Solo said:
When you show me your opinions in scripture it will become truth; until then it is just your opinion. The visible Body of Christ is the Spiritual Church that the Scriptures speak of, not a man-made institution of control.
Well, you are going to have to show me THAT concept from Scriptures... The Scriptures themselves do not call themselves the sole source of truth, now, do they? Nor does the Scripture ANYWHERE say that the teaching Church is subject to the Bible...
The Visible Body of Christ is a GOD-MADE institution that IS visible. How else would people know the Word of God? From a visible body who wrote a visible book, practiced a visible way of life, worshipped in a visible way, and taught an objective Gospel. Were the teachers of the Church visible or not? Did believers know where to point to when someone asked "Where is Christ's Church"? Did they point to some esoteric teaching or a book or an institution with people? Christ gave a mandate to the apostles to preach and teach, not pass out tracts and let everyone figure it out through the "Holy Spirit"! Thus, they were VISIBLE. All this talk about an invisible church to the detriment of the visible is ridiculous and illogical. It is throwing out the baby with the bath water.
Your "invisible church" concept basically says that your ideas and thoughts are from the Holy Spirit. Sorry, I am not convinced that every word you utter is from the Holy Spirit, nor are your interpretations of Scriptures always from the Holy Spirit. Basically, you are making yourself the official interpreter of God's Word. Our latest exchanges show you err, so you are not the speaking receptible for God. So what do you do when you run into another Protestant who claims the same thing but believes something else about baptism? Are there now two truths that completely contradict? Two "Holy Spirits"? In the end, you can never know if you are really correct, since you are not infallible.
Fortunately, we CAN turn to a visible Body that has been given the Keys - power to bind and loosen - and protected by God from the Gates of Hell. Whatever is bound on earth is bound in heaven. Is this not enough evidence that what the visible Church says is bound in heaven - infallible? I have given you Scriptures - Matthew 16:18-20.
Another is Galatians 1:9-11. Paul KNOWS the Gospel that he preaches is infallible, not because of his knowledge, but because he is part of the Church of Christ, the VISIBLE Church, an apostle protected from error.
Another is Acts 15. The VISIBLE Church decides - AGAINST ALL SCRIPTURES - that circumcision was no longer required. If this isn't proof of the infallible actions of the Visible Church, (IN CONTRADICTION TO THE OLD TESTAMENT SCRIPTURES!!!) I don't know what is...
I wonder what you would have said in 47 AD when the Church made this decision - without any Scriptural warrant to back it up with! So much for Sola Scriptura - disproved by the Bible itself...
To those who have ears...
Regards