Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • Are you taking the time to pray? Christ is the answer in times of need

    https://christianforums.net/threads/psalm-70-1-save-me-o-god-lord-help-me-now.108509/

  • The Gospel of Jesus Christ

    Heard of "The Gospel"? Want to know more?

    There is salvation in no other, for there is not another name under heaven having been given among men, by which it behooves us to be saved."

  • Looking to grow in the word of God more?

    See our Bible Studies and Devotionals sections in Christian Growth

  • Focus on the Family

    Strengthening families through biblical principles.

    Focus on the Family addresses the use of biblical principles in parenting and marriage to strengthen the family.

  • Have questions about the Christian faith?

    Come ask us what's on your mind in Questions and Answers

  • Wearing the right shoes, and properly clothed spiritually?

    Join Elected By Him for a devotional on Ephesians 6:14-15

    https://christianforums.net/threads/devotional-selecting-the-proper-shoes.109094/

Here's a curious question....

On reddit, there was a user who made a post about asking God to wipe him/her from existence/consciousness after he/she did all he/she was supposed to do to be saved from eternal torment. Basically, he/she accepted Christ as his personal savior, but his/her plan is to ask God to return him/her back into a state of nonexistence now that the infinite debt of sin has been paid.

What perked my ears was the fact that almost all of the comments said that he/she deserved eternal darkness in conscious torment forever, comparing the desire to simply not exist to Satan's tyrannical desire to overtake God's Kingdom and rule and own the universe as his own, since he wanted to be God. There were several other users on Quora as well who did this.

So, this begs the question: HOW and WHY is the mere desire to not exist at all tantamount to someone with the narcissistic and egomanical desire to try to overtake somebody else's place, let alone their universe??? The person who doesn't want to exist at all forever doesn't want a thing from ANYBODY. They have absolutely NO interest in taking over anything or ruling anyone's life. They're not hurting anybody.

And it's interesting that while comparing the desire to choose nonexistence over eternal existence to the bold, arrogant desire of Lucifer to overthrow God, NONE of those people applied the same paradigm to people on Earth who lie, cheat, steal, rape, murder, etc. THOSE acts, just like Satan's attempt at overthrowing God, also play God, disrespect Him, destroy and ruin His creation and make life for everyone and everything living on Earth a living hell. Why isn't anyone saying "Are you God? Who said you have a choice over that?"

And we all know why: free will. So shouldn't the same apply to the choice between existing and not existing? Who is the person hurting or insulting? Also, theoretically, since the person never existed, they therefore wouldn't have been born in sin, wouldn't freely choose to sin, wouldn't need to be held accountable, and thus, no need for a Savior.

Their responses give the implication that simply the mere act of not wanting to exist in the first place is in of itself, a great evil for two reasons: 1. Since God created the soul, He intended for said soul to exist forever, so understandably, going against that design would be considered going against His will. 2. One could conclude that such an individual would only want such a thing if he/she simply wants to escape accountability for a lifetime of sin or avoid punishment.

They have a point, but there's a third alternative to consider: It could be that the person quite simply DOESN'T want Christ. They don't want to spend eternity in Hell not only due to the inevitable fellowhsip with some of the worst, most depraved, wicked people to have ever disgraced the Earth, but also other less discussed reasons such as a perpetually worsening spiritual and moral state and the obvious fact that nobody in their right mind would want to spend all of eternity in total darkness, loneliness, pain and misery with thoughts and a conscience that torment you (and not simply just because they want to escape punishment or accountability).

At the same time, the person...just doesn't want Christ.....it has nothing to do with sin, because there's plenty of sinners who DO want to spend eternity with God. They just don't have a desire or a passion to serve Christ for its own sake. Inevitably, they'll only want to come to Him if it's to avoid the alternative: Hell. And I'm NOT going to do that. You either want Him or you just don't. Bottom line.

So it begs another question: why are people like us here? Why are we here? The fact that there are only two eternal destinations after death and the fact that there's people who don't want God but are not necessarily evil in the truest sense of the word has solidified my belief (which in turn highlights Jesus' point when He said of Judas 'It would have been better if that man had never been born') that people like us should've never entered into existence.

That way, we wouldn't have a thing to complain or worry about. Know existence, know sin, know accountability. No existence, no sin, no accountability.
 
but his/her plan is to ask God to return him/her back into a state of nonexistence now that the infinite debt of sin has been paid.
I think this shows that they do not really understand what sin is or have any comprehension of what God is.

God is the ultimate realiy and to not want to know, or experience that indicates they do noy understand.
there's people who don't want God but are not necessarily evil in the truest sense of the word

The true meaning of evil is to reject God.

What people regard as the problem of evil, the vile things people do is only the outworking of there hatred of God and his pure goodness.

To be brutal, there will be no innocent people in Hell, they will All have chosen evil over good.
 
On reddit, there was a user who made a post about asking God to wipe him/her from existence/consciousness after he/she did all he/she was supposed to do to be saved from eternal torment. Basically, he/she accepted Christ as his personal savior, but his/her plan is to ask God to return him/her back into a state of nonexistence now that the infinite debt of sin has been paid.

This person's request to be unmade indicates that they were very likely not actually saved. Salvation entails submitting to God, to His divine authority, wisdom and power. If a person intends to be saved by God, they must understand that He saves them AS GOD, which is to say, He saves them as the One who is their Lord, Master, Ruler and King. He will be nothing less in the lives of His creatures. As such, if He has seen fit to create someone, who are they to think they know better and ought to be uncreated? Where is the submission to God in such a request?

So, this begs the question: HOW and WHY is the mere desire to not exist at all tantamount to someone with the narcissistic and egomanical desire to try to overtake somebody else's place, let alone their universe??? The person who doesn't want to exist at all forever doesn't want a thing from ANYBODY. They have absolutely NO interest in taking over anything or ruling anyone's life. They're not hurting anybody.

They are implying that God should not have created them, which is to say the creature knows better than its Creator whether or not it should exist. This is a kind of pride, obviously. On what basis would the creature's view of its existence be superior to that of its Creator? Again, where is the proper and necessary submission to God's will in the creature wanting to cease to exist entirely?

Such a desire for non-existence communicates volumes about what the creature understands of its Creator, too. God says He is the Ultimate Locus of all good things, the Perfect Apex of love, joy, peace, contentment, wisdom, etc.. He says we can know and enjoy Him in all of His goodness and perfection, if we walk with Him in the way has told us to do. The person who wants to cease to exist implicitly denies all that God has said about Himself concerning His goodness and rejects God's offer of fellowship. How is this not an evil thing to do, given God's excellence and the generosity of his offer?

And it's interesting that while comparing the desire to choose nonexistence over eternal existence to the bold, arrogant desire of Lucifer to overthrow God, NONE of those people applied the same paradigm to people on Earth who lie, cheat, steal, rape, murder, etc. THOSE acts, just like Satan's attempt at overthrowing God, also play God, disrespect Him, destroy and ruin His creation and make life for everyone and everything living on Earth a living hell. Why isn't anyone saying "Are you God? Who said you have a choice over that?"

??? I know of many Christians - myself among them - who say these very sorts of things.

At the same time, the person...just doesn't want Christ.....it has nothing to do with sin

But not wanting Christ is sin. He is the Creator; he is God; to not want him is to not want the purpose for which one has been made. He is the Ultimate Point of our existence; we are made for him, not the other way 'round.

They just don't have a desire or a passion to serve Christ for its own sake. Inevitably, they'll only want to come to Him if it's to avoid the alternative: Hell. And I'm NOT going to do that. You either want Him or you just don't. Bottom line.

This is the ultimate narcissism. The attitude described above indicates that the will of the creature is superior to the will of its Creator, that the creature has a right to self-determination, to seek its own will and way rather than the will and way of its Creator. But this is entirely false. None of us were made for ourselves, to seek and fulfill our own will and way. When we behave as though we should serve ourselves, we are like a hammer used to sew curtains, or a saxophone used to play golf; we are completely unfit for purpose and descend into frustration, meaninglessness, darkness and self-destruction.

We are in God's universe, made and sustained by His will and power, and are intended by Him to serve His purposes, not our own. To rail at this, to reject His right as our Creator to direct our lives and do with us as He pleases, is the very height of hubris and enormously evil - so much so that God will punish such wicked pride with eternal hell.
 
This person's request to be unmade indicates that they were very likely not actually saved. Salvation entails submitting to God, to His divine authority, wisdom and power. If a person intends to be saved by God, they must understand that He saves them AS GOD, which is to say, He saves them as the One who is their Lord, Master, Ruler and King. He will be nothing less in the lives of His creatures. As such, if He has seen fit to create someone, who are they to think they know better and ought to be uncreated? Where is the submission to God in such a request?



They are implying that God should not have created them, which is to say the creature knows better than its Creator whether or not it should exist. This is a kind of pride, obviously. On what basis would the creature's view of its existence be superior to that of its Creator? Again, where is the proper and necessary submission to God's will in the creature wanting to cease to exist entirely?

Such a desire for non-existence communicates volumes about what the creature understands of its Creator, too. God says He is the Ultimate Locus of all good things, the Perfect Apex of love, joy, peace, contentment, wisdom, etc.. He says we can know and enjoy Him in all of His goodness and perfection, if we walk with Him in the way has told us to do. The person who wants to cease to exist implicitly denies all that God has said about Himself concerning His goodness and rejects God's offer of fellowship. How is this not an evil thing to do, given God's excellence and the generosity of his offer?



??? I know of many Christians - myself among them - who say these very sorts of things.



But not wanting Christ is sin. He is the Creator; he is God; to not want him is to not want the purpose for which one has been made. He is the Ultimate Point of our existence; we are made for him, not the other way 'round.



This is the ultimate narcissism. The attitude described above indicates that the will of the creature is superior to the will of its Creator, that the creature has a right to self-determination, to seek its own will and way rather than the will and way of its Creator. But this is entirely false. None of us were made for ourselves, to seek and fulfill our own will and way. When we behave as though we should serve ourselves, we are like a hammer used to sew curtains, or a saxophone used to play golf; we are completely unfit for purpose and descend into frustration, meaninglessness, darkness and self-destruction.

We are in God's universe, made and sustained by His will and power, and are intended by Him to serve His purposes, not our own. To rail at this, to reject His right as our Creator to direct our lives and do with us as He pleases, is the very height of hubris and enormously evil - so much so that God will punish such wicked pride with eternal hell.
Okay. But what about murder, theft, rape, cheating, terrorism and mass killings? We have the free will to do all of these things which are against God's will and are of great disrespect to Him and His creation, but a mere wish to turn down eternal existence especially when it causes no harm to anyone and when the person hasn't even sinned yet, is equal to or worst than all of those atrocities?
 
On reddit, there was a user who made a post about asking God to wipe him/her from existence/consciousness after he/she did all he/she was supposed to do to be saved from eternal torment. Basically, he/she accepted Christ as his personal savior, but his/her plan is to ask God to return him/her back into a state of nonexistence now that the infinite debt of sin has been paid.

What perked my ears was the fact that almost all of the comments said that he/she deserved eternal darkness in conscious torment forever, comparing the desire to simply not exist to Satan's tyrannical desire to overtake God's Kingdom and rule and own the universe as his own, since he wanted to be God. There were several other users on Quora as well who did this.

So, this begs the question: HOW and WHY is the mere desire to not exist at all tantamount to someone with the narcissistic and egomanical desire to try to overtake somebody else's place, let alone their universe??? The person who doesn't want to exist at all forever doesn't want a thing from ANYBODY. They have absolutely NO interest in taking over anything or ruling anyone's life. They're not hurting anybody.
First, such a person who claims to have done all “he/she was supposed to do to be saved,” has tried to complete a list of works to be saved, as though a person can simply decide to do X, Y, and Z and be saved. Second, the fact they’re not saved is shown in their desire to not want to be with God for eternity. To claim to be saved and yet not want to be with God for eternity is a contradiction. Third, it is to say that God made a mistake by allowing them to exist. Fourth, it is to utterly fail at recognizing the significance of their existence, that there is a purpose for it. Fifth, it is utterly selfish and self-centered.

And it's interesting that while comparing the desire to choose nonexistence over eternal existence to the bold, arrogant desire of Lucifer to overthrow God, NONE of those people applied the same paradigm to people on Earth who lie, cheat, steal, rape, murder, etc. THOSE acts, just like Satan's attempt at overthrowing God, also play God, disrespect Him, destroy and ruin His creation and make life for everyone and everything living on Earth a living hell. Why isn't anyone saying "Are you God? Who said you have a choice over that?"
That is at the core of wanting to not exist. It is for that person to say that God made a mistake and that he/she knows better than God. It is the sin of sins.

And we all know why: free will. So shouldn't the same apply to the choice between existing and not existing? Who is the person hurting or insulting?
God. Humans are made in the image of God and have infinite worth. It is a huge insult to God.

Also, theoretically, since the person never existed, they therefore wouldn't have been born in sin, wouldn't freely choose to sin, wouldn't need to be held accountable, and thus, no need for a Savior.
They also would be unable to love God and bring him glory and enjoy him forever.

Their responses give the implication that simply the mere act of not wanting to exist in the first place is in of itself, a great evil for two reasons: 1. Since God created the soul, He intended for said soul to exist forever, so understandably, going against that design would be considered going against His will. 2. One could conclude that such an individual would only want such a thing if he/she simply wants to escape accountability for a lifetime of sin or avoid punishment.

They have a point, but there's a third alternative to consider: It could be that the person quite simply DOESN'T want Christ.
Which again shows that such a person cannot be saved. Every single unsaved person in hell are those who reject Christ--that is the very reason they are there.

They don't want to spend eternity in Hell not only due to the inevitable fellowhsip with some of the worst, most depraved, wicked people to have ever disgraced the Earth,
It's always easy to point out the evil in others while ignoring the evil inside oneself, made all the worse by comparison--that person is so evil because they did X and therefore since I haven't done X, I am good and not evil.

but also other less discussed reasons such as a perpetually worsening spiritual and moral state and the obvious fact that nobody in their right mind would want to spend all of eternity in total darkness, loneliness, pain and misery with thoughts and a conscience that torment you (and not simply just because they want to escape punishment or accountability).

At the same time, the person...just doesn't want Christ.....it has nothing to do with sin, because there's plenty of sinners who DO want to spend eternity with God. They just don't have a desire or a passion to serve Christ for its own sake. Inevitably, they'll only want to come to Him if it's to avoid the alternative: Hell. And I'm NOT going to do that. You either want Him or you just don't. Bottom line.
Then they have absolutely no idea about who God actually is or who Jesus actually is. That begs the question as to why they don't want him. How can a person rationally reject God or Christ whom they don't even know? That makes no sense.

But, they don't actually want to spend eternity with God, they just want to spend eternity doing what they want to do. That's the ultimate in selfishness and self-centeredness. That is the bottom line.

So it begs another question: why are people like us here? Why are we here?
I would reframe it slightly as: Why do I exist rather than not exist? I think that it more strongly suggests purpose. Should we not then seek that out with everything we are and by all means possible? God wants everyone to be here, for his reasons and purposes. Do we need any other reason?

The fact that there are only two eternal destinations after death and the fact that there's people who don't want God but are not necessarily evil in the truest sense of the word has solidified my belief (which in turn highlights Jesus' point when He said of Judas 'It would have been better if that man had never been born') that people like us should've never entered into existence.
But, they are evil in the truest sense of the word. They have rejected God, which is to reject love and goodness and holiness himself, so they can only be evil. The claim that there are people who "don't want God but are not necessarily evil in the truest sense of the word," betrays a complete lack of understanding of what sin is and how sinful even the smallest sin is to a perfectly holy God. As such, one also cannot understand the holiness and justice of God.

That way, we wouldn't have a thing to complain or worry about. Know existence, know sin, know accountability. No existence, no sin, no accountability.
If someone thinks that they would have been better off and would be better of just not existing, then something is very wrong spiritually with that person. If a person knows it would be infinitely better to be in heaven, then why would they reject God and reject Jesus instead of pursuing them with all their being? Especially since, at this point, there is no option to not exist.
 
So, this begs the question: HOW and WHY is the mere desire to not exist at all tantamount to someone with the narcissistic and egomanical desire to try to overtake somebody else's place, let alone their universe??? The person who doesn't want to exist at all forever doesn't want a thing from ANYBODY. They have absolutely NO interest in taking over anything or ruling anyone's life. They're not hurting anybody.

Simply put , in this life either you are serving God or you are serving Satan .

If you do not desire to be here living your life after have been given the gift of life from the Creator you would be serving Satan .

New Living Translation
Don’t you realize that you become the slave of whatever you choose to obey? You can be a slave to sin, which leads to death, or you can choose to obey God, which leads to righteous living.

A poet wrote .
But you’re gonna have to serve somebody, yes indeed
You’re gonna have to serve somebody,
It may be the devil or it may be the Lord
But you’re gonna have to serve somebody.
 
Okay. But what about murder, theft, rape, cheating, terrorism and mass killings? We have the free will to do all of these things which are against God's will and are of great disrespect to Him and His creation, but a mere wish to turn down eternal existence especially when it causes no harm to anyone and when the person hasn't even sinned yet, is equal to or worst than all of those atrocities?

Is it a "mere wish" to want to be annihilated, to be put out of existence? Or is it as I've described? What it means to want to be unmade (which I explained in my last post) isn't lessened or negated by the other acts of evil you've listed.

You know, I've heard people say things like, "Well, I've never killed anybody," or "I'm not as bad as Hitler," when they argue against God sending them to hell forever. They find the worst people to which to compare themselves so that they're own wickedness seems far less heinous. But God's standard for judging what is good or evil isn't the one we want to propose to Him. He doesn't accept our sin because the next guy's sin was far worse. No, God is His own standard for judging our sin and next to His holy perfection we are all vile, depraved monsters. And so, pointing at "greater" evils (from your point of view) doesn't make the evil of wanting to be unmade any less awful. God says it all defies His will and so He will punish it all as it deserves to be punished.
 
Back
Top