Post 1
O Father, please open our minds and hearts to understand Your love for us in Your Son and our Saviour - Jesus Christ. Amen.
I've just skimmed through this thread. And the issue i've comprehended is over why and how Christ is the only means of salvation. This is what i've gathered so far - correct me if i'm wrong. In this post and the following ones, I am going to refer to other religions but I don't have an in-depth knowledge of them. So if there are any misconceptions on my side, I would be willing to correct them as they're pointed out. Let the discussion proceed in a civil and not a caustic tone. I'd request the reader to read through completely before rejecting any argument because I have had to deal with different overlapping arguments at different places. I'll also clearly declare here that my intent is only to share the truth, not try to impose my beliefs on anyone.
Firstly, I think all of us would agree that when we refer to 'God', we imply the All-Knowing,All-Wise,All-Good,All-Powerful,All-True,All-Loving,Perfectly-Just,Absolutely-Holy, Omnipresent Eternal Sovereign Being.
Now, i'm avoiding discussing the atheist's viewpoint for now. But just reflecting, they arrive at it with no just cause and also end up removing all meaning and purpose from life. When there seems to be so much meaning and purpose in all of creation which we see everyday, and if we ourselves are driven towards meaningful pursuits and a purposeful life, then there has to be meaning and purpose for our existence too - and this can be found revealed only in our Creator - the one true God. I'll deal with this later...but for now -
I don't understand the agnostic's viewpoint which claims that there might be a God but that He cannot be known. What does that mean - 'He cannot be known'? Obviously He cannot be known if He doesn't choose to reveal Himself but if God doesn't reveal who He is and why we are here, then it goes against the very definition of God. God cannot be All-Wise and still be the author of confusion. God cannot be All-Good and still be cruel. Do you imagine God observing us as if we were white mice in the laboratory, without revealing to us why we're here and who He is? That's cruel. Do you imagine Him sitting back without taking any effort to reveal truths to us as we flounder about many religions and many concepts of God through our imagination and perception? That's confusion. How can an All-Loving God be so unloving when we seek answers about Him? And how can an All-True God let us flounder about our own concepts of 'true' and false without ever revealing the actual, absolute truth? Compare this with what God reveals through His written Word - the Bible.
Joh 8:32 And you shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.
Joh 14:6 Jesus said to him, I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life; no one comes to the Father but by Me.
God has indeed revealed all truths and meaning through the Word, all creation, His angels, the numerous prophets, His written Word and His own begotten Son who came in the flesh, Jesus Christ. These truths are being suppressed because of our own rebellion against submitting to the Holy God.
To avoid misinterpretation of the previous para, let me state that by revelation from God, I don't necessarily mean a physical revelation. Well, that is going to happen on the Last Day but what I mean here is that God has to reveal meaning and purpose for our lives so that we can have hope in our lives in this world. We must have a roadmap of where we are to go and which way actually leads there. God has indeed revealed all this and more which is to be accepted through faith in Him.
Secondly, satan is the author of confusion - he spawns off the other religions through his deceptions to keep people from going to the one true God. But people hold on to these erroneous beliefs only because they seek not the truth. They've heard and want to continue hearing what their itching ears want to hear. Nobody who seeks the truth can ever be lost apart from Christ.
So agnosticism breaks down to either atheism or an attempt to find the one true God's revelation among the religions of the world that claim divine origins. If agnostics mean that the true God cannot be known from among the religions of the world, then that's just laziness. But if they mean that their concept of God is not that of the one defined above but rather a spiritual life-force that drives our world and our lives, then C.S.Lewis best sums it up......
"...But to be complete I ought to mention the Inbetween view called Life-Force philosophy, or Creative Evolution, or Emergent Evolution....People who hold this view say that the small variations by which life on this planet 'evolved' from the lowest forms to Man were not due to chance but to the 'striving' or 'purposiveness' of a Life-Force. When people say this we must ask them whether by Life-Force they mean something with a mind or not. If they do, then ' a mind bringing life into existence and leading it to perfection' is really a God, and their view is thus identical with the Religious. If they do not, then what is the sense in saying that something without a mind 'strives' or has 'purposes'? This seems to me fatal to their view. One reason why many people find Creative Evolution so attractive is that it gives one much of the emotional comfort of believing in God and none of the less pleasant consequences. When you are feeling fit and the sun is shining and you do not want to believe that the whole universe is a mere mechanical dance of atoms, it is nice to be able to think of this great mysterious Force rolling on through the centuries and carrying you on its crest. If, on the other hand, you want to do something rather shabby, the Life-Force, being only a blind force, with no morals and no mind, will never interfere with you like that troublesome God we learned about when we were children. The Life-Force is a sort of tame God. You can switch it on when you want, but it will not bother you. All the thrills of religion and none of the cost.Is the Life-Force the greatest achievement of wishful thinking the world has yet seen?"
- C.S.Lewis, Mere Christianity
So we see that a spiritual Life-Force breaks down to our definition of God to have purpose and meaning or breaks down to meaningless chance if it lacks purpose and meaning. In the other views of God where even one of the smallest attributes of perfection are removed from God, God just becomes a superiorly abled but nonetheless flawed Being which again cannot be trusted for meaning and purpose - for what meaning is there in a flawed purpose.
I'm not trying to oversimplify things here but looking at it experientially and not from just a theoretical viewpoint, all meaning and purpose and thereby hope is found in a perfect God who has to have revealed His intents and consequently our purpose of existence through one of the religions of the world claiming divine origins.
The only assumption in my argument so far is that mankind has to have meaning and purpose. I haven't justified or proved this assumption because I take it experientially but any objection to this only implies that some actually are fine with their lives being without meaning and purpose - this seems hypocritical because I'm sure(experientially) that they are trying to substitute this lack of meaning found in God with the 'meaning' of excelling in and enjoying this life to the maximum extant possible. A life that is merely meant to be survived and within that objective, to be made best use of, actually lacks overall meaning. If people would rather be epicureans, they're just being the rebels that the Bible talks about - those who would avoid God at all costs so that they can hold on to their imperfections that the Holy God finds abhorring while pursuing and satisfying their lusts. They are indeed without excuse on the Day of Judgement. (Romans 1:18-22)
On the other hand, I believe that it is God who has given us this desire to question our existence and thereby seek God in order to know more about Him, to see His love and grace, to love Him in return and hence derive our meaning and purposes linked to His will.
So, we arrive at trying to find out which of the world religions claiming divine origins is absolutely true. I hope nobody's beliefs are offended but a search for truth always brings up falsehoods that we might have always held on to, but the effort to let go these falsehoods shouldn't keep us from knowing the truth. For it's the truth (Christ) who sets us completely free from all the slavery of sin, deceit and falsehoods. I believe that people follow other religions because they just might be misguided in their beliefs through the deceptions of satan. What makes me so sure that I'm not misguided - not any of my human wisdom but purely God's grace and revelation. I too was deceived by satan's lies, my own self-pride and rebellion until Christ set me free. I have no claim in the discovery of truth - it was pure revelation by grace. I pray that God's grace abounds in all of you who are seeking God. I oft repeat this promise of God -
Jer 29:13 And you shall seek Me and find Me, when you search for Me with all your heart.
I know none of what I say about myself and my convictions can be proved or backed up with empirical data. But that's the case with anyone's faith. That's why this post puts forth some arguments of the mind, so you may have something to evaluate that could help build your faith, but you also need to accept these in your heart. May the grace of our God enable you to do so. Else, we're not building faith but rather are vainly philosophizing.
Continuing, a simple elimination process of religions is found in these verses from Acts 5:33-39 -
Act 5:34 Then there stood up one in the sanhedrin, a Pharisee named Gamaliel, a doctor of the Law honored among all the people.....[and said]
Act 5:38 ....... For if this counsel or this work is of men, it will come to nothing.
Act 5:39 But if it is of God, you cannot overthrow it, lest perhaps you be found even to fight against God.
So, a revelation from the All-Powerful God cannot die out. This leaves us just the religions that are prevalent today and which also claim divine origins. The ones that I know of are - Christianity, Hinduism(with Personal God), Islam and Judaism. My knowledge is limited here. If there are any other religions/religious beliefs that believe in a personal God, claim divine origins and that are prevalent today, then I'd include them as they're pointed out.
The variants of the above religions are not included here because it's the basic doctrines that need to be tested first and if these are shown to be non-contradictory, then perhaps further exploration can be carried out. Religions like Buddhism are not included because there is no divine origin or revelations of God - so it's by its own admission, a man-made(Buddha) system of beliefs.
Obviously, none of the religions can be intellectualized or emotionalized into truth - so let's just start by searching out contradictions within themselves and with our experiential observations.
I'll continue in following posts....