but if this verse is a reference to the moon, it is called a light.
=========
Genesis 1:11-12-god creates plants.
Problematic: god creates the sun later.
Interesting: These verses indicate that the earth brought forth plants, which would be god using abiogenesis to create life.
=========
Genesis 1:20-21-god says for the waters to bring forth living creatures and fowls.
Interesting: This verse also indicates god using abiogenesis
Bizarre: Why did fowls emerge from the water? (Edit: It seems this is also worded sometimes as just mentioning the fowls but not saying they emerged from the water, in which case, it wouldn't be bizarre)
=========
Genesis 1:24-god says for the earth to bring forth life. This is another instance of abiogenesis.
=========
Genesis 2:17-god says that Adam will surely die the day he eats of the eats of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. However, later in the story, he eats the fruit of that tree and yet lives.
Problematic: If this is literal, god did not know what he was talking about, or lying. If god meant that Adam would die spiritually if he ate of that tree, then that was not literal, as god never mentions a spiritual death. And thus this would then seem to indicate that this is not literal but metaphorical.
=========
Genesis 3:8-says that Adam and Eve heard the voice of god walking in the garden and so they hid. I thought this was odd. If god is a spirit, why is he walking? And also, why is he talking to himself? (Edit: It seems this is also sometimes worded as they heard the sound of god walking in the garden, in which case it isn't strange)
Genesis 3:14-god curses the serpent to eat dust the rest of its days. Snakes do not eat dust.