Hey, Shana!
Hope you're well.
You wrote:
God punishes sin, but there is no evidence that there would be the penalty of an eternal hell for sinners. What would it have accomplished if there had been and if it is true?
Apart from serving to execute God's perfect justice, not much, apparently. The Israelites, for instance, had a long and intimate relationship with God. They had seen both His blessing and His punishment. Nonetheless, again and again they grew apathetic and rebellious toward Him. It seems neither God's goodness nor His wrath could long prevent them from following the selfish bent of their sin-cursed hearts. And this remains true even to today. Many people know of the concept of Hell. Few give it any serious consideration. They are willing to take their chances, hoping the Bible is all wrong. Really, I'm not so sure God intends for Hell to serve primarily as a threat hung over the heads of people. I think its first and foremost purpose is not to scare people, but, as I said, simply to execute God's judgment upon the wicked. Scripture allows for Hell to be used as a threat (Jude 1:23), but I think God recognizes that you draw more flies with honey than vinegar.
But here is the thing-God is described as agape love...
God is, above all, holy. In fact, Scripture says that He is "Holy, holy, holy." God isn't described as "Love, love, love," or "friendly, friendly, friendly". Only concerning His holiness is He thrice-declared. ONe must, then, reason about God with His holiness preeminent. Putting anything else before this characteristic will produce faulty conclusions about Him.
He will have all to be saved and come to a knowledge of the truth - even the wicked.
Sorry to nitpick, but we all fall under the heading of "wicked" before we are saved. :wink: :-D
[/quote]Does this exclude those who lived before Jesus came to earth?[/quote]
You know, the Bible clearly states that God does as He pleases with what He has made -- even including destroying it:
"As it is written, 'Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated.' What shall we say then? Is there unrighteousness with God? God forbid. For He says to Moses, 'I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion....Therefore has He mercy on whom He will, and whom He will He hardens (ie. Pharaoh)...Has not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honor and another unto dishonor?" Romans 9:18-21 The passage goes on to speak more of vessels made unto honor and vessels fitted to destruction. As the Creator of all, God has carte blanche to do as He wills, to bless or destroy His creations. This is His Sovereign prerogative. A sobering thought in an age where the biblical concept of God, by the exaggeration of His love at the expense of His other attributes, has been warped to such a degree that His holy judgment is now denied.
If the penalty of an eternal hell is what happens to the lost for all of eternity and if God loves all men, why not the warning at the beginning of time?
As I said before, I think that, even without knowing of Hell, they had cause to expect and fear God's judgment of sin. Today, with the knowledge of Hell before them, people carry on more or less as the Israelites did in the OT. For this reason, I don't think knowing of Hell would have made much, if any, difference to the conduct of OT people.
Why is this eternal punishment not screaming from every page of the Holy Scriptures?
What kind of a book would the Bible be if it were? It would be quite horrible, I think! Obviously, there was more that God wanted us to know. I'm sure God, being the perfect being that He is, mentioned Hell just the right number of times in HIs Word. Goodness! You'd think once would be enough! :o
Why even preach this today if it is true, it will have no effect?
I think I already answered this. :D
but God is also described as the Savior of all men.
This is a potential truth, not an actual one. "Wide is the road and narrow the gate", remember?
Evidently God's love overrules any "hatred" for men as described in the scriptures because Jesus died for the wicked, for us believers who were once wicked. Jesus taught us to love our enemies and to be perfect as our Heavenly Father is perfect. It follows then that God loves His enemies, the wicked.God bless.
As I think I've shown, its not quite that simple, Shana. :D
God bless you, too!
In Christ, Aiki.