What's new
By:
Filters
Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Christian Rock & Metal

Roro1972 said:
a prime example of a little leaven leavens the whole lump
Click to expand...
Leaven is symbolic of evil. So you are saying modern Christian music is evil (the metal genre in particular)? Only God decides what is evil. Show me the scripture from God that tells us modern Christian music is evil and telling us before which date non-evil music must have been written. Otherwise this is a matter of your taste, not of evil. Please consider how your false judgement on the good Christian folks who are writing and producing this modern genre of Christian music and on those who enjoy it and are drawn closer to God by it must affect them in a bad way.

Or perhaps you can show me an example of modern Christian metal music that is evil (evil according to scripture, not according to your personal preference). I've asked for this many times on this forum and also in other places and so far no one can show me.
 
Last edited:
Angel said:
There is a culture that coincides with all (secular) genre's, and you have to be careful about how you are influenced.
Click to expand...
Christian metal isn't a secular genre.
This really appears like an issue of not liking the metal genre, music-wise. Which is fine, but calling Christian metal demonic is plain wrong.
 
Obadiah said:
Leaven is symbolic of evil. So you are saying modern Christian music is evil (the metal genre in particular)? Only God decides what is evil. Show me the scripture from God that tells us modern Christian music is evil and telling us before which date non-evil music must have been written. Otherwise this is a matter of your taste, not of evil. Please consider how your false judgement on the good Christian folks who are writing and producing this modern genre of Christian music and on those who enjoy it and are drawn closer to God by it must affect them in a bad way.

Or perhaps you can show me an example of modern Christian metal music that is evil (evil according to scripture, not according to your personal preference). I've asked for this many times on this forum and also in other places and so far no one can show me.
Click to expand...
I remember ( most I have ever heard ) metal and rap as being as far from Christ as possible. much was down right filthy.
and much of it incorporated satan or sex in verses. im not going to try to convince anyone Im right and their wrong. that is my perception of that type music; when I was wild and had the attitude anything goes I went along with it and the crowd
lots of drugs, sex, whiskey and cussing. I left that crowd and that image.
 
Obadiah said:
Then by your logic everything has to be avoided because almost everything was being done before we were Christians. I simply can't agree with your application of this passage. Considering the biblical references to the use of music to praise God (in which the descriptions of it certainly sound pretty wild and joyful!) this scripture is not a condemnation of modern Christian music.

By the way, I find a valid argument in the concept that Christian metal or rock actually IS a "new wine skin" if you want to use that analogy. They took the previous version (secular metal) and re-did it into something new; Christian metal which now avoids the evil parts of the old version. Since none of this music has any evil concepts presented in it, to condemn this is to say that you know the hearts of the artists are evil and their intent in writing their songs is evil. I'm sure I don't need to cite the scripture telling you that you can't make this judgement.
Click to expand...

I can make that judgment, Just as you made your Judgment. The question is "what is the Truth?"
 
There's two sides to this as I see it. Christian metal may have a place, depending on its message. There's a people who don't go to church and need a physician (to be saved). These people would not play traditional Christian music. They would play metal music. It could plant seeds.

The other side of this is, is the message good, or metal with a Christian label only?

This brings us to the 64k dollar question. Is it the lyrics of the music or the music itself which make it good or evil? Or both?
 
I wonder why people go looking for evil in places it isn't.

Do some really think God dislikes one variety of worship because it contains drums, a base guitar and a electric guitar rather than an acoustic guitar?

I've seen Petra live (ok, they're more rock than metal but anyway) : More worship there (in music AND words) than in any church I ever saw in Norway, Germany, England or Scotland
 
Roro1972 said:
I remember ( most I have ever heard ) metal and rap as being as far from Christ as possible. much was down right filthy.
and much of it incorporated satan or sex in verses. im not going to try to convince anyone Im right and their wrong. that is my perception of that type music; when I was wild and had the attitude anything goes I went along with it and the crowd
lots of drugs, sex, whiskey and cussing. I left that crowd and that image.
Click to expand...
Ok, you say you have heard... this is your perception, etc, etc. You are not God. You do not decide what is evil. You have shown no scripture from God to back your claim of evil. And you claim this music (Christian metal and Christian rap) "incorporated satan or sex in verses" and are telling me those who enjoy it are into "lots of drugs, sex, whiskey and cussing" but you fail to give me even one example of this, not even one shred of evidence of any of it when I asked you for it. Yes, sir, this is false judgement against these Christian people.
 
Douglas Summers said:
I can make that judgment, Just as you made your Judgment. The question is "what is the Truth?"
Click to expand...
No, you can make a personal choice of what type of music you like. You CAN NOT judge and accuse Christian artists of producing evil music as leaven just because it doesn't fit your personal tastes. There is clear scripture against that and I think you are well aware of that.
 
Praise him with trumpet sound;
praise him with lute and harp!
Praise him with tambourine and dance;
praise him with strings and pipe!
Praise him with sounding cymbals;
praise him with loud clashing cymbals!
Let everything that has breath praise the Lord!
Praise the Lord!
(Psalm 150: 3-6, ESV)
 
Edward said:
There's two sides to this as I see it. Christian metal may have a place, depending on its message. There's a people who don't go to church and need a physician (to be saved). These people would not play traditional Christian music. They would play metal music. It could plant seeds.

The other side of this is, is the message good, or metal with a Christian label only?

This brings us to the 64k dollar question. Is it the lyrics of the music or the music itself which make it good or evil? Or both?
Click to expand...
Music without lyrics is simply a series of combinations of tones created by vibrations of the air. There is nothing good nor nothing evil about it. The message conveyed can only be in the lyrics. I've asked over and over for someone to show me an example of any Christian music with these "satanic" or "evil" lyrics or messages they keep harping about and not one person can do it. So all these arguments of it being evil so far are baseless and unscripturaly false judgements. The video that was posted early on has music that is not to my personal liking, but I listened to all of it and found nothing evil or satanic about it in any part of the messages that I could understand.
 
wwjd_kilden said:
Praise him with trumpet sound;
praise him with lute and harp!
Praise him with tambourine and dance;
praise him with strings and pipe!
Praise him with sounding cymbals;
praise him with loud clashing cymbals!
Let everything that has breath praise the Lord!
Praise the Lord!
(Psalm 150: 3-6, ESV)
Click to expand...
Thank you! This psalm describes the Old Testament equivalent of a modern day Christian hard rock band, but oh how many people here condemn what this psalm describes as evil and satanic!
 
It's already been explained that Christian metal is NOT the same as secular metal, but some people are just on such a witch hunt, such a crusade on this subject that they are totally blinded to the difference and therefore don't seem to mind at all calling evil what God has said is good. (Ps 150:3-6)
 
Is it any different then any other Christian music genre, no. What it is is the word of God put to music like any other Christian group. I personally do not care for that type of music, but it does reach out to the youth as Christ draws them to Himself. Anytime I have ever seen Christian groups like this they always take a break to share scripture with the kids and many do receive Jesus as their Lord and Savior. We might not understand the words they sing, but I know for a fact those kids can repeat those words and know what they mean.
 
Obadiah said:
No, you can make a personal choice of what type of music you like. You CAN NOT judge and accuse Christian artists of producing evil music as leaven just because it doesn't fit your personal tastes. There is clear scripture against that and I think you are well aware of that.
Click to expand...
Obadiah, it is obvious that you are into christian rock and heavy metal and maybe even christian so called rap. I did not capitalize any of the proper nouns, because I don't think they deserve it. The first and original sin is "PRIDE", and that is all those musicians care about is notoriety. I grew up on the birth of Rock and Heavy Metal. Elvis, Bill Haley, Pat Boone, Jerry Lewis (whose cousin is Pat Robinson) all the way through the 50's, 60's, 70's. I pretty much then got selective on the music I listened to or liked, so I'am not void of the influence of music on a persons life.
If you will take the time to look at how many musicians started their careers in Church Choirs and became famous changing to secular or pop music that have died of drugs or had their lives ruined,....... from Elvis, Marvin Gay, Whitney Huston, and many others, you would see the trend of how such music and life styles have completely hindered any progress in the change of self to grace, blocking out the image of Christ. You must be born again...really.
 
Obadiah said:
Ok, you say you have heard... this is your perception, etc, etc. You are not God. You do not decide what is evil. You have shown no scripture from God to back your claim of evil. And you claim this music (Christian metal and Christian rap) "incorporated satan or sex in verses" and are telling me those who enjoy it are into "lots of drugs, sex, whiskey and cussing" but you fail to give me even one example of this, not even one shred of evidence of any of it when I asked you for it. Yes, sir, this is false judgement against these Christian people.
Click to expand...

did I say I was God, sorry Im just a human. Did I say I decide what is evil.
I CLAIMED that rap and metal that I REMEMBER HEARING had incorporated satan or sex in verses; thats true
I DID NOT SAY CHRISTIAN RAP HAS DRUGS AND SEX IN THEM;
This is a STAFF MEMBER changing and adding words in a post then lashing out at the post they created as if the other poster said it.
Again you make another FALSE claim I did not say those who enjoy it are INTO "lots of drugs, sex, whiskey and cussing" I said when I was wild and and listened to it there was "lots of drugs, sex, whiskey and cussing" involved
it is obvious you did not understand my post but you should not move and shift words around to attack me.
Rap and heavy metal DID and DOES have lots of sex drugs and cussing in the verses that creates an image.
I said that image follows the music when brought to church.
Pay Attention to 30 to 34 seconds in the clip. also 58 to 59 in the clip, hope I am not asking to much of you
remember 30 to 34 and 58 to 59 try to remember these its tough I know but try
 
Douglas Summers said:
Obadiah, it is obvious that you are into christian rock and heavy metal and maybe even christian so called rap. I did not capitalize any of the proper nouns, because I don't think they deserve it. The first and original sin is "PRIDE", and that is all those musicians care about is notoriety. I grew up on the birth of Rock and Heavy Metal. Elvis, Bill Haley, Pat Boone, Jerry Lewis (whose cousin is Pat Robinson) all the way through the 50's, 60's, 70's. I pretty much then got selective on the music I listened to or liked, so I'am not void of the influence of music on a persons life.
If you will take the time to look at how many musicians started their careers in Church Choirs and became famous changing to secular or pop music that have died of drugs or had their lives ruined,....... from Elvis, Marvin Gay, Whitney Huston, and many others, you would see the trend of how such music and life styles have completely hindered any progress in the change of self to grace, blocking out the image of Christ. You must be born again...really.
Click to expand...
Once again, ungodly judgement without scriptural cause. You unrighteously condemn a whole class of people based on a few, and you don't give a hoot about our young people bring brought to the Lord through this. What was it Jesus said about how important He considered young people again? Perhaps you have lived past the point of caring about them anymore?
Douglas Summers said:
You must be born again...really.
Click to expand...
I must be born again? Maybe you must be born again so you would learn not to judge falsely.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top