I do wonder..why he is here and what his motives really are. I do know that he does bring confusion into the mix of what he is saying. Seems to me that alone is enough to be concerned of what effect he is having on others here. My guess is that he goes from forum to forum with the shock and attack method used here, a very intelligent troll, but nonetheless a troll all the same. Yes, very rude, sometimes insulting, and not charitable. Frankly, my guess is that he is mainly trying to stir up reactions rather than actually seeking anything else. Argumentative but not open to change himself. You and others here have taken time with him and giving him attention beyond what he likely is accustomed to receiving and I certainly commend you for doing so. That alone should speak to him. But there are many here in various stages on their Christian journeys and new comers arriving regularly. My take is that for the common good of all...it's time to protect them from further confusion and attack. Prayerfully submitting this, but whatever you administrators decide I will support. Thanks for including us in the conversation.