Yeah, the lyrics are the most important.
My pastor would say several things about the lyrics to modern songs. He'd say things like they'd say "You" instead of "God", they sound like they're talking to their latest boyfriend instead of God, they don't like to sing about Jesus' blood, they were "watered down", etc. I had had exposure to some of these songs, and I knew he wasn't fully correct (some of it was partially true), but I partially believed him for a long time, anyway.
When I found Casting Crowns, none of that was true about them. (Like I said, some of it is true about some songs, but some of those I've come to believe are not necessarily a bad thing. Does it really matter if you say "You" instead of "God", as long as you know who you're talking about? And that they never say anything about Jesus' blood is simply not true. He obviously hasn't listened to very many CCM songs.
Not all bands are as straightforward as Casting Crowns, and that's fine. There is plenty to choose from in the realm of Christian music, anyway.
Anyway, another one of the early songs by Casting Crowns I listened to was Voice of Truth.
And I'm listening to it right now.

..