What's new
By:
Filters
Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Polio virus nearly eradicated

A

Aardverk

Guest
Along with hundreds of other species that mankind has deliberately, carelessly or greedily brought to extinction, we are apparently almost there with Polio.

Is it right for mankind to wipe out one of God's creations just because we don't like it? (Said with tongue firmly in cheek.)
 
LOL


I hadnt quite started school when Polio vacinations were begun.
 
Hitch said:
LOL I hadnt quite started school when Polio vacinations were begun.
Click to expand...

For clarity, that would have been a prophylactic vaccination to stop you suffering from polio. We are talking here about the complete eradication of polio from the natural world - same as with smallpox.

My question was - God created polio, should mankind utterly destroy it OR assume that He had good reason to have created it?
 
Aardverk said:
For clarity, that would have been a prophylactic vaccination to stop you suffering from polio. We are talking here about the complete eradication of polio from the natural world - same as with smallpox.

My question was - God created polio, should mankind utterly destroy it OR assume that He had good reason to have created it?
Click to expand...

OK, show me in scripture where God created diseases and then choose which ones would receive them. Wouldn't that make God a respecter of person. How could God create everything and say it is good if he created diseases that brings pain, anguish and even death.
 
for_his_glory said:
OK, show me in scripture where God created diseases and then choose which ones would receive them. Wouldn't that make God a respecter of person. How could God create everything and say it is good if he created diseases that brings pain, anguish and even death.
Click to expand...
Are you implying that there is a creator other than God?
 
Aardverk said:
Along with hundreds of other species that mankind has deliberately, carelessly or greedily brought to extinction, we are apparently almost there with Polio.

Is it right for mankind to wipe out one of God's creations just because we don't like it? (Said with tongue firmly in cheek.)
Click to expand...
I think a strong case could be made for things such as polio being the result of a fallen world, a creation now less than what God had declared good. It is not only right for mankind to wipe out such diseases, it is the Christian's imperative to attempt to do so.
 
Aardverk said:
Who made the diseases if not God?
Click to expand...

Job 1:12 And the LORD said unto Satan, Behold, all that he hath is in thy power; only upon himself put not forth thine hand. So Satan went forth from the presence of the LORD.

Disease and pestilence is that of Satan to try and steal our faith in Christ. Whether child or adult they are of the Lords if their faith stands strong even to death for that which Satan causes them to face. Faith stands strong in the face of persecution and always brings us out victorious in the end. 1Corinthians 15:55 O death, where is thy sting? O grave, where is thy victory?
 
for_his_glory said:
Disease and pestilence is that of Satan to try and steal our faith in Christ. Whether child or adult they are of the Lords if their faith stands strong even to death for that which Satan causes them to face. Faith stands strong in the face of persecution and always brings us out victorious in the end.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure if you are quoting that from somewhere or if those are your own words 'for_his_glory'. Are you saying that Satan is also a creator (of diseases etc) and that God didn't create polio (etc)? i.e. that God is not the only creator. Or are you saying that God created them so that Satan can use them to try to steal faith in Christ?
 
I think the safest analogy is that God did not create GM Trout. God created trout, we created the augmentation in trout.
 
Also, was it polio or something else that was almost eradicated in 3rd world countries by simply teaching hygiene and then WHO took all the credit by curing a small percentage of the remaining population?
 
Fedusenko said:
I think the safest analogy is that God did not create GM Trout. God created trout, we created the augmentation in trout.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure I understand that analogy. You seem to be saying that polio was genetically engineered by man. Surely you don't really think that?

It seems to me that there are four options. The explanation for polio and other diseases is either....

1. God created everything and saw that it was good - and we simply have not realized yet why diseases are 'good'. OR
2. God was not the only creator and diseases were created by Satan - for example. OR
3. Evolution is a fact. OR
4. Despite man's searching answers for 'everything' he has not yet found the right answer. i.e. it's not God OR evolution but something else.

Any ideas for number 4?
 
eliminate1337 said:
Why is this even debated? Of course it's right to eradicate a disease to save thousands of lives!
Click to expand...

Of course it is right to eliminate diseases along with every other major source of death and suffering but you are being too literal. Maybe on that level you think we should eliminate mosquitoes, crocodiles, hippopotami and lions as well? They all kill and maim people.

The question is in reality the unspoken sub-text of WHY would God create such things OR did he not create them? If he did NOT where did they come from?

No one has yet come up with an answer to that sub-text but maybe you can.
 
No, I do not believe that man engineered polio, but that which it came from was not of a destructive nature. The enemy can manipulate the world. And don't call me Surely.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top