I enjoy John Mac Arthur. I am not exposed to many American Pastors, The pastor at the Church I belong to is sound in doctrine and cares for the church and the community. He is involved in bringing the young people that enter our local university into the Church. He is also involved in the lives of many of the older folk in our church and we have a good mix. Our local Baptist Church was started in the 1820's when our town began and is the oldest Baptist Church in South Africa.
When myself and my family were having difficult times he came to visit us personally, to guide and to pray for us. Since attending the church It has had three other pastors, one left for England, another passed away, the other was a temporary post until the church called our current pastor. I was baptized by my current pastor. He has also got me to be more involved in the local church and I currently am a leader in the mens ministry, and although I may not be the greatest speaker, I have stepped out of my protective layers that I have put around myself for years. That includes excessive drinking etc.
I would not think it fair to judge a pastor on the amount of people he brings into the church, but more on the correctness of the gospel he preaches. I personally feel that many of the larger more growing churches, like Joel Osteen's church, do not preach the real gospel and mislead many in the true meaning of the gospel. There are many great preachers out in the world, many great talkers, but the ones that are guided by the holy spirit and the ones that are scripturally sound, to me, are the great ones. Not the ones they show on TBN, they continually preach false gospel that corrupt the minds of so many. I hate money seeking churches, that teach prosperity only to fill their own coffers.