- Thread starter
- #141
Drew said:whirlwind said:Christ was sent to the "lost sheep of the house of Israel." He was of the house of Judah, a Jew, through His mother Mary but He was not sent to them...nor were His disciples. They, the house of Israel, are not nor ever have been Jews.
- Matthew 10:6 But go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
15:24 But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
He was sent to them and...He found us. We carry His name.
Wow. I have never seen this argument. Let me see if I understand you - you are saying that Jesus' mission was narrowly focused on the lost 10 tribes, to the exclusion of Judah? I do not see how such an argument can work. You are leveraging the ambiguity of the term "Israel" in support of an hypothesis that is otherwise entirely untenable.
Dear Drew...do you or do you not believe His Words. It is not me that is saying anything. It doesn't matter what I believe...it is what is written. Accept it or not.
We all know, or at least should know, that the term "Israel" has multiple connotations. Sometimes it denotes all 12 tribes, and, as much as I suspect this will only feed your exegitical errors, sometimes it refers to the church, and, of course, sometimes it refers to the 10 tribes.
But, there is every reason to believe that when Jesus refers to being sent to "the lost sheep of Israel", he is referring to all Jews, not just the 10 northern tribes as you seem to think.
Biblically, Jews does not nor ever has referred to Israel. Jews are of Israel but not all Israel are Jews.
The reasons for this are many. Throughout his ministry, Jesus preached to the Jews of Judah, calling them to a new way of living and critiquing their leaders. He even declares himself to the the chief cornerstone of the temple, the center of of life for the tribe of Judah. So it is very hard to make the case that Jesus' ministry does not include the tribe of Judah.
I didn't say it did or did not include Judah. I quoted His Words. Please refer to them. Also consider that as the Chief Cornerstone it is of the living temple...that is us. We are the temple.
It is true that there is indeed a sense in which we, the church can see ourselves as Israel. But, as the Romans 9 example so clearly shows, we cannot apply the over-simplified hermeutical key of thinking that every reference to Israel is a reference to the church.whirlwind said:Some of us are Israel by lineage others of us are Israel through belief. Either way, we are His chosen and His letter, the Bible, is written to us...for all time until the end of time. And...if that is "foolishness" to you and others then...so be it. [/b]
References to Israel are to God's chosen....all twelve tribes and that would include those that become Israel through belief. Thus...the Jeremiah quote pertains to us.