MOHAMMAD: THE CHILD KILLER

[Sanitarium]

maybe you bring us the exsact number of those Hadith also!?

You want the exact number of Sahih ahadith? I do not know the exact number. However, just because a narration is included in a sahih collection does not automatically make it sahih. Bukhari (and his student, Muslim) admitted as much.

I can give you examples of false ahadith. The Quran states that Muhammad performed no miracles; that the only 'miracle' was the Quran, right? That means all the narrations in Bukhari and Muslim that state Muhammad performed other miracles fail the last (3rd) of Bukhari's criteria the mat'n - the contents of the narration must not contradict the Quran. That means these narrations are not actually Sahih.

You keep stating that all of Ibn ishaq is false ahadith but you have not provided any evidence. Why?

 

[Love25]

maybe you bring us the exsact number of those Hadith also!?

You want the exact number of Sahih ahadith? I do not know the exact number. However, just because a narration is included in a sahih collection does not automatically make it sahih. Bukhari (and his student, Muslim) admitted as much.

I can give you examples of false ahadith. The Quran states that Muhammad performed no miracles; that the only 'miracle' was the Quran, right? That means all the narrations in Bukhari and Muslim that state Muhammad performed other miracles fail the last (3rd) of Bukhari's criteria the mat'n - the contents of the narration must not contradict the Quran. That means these narrations are not actually Sahih.

You keep stating that all of Ibn ishaq is false ahadith but you have not provided any evidence. Why?

Of course Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) didnt do any Miracles as Holy Quran says same like Bible says that Jesus (pbuh) didnt make any Miracles!

Becuase simply all miracles were done by POWER and WILL of GOD!

So when we say Miracles which are SIGNS that were given to Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) by God is by the way equal and more then those Miracles done by all previous Prophets included Jesus (pbuh)!

By the way for us Muslims we dont differ between prophets or compare, also we dont care about those Miracles becuase we dont depend our faith on such miracles, but I thought it is important to show that Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) made Miracles more then Prophet Jesus (pbuh) whom you consideras God!!!

Peace

 

[Rick W]

Jesus is more than a prophet. He is the Son of God.

 

[Gabe]

I can give you examples of false ahadith. The Quran states that Muhammad performed no miracles; that the only 'miracle' was the Quran, right? That means all the narrations in Bukhari and Muslim that state Muhammad performed other miracles fail the last (3rd) of Bukhari's criteria the mat'n - the contents of the narration must not contradict the Quran. That means these narrations are not actually Sahih.

Of course Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) didnt do any Miracles as Holy Quran says same like Bible says that Jesus (pbuh) didnt make any Miracles!

Becuase simply all miracles were done by POWER and WILL of GOD!

So when we say Miracles which are SIGNS that were given to Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) by God is by the way equal and more then those Miracles done by all previous Prophets included Jesus (pbuh)!

How do you explain the following verse (which is one among many)?

And those who disbelieve say: Why is not a sign sent down upon him by his Lord? Say: Surely Allah makes him who will go astray, and guides to Himself those who turn (to Him). Quran 13:27

Regardless of how much you like to twist words, there were no "signs" sent down to or given to Mohammad.

By the way for us Muslims we dont differ between prophets or compare, also we dont care about those Miracles becuase we dont depend our faith on such miracles, but I thought it is important to show that Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) made Miracles more then Prophet Jesus (pbuh) whom you consideras God!!!

Peace

For someone who does not compare "Prophets", you sure like to compare your number one Prophet to your number two Prophet, and the last time I checked; Atheists do not consider Jesus Christ to be God.

 

[Love25]

How do you explain the following verse (which is one among many)?

And those who disbelieve say: Why is not a sign sent down upon him by his Lord? Say: Surely Allah makes him who will go astray, and guides to Himself those who turn (to Him). Quran 13:27

The answer is in the bible also beucase if you read what Jesus (pbuh) did due to the bible you will find that not always he did Miracles, as Prophets didnt come to make kind of SHOW, but those Miracles were done by God in the time and moment and situation that ONLY God decide!!!

So return to this verse know when it were said and also in which sitution and things will be more clear!
--------------------------

Regardless of how much you like to twist words, there were no "signs" sent down to or given to Mohammad.

Said by who!?

--------------------------

For someone who does not compare "Prophets", you sure like to compare your number one Prophet to your number two Prophet, and the last time I checked; Atheists do not consider Jesus Christ to be God.

Not at all we only compare Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) whom we love more for sure to Jesus son of God (or God) due to your beleives, and by the way it is your side that always do that as to show that Jesus your God is better then our Prophet!!!

So if Jesus the God better then our Prophet the Human becuase of Miracles then this is no reason for you to accept Jesus as God becuase as I said and I repeat God gave Prophet Mohamed (pbuh) miracles and SIGNS equal or better then any other Prophet before and I dont mean the Miracle of Holy Quran but I mean miracles in the way you love!!!

Peace