Free said:Interestingly enough, both JWs and Mormonism came about from the rejection of orthodox Christianity.MM said:No, you are not sticking to the topic of this thread. You say you are, but you are not ! I am not a JW, but I still feel, that my JW brethren should not be put down in such a manner. This is the reason I even entered this thread. I believe that they have many errors within their understandings of scripture. But I also believe , that many Christians hold to an divisive stance, just to cause division among the brethren. Such is the case here.
And this begs the question of what is and is not a man-made doctrine. Your unsupported opinion is that it is man-made (ie. taken to be unsupported by Scripture), it is the opinion of orthodox Christianity and this site that the Trinity is, in the least, a doctrine formed by man based completely on all that Scripture reveals.MM said:Christianity is only bound by the scriptures, and nothing else. Man made doctrines do not stand up to the scriptures. And that is why there is conflict and division. Men who go around and make false claims as to whom is and who is not a Christian, based upon a man made doctrine, will find themselves the cause of division.
Only in your opinion does your come from Scripture. From my opinion, and that of historic, orthodox Christianity, the idea that Jesus is very much God in nature, yet not the Father, is fully supported from Scripture.MM said:I agree, Jesus Christ is divine, and is deity. Again, we have unity. But where we can not agree, is on the use and definition of the words "divine" and "deity". That is because you take a different approach on the issue. Your approach is from your core beliefs. Mine comes from reasoning out the scriptures.
I have yet to have my stronger arguments adequately answered or even engaged, and they are all based on Scripture.
And yet you so willingly tell others who disagree with you that they are carnally minded. :gah The Scriptures even tells Christians we are to judge whether doctrine is correct or not. It makes it clear that there are false teachers who teach of another Christ. It is also clear that who Christ is is absolutely central to believing in him and becoming a follower.MM said:I find no peace nor any joy in you telling me or others that they are not a christian.
Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God. For flesh and blood has not revealed this unto you, but my Father which is in heaven. < Is this a good enough source ?