Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is this rude, or am I out of step with the times...

handy

Member
It's happened again....

We got another wedding invitation. This one, from a couple who have been living together sans marriage for about two years now. This is a distant cousin of his... I had to ask him to remind me who she was because we don't normally keep in contact with her, but we do send cards and pics of the kids to her mother, a cousin of Steve's mom and Steve's mom was able to fill us in on the details of her and her fiance.

They are both older, she's in her late 20's and he in his early 30's and they have a little girl. She also has a daughter from a previous relationship and he's been a good dad to her. They own their own home and have been established in life for a number of years now. Both are working professionals, she in the medical field and he in a corporation.

Oh, and they live out of state and given the distance of both the relationship and the wedding itself, Steve doesn't want to go, especially since we can't afford a trip to PA this summer.

I'm glad they are getting married, if only because they have children and I think it's best kids have parents who are married to each other. To my knowledge, they're not Christians. But, I really don't know them at all. I met her once back in 2006, when we were at a family reunion picnic and we chatted with her for about 3 minutes.

So, we get this invitation to their wedding... and in the invitation there is a little card that basically says, "We don't need gifts, if you choose to honor us with one, please send money." OK, that isn't exactly how it's phrased, but that's the bottom line.

This is about the third wedding invitation we've received that had a "money only" note in it and they've all been from people who've lived together and have already established their household...one couple specified that the money would fund their honeymoon trip to Hawaii.

I just find this very rude. Like, just because they decide to make their living arrangement a legal one and throw an expensive party for it, we're supposed to give them a chunk of money. Maybe I'm turning into a cranky old woman, but why should we help fund a trip to Hawaii for two people who had lived as a couple for over 5 years, when we can't even afford to take the kid's to Roaring Springs or Boondocks?

Growing up in the '70's, I was taught that Bridal Showers helped give the bride the things she would need for her new home, sheets, towels, flatware, pots and pans, etc.... and wedding gifts were for giving the young couple some nice things, things they wouldn't really be able to afford to buy for themselves for a while... a place setting of their nice china, crystal glasses, cut glass vase... If one didn't know the specific taste of the couple one could always give a nice card with some cash in it, or, if one knew the couple didn't have a lot, one could give both the silver candelabra and some cash.

But, then again, that was back in the day when living together before marriage wasn't common (at least it wasn't in my neck of the woods) and couples were much, much younger, just out of college or even just out of high school. Most were moving from their parents home into their first apartment or starter house.

It's not that I mind giving presents to couples that have a long established household together... when some neighbors of ours turned back to God and wanted to honor Him by getting married after living together for 18 years, we sent them a gift certificate to a really nice restaurant. We figured after 18 years, 5 kids, 4 dogs and who knows how many cats, a little get away for the two them with a meal she didn't have to cook would be nice.

But, to have couples that have long established their home ask me to give them money just because they decided to tie the knot?

Have any of you been given invitations with money vouchers in them? How do you feel about it?
 
YES it is rude...And gifts are not in order.... Nothing like raising your flower girl...:eeeekkk The whole wedding thing has become like secular Christmas

Dora, the big WHITE wedding dress was a signal of virginity. I felt so strongly about that in 1964 :sad my dress was not white.

What you did for your neighbours :thumbsup
 
It's happened again.

This is about the third wedding invitation we've received that had a "money only" note in it and they've all been from people who've lived together and have already established their household...one couple specified that the money would fund their honeymoon trip to Hawaii.

I just find this very rude. Like, just because they decide to make their living arrangement a legal one and throw an expensive party for it, we're supposed to give them a chunk of money. Maybe I'm turning into a cranky old woman, but why should we help fund a trip to Hawaii for two people who had lived as a couple for over 5 years, when we can't even afford to take the kid's to Roaring Springs or Boondocks?
You don't even KNOW them, therefore, the mail from them is spam. That is my take on it, anyway.

Yes, it is rude of them. And yes, you ARE out of step with the times - as I am.
I promise to STAY out of step with the times.
 
I was feeling a little "spammed" about it myself and yes, there are definitely things I want to stay out of step with as well... this whole money voucher thing for weddings is one of them.



Reba, white dresses have so lost the symbolism it once had that Viola isn't even thinking about getting a white dress. We talk "wedding" every now and then, what girl isn't thinking about her wedding day occasionally...

Anyway, we were talking about weddings and specifically what she wants for her wedding and she told me that she wants her bridesmaids to wear floor length formal in whatever color they choose and she is going to wear a light green dress.

At first I was going to say, "Wait, you'll be the bride, you should be in white"... then I got to really thinking about wedding dresses and figured... let her wear what she wants. :shrug
 
I'm with you! Wedding seem like no more than a 'how much of everyone else's money can we spend' party.
Really?? You need to spend $1000 on a cake???? $10,000 on a dress,etc....

I wish people put as much into their marriages as they do their weddings.......

Oh yeah, SPAM.....DELETE....
 
As a former wedding DJ and videographer, it would amaze me to watch people spend $40K on one day for about six hours. Now if you can afford it and it won't stress you out when you are actually married, cool. But for those people that max out their credit cards, rob Peter to pay Paul, and can't enjoy the honeymoon phase of their marriage because they are working to pay for 1 day is CRAZY!!! :nono2
 
As a former wedding DJ and videographer, it would amaze me to watch people spend $40K on one day for about six hours. Now if you can afford it and it won't stress you out when you are actually married, cool. But for those people that max out their credit cards, rob Peter to pay Paul, and can't enjoy the honeymoon phase of their marriage because they are working to pay for 1 day is CRAZY!!! :nono2

Whoo boy, I bet you could write a book!
 
white dresses comes from the jews. its means just that. PURITY. and yes you arent rude. my brother when married again to his second wife didnt do that. i know you saw them photos ,dora, on my page.
 
Send 'em a book of McDonald's gift certificates with a note that it's obvious they are hard up and need a decent meal.

Just kidding. Don't send the note. Just send the McDonald's gift certificates. ;)
 
Handy i have been to a few weddings like this lately and in some ways getting gifts might double up on what a couple living together already have.

In what a wedding will cost you to attend I think no gift would be more than fair.

petrol up to $!00
hairdo $60
Suit $200
Good shirt $80
Dress $150

Overnight accommodation $250

Incedentals $100


I think for people who live local and are financially living in excess a small moneteary gift would help pay for thier special day.

Thats the impression I got from the last few weddings I went to.

Some weddings these days cost about $10,000 for a basic one.

A few thousand dollars buys you a BBQ in the backyard these days.

I hope that helps anyway
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It amazes me how the average person these days has such little regard to common decency.

No,its not just you..Id trash the invitation and gladly share with them why I didnt go as well as what I thought of it if asked later.

Furthermore,if you dont need gifts why would you ask for cash handouts?? Its almost like the ones you see running around with money pinned to their shirt on their birthday obviously advertising the desire for more. Trashy.
 
I don't know if that's common these days (most of my friends who get hitched ask for presents), but even if its common, its rude. Kind of like checking your facebook at work is common, but its still not OK.

Anyway, I say just trash the invite. Distant cousin? You have your own financial concerns? Yeah...no. These people are--sorry to sound harsh--low on the priority list.
 
I would not send the cash. Yes it is rude and cash is a thoughtless gift (usually).


I am thankful for every wedding gift I recieved and all of them were needed. Most of the items are still in my house and I often think of the person who sent them to me. If I had asked for cash then I would not have these wonderful physical reminders of the people who helped celebrate my marriage, even if the people that did not come to my wedding.
 
I don't know if that's common these days (most of my friends who get hitched ask for presents), but even if its common, its rude. Kind of like checking your facebook at work is common, but its still not OK.

Anyway, I say just trash the invite. Distant cousin? You have your own financial concerns? Yeah...no. These people are--sorry to sound harsh--low on the priority list.
sometimes people invite you because they think they better so you don't get offended about not getting invited.

A wedding story I heard someone done in Australia is they invited their friends to a joint birthday party at a bowling club or something like that, and when everyone arrived for a casual birthday party they announced it was their wedding. I like that idea, it is low fuss and expense.
 
I will not attend a wedding like that nor will I send money. I don't have anything against those people, but I don't think it is appropriate.
 
I know in many Asian cultures it's customary to give money at weddings - in fact it is incredibly rude not to. But there seems to be a divide on this with Western weddings.

Would it bother you as much if the couple who asked for money hadn't cohabited? I agree that it seems senseless to give couples household items when they already have everything. When I got married I was living in my own place and had every single household item I needed, it would've been pointless to receive eight additional frying pans and two blenders. I felt rude asking guests for specific gifts so I mentioned nothing. Then people complained they didn't know what to get me, so I had to get a registry. But in retrospect I wish I asked for money instead to those who really wanted to get me something, because of the reasons mentioned above.

The thing with these types of invitations is that they're merely suggestions. You don't have to give them money just because a couple suggested it, just as you don't have to get something out of the gift registry because a couple has one. There's no point grumbling over wedding etiquette or what other people do with their wedding invitations. If you can't attend the wedding, you don't need to give gifts, and if you want to give gifts, you can get whatever you want. The last wedding I attended suggested cash as well, I gave them a small gift instead (didn't know the couple well), and I got a lovely thank you letter just the same. It's such a waste of time to fume over what other people choose to do over minor matters like this.

It's customary to attend a wedding with a gift. I would never, ever attend a wedding empty handed, even if it's at a wedding of someone I disliked. And if the couple doesn't need any particular item, but want cash, why not give them what they want? If my friends needed cash but not any household items, I'd gladly give them cash.
 
Update on this is that between Steve's mom and us, we've decided that the invite was probably because her mom put us on the invite list... more likely as a way to get the news out that they are getting married as opposed to any real expectation of us being there.

We've decided to send a nice card. No gift.

boolnz, (Hi! :wave) Weddings are very culturally oriented things. In Western culture, asking for gifts is considered very rude. Gifts are supposed to come from the heart of the giver. But, our gift giving occasions, Christmas, birthdays, weddings and anniversaries have become more and more "getting" occasions, with many just handing out a list of things others are to buy for them.

I do understand not wanting a lot of stuff when the house is already filled with things. We tend to give cash for wedding for that very reason. Because we were married older and had to combine two separate houses, we really didn't want any gifts at all.

We were going to send the word out through the family and good friends that we didn't want gifts, but were told by quite a few people that people were going to give gifts, no matter what. So, we took a pool of what we had and what could be upgraded or replaced... and I chose a china pattern... then we registered. Folks could go as low as new towels for the bathrooms (Steve's were towels only in the sense they were rectangular and had once been made of terry cloth and mine were the wrong colors for his house) or spring for something off our china pattern, something as simple as a sugar bowl to an entire place setting. The message that got out was, "They already have everything they need and really would prefer no gifts, but if you want to give something they are registered at..." As it was, we got place settings for 10, plus other items in my pattern, a new look for Steve's bedroom, some vases and candy dishes and a few odd ball things. Plus cash. I sent out thank you notes for everything. We weren't overwhelmed with a bunch of stuff we neither wanted nor needed and I don't think anyone felt dunned into giving a gift.

I think the big difference was that we didn't put any mention of gifts or lack thereof in the invitation.

I know due to how many people came to our wedding compared to how many gifts we received that we had guests who took us at our word and didn't give anything but a card... and that was great as far as we were concerned. We really didn't want a bunch of stuff.
 
Back
Top