I am not afraid for my soul (I don't believe I have one) and I believe I am a good person, whats there for other to be scared of?
On the other hand, I have never been threatened in any way by atheists because of my "beliefs" (or lack of), theists on the other hand have gotten quite hostile with me. I am sure you all know this from the other perspective and I am sure there have been atheists who have become hostile towards you. This isn't about who is or is not a good person, it is simply a clash of ideals between the two sides. Good people will justify themselves for any behavior no matter what side they subscribe to, this includes hostility towards the opposing side.
I can Understand why you would fear for the "soul" of an unbeliever but to have any personal negative emotions towards them is unreasonable, this works both ways though. An atheist will be saddened by the fact that you still believe, but personal negative emotions towards a believer just because they believe is unwarranted.
From my side, I would be very glad if you all let go of your faith, but I have no negative thought or emotions for any of you personally because I do not know you personally and cannot make a judgement about your character solely based on your beliefs.
From your side, I am sure you would all be very glad If I regained my faith, but you shouldn't have any negative thoughts or emotions for me personally because you don't really know me on a personal level sufficient to make a judgment of my character.
And yes, I am still here.