S
SputnikBoy
Guest
StoveBolts said:SputnikBoy, I think that you have some honest questions, and I also think that you’re looking for specific answers which are really good things. Let’s say for a moment though, that we can’t find any scripture to satisfy your specific question. Does that nullify scripture as a whole? If that’s the case, then I think there would be a lot of loop holes for salvation. Would you agree with that statement?
Could be but we should not simply assume that one's genetics are to be considered such a loop hole. The above are merely your words formed into a sentence. They are not divine.
Christians (many of them) use their Bibles as a law book that they wield like a weapon. But …only for CERTAIN things it would appear. While every other ‘abomination to God’ (of which there are many – and that includes the rather ‘lowly’ act of ‘lying’) seems to be all but ignored by Christians, the ‘sin’ of homosexuality stands out like a beacon. It has become an obsession by Christians, so –yes – I most definitely DO want scriptures to satisfy my specific question.
StoveBolts said:The way I see it though, is that scripture makes it pretty clear that homosexuality is a sin… So does it really matter why one sins?
That’s the way you see it and that’s fine …that’s your perspective on the issue. But, I don’t agree that the Bible is ‘pretty clear’ at all that genetically engineered homosexuality IS a sin. You DO realize, of course, that some mods get really nervous when this issue is raised so one has to be very careful how one expresses their opinion just in case – heaven forbid – one might be seen to be promoting homosexuality.
So, I’m rather walking on eggshells here and you know it. I’ll make my point yet again that homosexuality is a taboo topic among Christendom that far surpasses ANY other so-called ‘abomination’ in scripture. If this doesn’t suggest something to you, Stove (you’re a smart cookie), then it should.
StoveBolts said:Let’s say for a moment that one was ‘wired’ that way from birth, does that then justify ones sin?
Huh? We have opposing opinions on this issue of genetics, Stove. If one is ‘naturally’ predisposed to an attraction for the same gender, why then would that be construed as a sin? Please understand that my entire ‘argument’ here is that the Bible gives no more reference to the complex issue of genetics than it does to designing a rocket to take us to Mars.
Without the Bible and without the ‘norms’ of the society within which we live, we would not necessarily kill or steal or dishonor our neighbor or behave like wild animals. Our conscience is a powerful part of us and it dictates what is morally right and what is morally wrong. In that situation (minus the Bible and the ‘norms’ of society) would two homosexuals who were ‘that way’ from as far back as they remember live a life of celibacy based on their conscience alone? Or might they fall in love with each other and not think anything ‘immoral’ in that? I don’t know. I’m just being hypothetical.
StoveBolts said:You may not agree, but the only way to justify ones sins happened over 2000 years ago when Jesus hung on the Cross. Likewise, IT was accredited to Abraham as righteousness, and IT would be Abraham’s faith. And so it is that we should be made righteous in our faith through Christ that justifies our sin. Romans 4:23-25
That’s nice, Stove, and so typically ‘Christian’ and rhetorical. But it does NOT address my original question. Remember, while I can’t speak for everyone or every situation, I don’t hold to the view that (genuine) homosexuals are heterosexuals behaving badly.
StoveBolts said:I’d like to look at this from two points of view. First, we are all sinners and here’s a verse that I’m sure that you’re familiar with.
Romans 3:23 For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;
So think about it for a second… who qualifies for salvation? Simple, Sinners do. And who qualifies as a sinner? Everyone. So, does it really matter what kind of sin it is? To a degree, the answer would be yes because not all sins lead to death.
Yet again, we are not referring here to one’s sins in general. Or, at least, I’m not. Of course we’re all sinners. I (again) don’t hold to the mainline Christian belief that homosexuality in and of itself (in the true sense of the genetic meaning) is a sin. I’m sorry. I’m not meaning to argue for the sake of it even though ‘the Relics’ of this forum seem to think so. Like Mr.Spock of Star Trek, I prefer logic more so than wispy touchy-feely emotional stuff. If I see logic absent from anything – including the Bible – I will question it. I may well be frowned on as a ‘heretic’ but that isn’t my problem.
StoveBolts said:1 John 5:16 If any man see his brother sin a sin which is not unto death, he shall ask, and he shall give him life for them that sin not unto death. There is a sin unto death: I do not say that he shall pray for it.
But first we need to establish just what IS a sin, don’t we? If I were to look for ‘the sin of homosexuality’ from the Bible alone, the sparse texts that might even address this topic are so ambiguous that I would not be convinced. The ‘sin’ part of homosexuality has come from within ‘Christianity’ itself as well as society in general. Society started ‘the witch-hunt’ on homosexuals first. The scriptures came second.
Furthermore, the overwhelming majority of Christians who froth at the mouth over this issue would be hard pressed to even locate the scriptures that may pertain to this issue if put on the spot. They would need to do a Bible Concordance search because they haven't a clue. Even then they would not know EXACTLY what the texts are referring to. Tell me that I’m wrong.
StoveBolts said:So, based on this concept, what sins lead to death and which ones don’t? I think the answer is pretty clear when we look at what it takes to be saved, and that is repentance + Faith + Grace. I don’t see a need to post verse after verse here, but in just about every case I can think of the sinner has to repent before he becomes a Christian. But it doesn’t stop here either…
Colossians 3:12 Put on therefore, as the elect of God, holy and beloved, bowels of mercies, kindness, humbleness of mind, meekness, longsuffering;
Colossians 3:13 Forbearing one another, and forgiving one another, if any man have a quarrel against any: even as Christ forgave you, so also do ye.
Colossians 3:14 And above all these things put on charity, which is the bond of perfectness.
As far as the second point of view… well, here’s enough for now. However, I would like to leave you with a thought. Does it matter why one sins, or is it more important with what ones does after he sins?
Absolutely, Stove. But, assuming that I had a ‘sexual’ attraction for specific (certainly not ALL) people of the same gender that I had never asked for, why would I assume that this was ‘a sin’ or, more to the point, ‘unnatural’ to begin with? Answer: because the ‘norms’ of society have dictated this to me since day one. People are acquainted with this concept before they ever pick up a Bible. I would have been raised with the understanding that my ultimate aim in life is to pair off with someone of the opposite sex, fall in love, marry, have children and settle down (yawn).
My children would also be expected not to deviate from this ‘norm’. To do otherwise would be frowned upon. Everyone needs a partner of the opposite sex – particularly within Christian circles – or the tongues will start wagging. And, on it goes. We forever have to live up to expectations, particularly so if we’re a member of a church whose population are, first and foremost, members of the society in which they live. If I arrive at church each week with a friend of the same gender it won’t be too long before the rumors start flying.
By the way, I am not a homosexual (although Relic does sound kinda cute :smt007 ) – not that I need to justify myself to anyone – and I look at this issue purely from a logical and a scientific perspective. The Bible offers me no answers in this regard and so I still question this obsession by Christians to damn other human beings to hell because of a possible difference in chromosomes.