Join For His Glory for a discussion on how
https://christianforums.net/threads/a-vessel-of-honor.110278/
https://christianforums.net/threads/psalm-70-1-save-me-o-god-lord-help-me-now.108509/
Read through the following study by Tenchi for more on this topic
https://christianforums.net/threads/without-the-holy-spirit-we-can-do-nothing.109419/
Join Sola Scriptura for a discussion on the subject
https://christianforums.net/threads/anointed-preaching-teaching.109331/#post-1912042
Strengthening families through biblical principles.
Focus on the Family addresses the use of biblical principles in parenting and marriage to strengthen the family.
Read daily articles from Focus on the Family in the Marriage and Parenting Resources forum.
Quoting from Deborah13's post where she quoted John Gill is the best way that I can respond to your assertion that the sin the Christian commits and his old sin nature are one and the same thing:Whoa Jethro
I didn't even finish readng your post yet.
You say that any sin we commit simply does not come from a mind set ON THE FLESH, but that it comes from THE FLESH ITSELF, NOT FROM A SIN NATURE.
I've been asking you forever what it is that makes us sin if the sin nature is gone. Your reply to JLB explains to me the fallacy of your understanding - which is:
THE FLESH AND THE SIN NATURE ARE ONE AND THE SAME THING!
So, what you're saying in your 1st pp above, that it's the flesh itself causing us to sin and not the sin nature is theologically incorrect, since they are one and the same thing. In the N.T. you could replace sin nature with flesh and V V. They are one and the same. So if you believe it's the FLESH making us sin, what you're saying is that it's the SIN NATURE that makes us sin.
Wondering
there is a difference between flesh being in persons, from which none are free in this life, and their being in the flesh
That's not what Paul says:BY NATURE we are and will always be an object of God's wrath.
Because the flesh itself and it's desires is not what died in Christ--the mind set on those desires and which held us in bondage to those desires is what died in Christ and has been replaced by a mind set on the desires of the Spirit. This truth, this knowledge, is what helps us resist the ghost of our old nature when sinful desires spring up in our flesh.why would we have to learn if we have killed the sin nature?
Not only are we dead to the law, but dead to sin, too (Romans 6:6,11 NASB). That's the part you're missing in Paul's discourse which sets the context of Romans 7 and his analogy of marriage. In fact, it's because we are dead to sin that we are then dead to the law....dead to the power and the authority of the law to arouse and provoke sin in us. And as Paul explains that's because the law can no longer exert legal authority to keep us, the wife, bound in a 'marriage' to a husband who has died. That husband being our old mind set on the things of the flesh whom we served like a wife submits to and serves a husband--a relationship the law of Moses enforced like a legal certificate of marriage, not delivered us from.Therefore, my brethren, you also have become dead to the law ...
Not sin nature, dead to the law.
Hi DeborahRom_8:15 for ye did not receive a spirit of bondage again for fear, but ye did receive a spirit of adoption in which we cry, `Abba--Father.'
Gal_4:6 and because ye are sons, God did send forth the spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying, `Abba, Father!'
Sorry Jethro. I'm not reading John Gill. I don't do the posting game. I'm explaining to you in my own words and backing them up with scripture, a traditional Christian concept which is accepted by most churches, at least those who wish to remain pure in their thought. Being an intelligent person, you know full well that I could find 100 posts that will not agree with John Gill. Whatever it is he believes.Quoting from Deborah13's post where she quoted John Gill is the best way that I can respond to your assertion that the sin the Christian commits and his old sin nature are one and the same thing:
Yes Smaller. I see where you're coming from. I agree totally. Even with your last two sentences.
I don't know about being put here purposefully with Divine intent together with the evil one.
Can something not good come from God? Which is why at stop at "where does satan come from."
He does ALLOW evil though. OTOH, your understanding of this could work in explaining evil, but it breaks one of the three omni's, doesn't it? God is omnipotent. No power to do away with the evil? Why would He want it?
Plus, He has to be all good, no? Yes. This is mysterious to me and I have no answer and have been looking for MANY years. So I just accept. But I do agree with the difference you explain. sin vs sins.
Jesus said even though in your thought you lust, or in your hate you kill ... Mathew 5:21-22 and Mathew 5:27
(or VV). So yes, wretched man that I am, what will save me from this body of death? Romans 7:24
And this is why we need Jesus. So God will see Him and not us.
But some might take this idea to mean that Jesus did not win satan and sin. It's all words after all. Humans trying to explain and understand spirit.
Wondering
Right. It has to do with whether or not you still are 'in the flesh' having the nature of sin. If you are still in the flesh you are being controlled by the sin nature.
That's what it means to have the nature of something. You're programmed by nature to be something, regardless of how you may act to the contrary. Maybe people aren't getting what it means to be something 'by nature'.
Are you suggesting that you have made zero progress toward not sinning in thought or deed?
Zero progress signifies that a change of nature has not occurred.
It does not signify that the two natures are somehow co-existing with each other and the old one is ruling. That's saying we have both a mind set on the desires of the flesh, and a mind set on the desires of the Spirit. But Paul makes it clear that the believer has the mind set on the Spirit. That is our new nature. Our old nature was a mind set on the flesh.
He says we are NOT in the flesh anymore by virtue of having the Spirit within us. He did not say we are not in the flesh when we obey the Spirit. He said we have the mind of the Spirit by having the Spirit.
That husband being our old mind set on the things of the flesh whom we served like a wife submits to and serves a husband--a relationship the law of Moses enforced like a legal certificate of marriage, not delivered us from.
The above is for Smaller. Don't know if he answered.
But I'd like to say the because one believes we retain the sin nature it doesn't mean that we're not making progress toward not sinning in thought or deed.
That's where the learning comes in, which you mentioned and I answered to in post no. 257. You yourself say we have to learn. Again, why would we have to learn if we have killed the sin nature?
Please remember that sin nature and flesh is the same idea when Paul is speaking. Remember that he's speaking to Christians. He exhorts them not to sin.
Hebrews 10:26
Paul is speaking to Christians sinning willfully. How do we sin willfully if the sin nature/flesh is gone?
In post 235 you say:
As believers we no longer have the mind that drives sinful desires.
That's not what not having a sin nature means. It does not mean we become sinless. It means we are no longer owned and controlled by a mind set on the things of the flesh, like a wife is to her husband and a slave to their master.There was never a sinless flesh promised in the Gospels nor were we excused from the facts of having evil present with us no matter how good we get at HIDING IT or claiming it to be "legally obedient" or "under Grace" or "unseen" because THAT did not happen and never will.
Sin nature -- mind set on the things of the flesh: One and the same thing.Before, the husband was the sin nature. Since several people have shown you how the sin nature is not dead, but still produces sinful desires, now you have changed your terminology, and the husband is an "old mind set"
Not having the sin nature doesn't mean pretending you don't sin. It means not HAVING to sin because we are in bondage to sin like a woman is in submissive bondage to a husband. That is what ended....our bondage to sin because of having the nature that requires that of us. If we are in bondage to sin after receiving a new nature that desires righteousness it can be for several reasons but it definitely is not because you are still in bondage to a mind set on the things of the flesh.Oh yes, my nature has indeed changed. I'm not a liar about the facts. Nor do I have to "put on otherwise" when in the presence of others who are likewise fond of acting otherwise. I have a great detest for hypocrisy, particularly in myself.
Lol, correct, our indwelling sin did not get a 'new nature'. WE did....if we believe in Christ. The old mind set on the things of the flesh got replaced by a mind set on the things of the Spirit. Paul says if you still have a mind set on the things of the flesh (what he calls being 'in the flesh') you simply do not have the Spirit of God in you and you do not belong to him. Of course, you're probably hearing that as 'you won't sin anymore'. But what it means is you don't HAVE to sin anymore like a wife has to obey and submit to husband.Our indwelling sin didn't get a "new nature." If anything the opposite transpires.
Sin nature -- mind set on the things of the flesh: One and the same thing.
That's not what not having a sin nature means. It does not mean we become sinless.
It means we are no longer owned and controlled by a mind set on the things of the flesh, like a wife is to her husband and a slave to their master.
Sin nature -- mind set on the things of the flesh: One and the same thing.
Not having the sin nature doesn't mean pretending you don't sin. It means not HAVING to sin
because we are in bondage to sin like a woman is in submissive bondage to a husband. That is what ended....our bondage to sin
because of having the nature that requires that of us. If we are in bondage to sin after receiving a new nature that desires righteousness it can be for several reasons but it definitely is not because you are still in bondage to a mind set on the things of the flesh.
Lol, correct, or indwelling sin did not get a 'new nature'. WE did....
if we believe in Christ.
Jethro asks
Are you by nature an object of God's wrath, or were you?
When I read this I thought of the 'Abba Father' scriptures.BY NATURE we are and will always be an object of God's wrath.
Yes, we do sin against our Father. Our love is not perfected in our flesh. It takes time, patience, diligence, prayer, and the Word for our flesh to catch up to what God already has done in our spirit when He begot the new creature that we are. "Father, please help me to love others as you have loved me."He taught us to cry "abba, Father". So we are sons now. And do sons not "sin" against their fathers? How many times will they stay out late, not do their homework, smoke, lie to them, etc. It's the love the father has of the son that will allow forgiveness of these "sins". It certainly doesn't mean the son will never sin because he loves his father.
I am not picking on anyone.. Sometimes when i read the threads i see the surface bickering... yet in depth most of us are saying the same thing...
Is our sin nature dead? Boom Slam Dunk... or does it die over a span of time... ? In myself i can see some sinful thoughts / ideas just did drop dead others have revived at times...
Paul found for himself the opposite conclusion. 1 Tim. 1:15.
I do agree with some of the things you have said but this one, not at all. Paul is not saying that he is still a foremost sinner after his conversion. I must respect the language (words) that Paul used.The same guy, Paul, who said SIN NOT simultaneously openly admitted to being the chief of sinners, post salvation!
I would quote you if your words expressed my own thoughts better than I could myself, which would not be unlikely. I don't always write with clarity.Sorry Jethro. I'm not reading John Gill. I don't do the posting game. I'm explaining to you in my own words
Hi, No, we sin because it is our Adamic nature. We sin when we are enticed and tempted, being drawn away by our own lust and desires. Then when we give into our lustful desires it brings forth sin....and sin brings forth death. Satan is the tempter.So because i sin the devil is in me?