Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What is "church"?

Free said:
The problem I see here is that gingercat doesn't like to be told what to believe, which is the same as many people who reject the traditional notion of church. She has admitted such several times.

Free,

Jesus is telling many things what to do to me every day in His NT. I just don't obey people who are not showing much fruit.

The Bible tells us to look for the fruit. This is very simple. Why do you keep avoiding it?

You have thousands of doctrines and denominations. That proves thousands of deceptiveness. Truth is only one. The only way to find the true church is to look for the fruit. Do you get it? I already told you that my church is my family, VOM and my ministry. I know you don't want to accept anything less than your traditional mentality of "church" which I wholeheartedly disagree.
 
Free said:
But you seem to ignore the fact that the opposite is true as well. If your theology isn't biblically sound, it doesn't matter how good your fruit may appear to be. You cannot separate the two.

That is absolutely and unequivocally dead wrong. You have it completely backwards.

God is not going to be giving you a theology test on judgment day my friend. If you think God is going to judge you or anyone by the thoughts you had then you are living in a fantasy world. Theology is not a bad thing but neither is eating halibut steak.

It will be fruits on which Judgment day is based. His fruit in your life or your own fruit that leads to destruction. Read Matthew 25 and learn how to give the little ones a cup of water to drink. And then you mighty be lucky enough to be watching the "Lord, Lord" theologians be cast into the fire.

In fact, Paul makes it abundantly clear to the Corinthians and those who are willing to understand, that theology is a wisdom on a human level that is foolishness to God -child's play. On the other hand, the way of Christ in suffering and love is the Wisdom of God. And that is what Paul means by becoming mature in Christ.
 
HisFriend said:
Free said:
But you seem to ignore the fact that the opposite is true as well. If your theology isn't biblically sound, it doesn't matter how good your fruit may appear to be. You cannot separate the two.

That is absolutely and unequivocally dead wrong. You have it completely backwards.

God is not going to be giving you a theology test on judgment day my friend. If you think God is going to judge you or anyone by the thoughts you had then you are living in a fantasy world. Theology is not a bad thing but neither is eating halibut steak.

It will be fruits on which Judgment day is based. His fruit in your life or your own fruit that leads to destruction. Read Matthew 25 and learn how to give the little ones a cup of water to drink. And then you mighty be lucky enough to be watching the "Lord, Lord" theologians be cast into the fire.

In fact, Paul makes it abundantly clear to the Corinthians and those who are willing to understand, that theology is a wisdom on a human level that is foolishness to God. On the other hand, the way of Christ in suffering and love is the Wisdom of God.


Amen, His friend. :angel:
 
Free

So if "the average building church" teaches that the Bible is the authority and you are applauding gingercat for living that out, then why are you so against "building churches"?

They say it but they do not do it. If so they would not have a church building or pastors, or pulpits etc.

But that is the whole point Henry. By your last sentence you have just moved beyond merely judging fruit, you are now judging the motives of the heart.

You are very talented at reading into things, I am not the judge of anyones heart nor do I want to be. God is the judge and he know what for what.

Imagine that, a shepherd taking care of a flock. How unbiblical... Just what do you think God's purpose is in giving people the gift of being a pastor?

The modern office of the church pastor is totally unbiblical you are correct finally. Oh and the gift of pastor is not in the list, he calls men to be leaders by example not by rule and never is one ever called by such titles, actually Jesus said not to use titles.

Now Gingercat would not mind being told what to believe by a mature Christian she knows and respect, she just isn't interested in being preached at.

I would was just at a teaching meeting not long ago, great time we learned so much from the teachers that day. But that was not a church meeting and though those men are leaders they have no authority over the church.

Imagine that leader who have no authority over others, that is what Jesus said we are to be like. Oh, my the bible says so….
 
Henry:

Where do we keep sheep?

Say these two words out loud:

Pasture

Pastor

That might help you understand. A pastor is a shepherd that tends the flock in the pasture.

And He gave some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers, (Ephesians 4:11).

Pastor... Shepherd.... same thing.
 
HisFriend said:
Henry:

Where do we keep sheep?

Say these two words out loud:

Pasture

Pastor

That might help you understand. A pastor is a shepherd that tends the flock in the pasture.

And He gave some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers, (Ephesians 4:11).

Pastor... Shepherd.... same thing.

Hisfriend,

I know you did not address this to me but I hope you don't mind my answering it.

I am a woman, I looked for church I could attend. I searched about 5 years and could not find any godly church. All of them seemed more focused on the popularity rather than following Jesus. So I gave up and found my own way of serving God. I know He is supporting my decision from the spiritual blessing He has giving me by being useful for other brethren and my family and my own ministry.

The Bible tells us to not to have anything to do with fruitless deeds of darkness. I came to conclusion that many of the organized churches are fruitless. My church is my family, VOM and my ministry.
 
gingercat said:
HisFriend said:
Henry:

Where do we keep sheep?

Say these two words out loud:

Pasture

Pastor

That might help you understand. A pastor is a shepherd that tends the flock in the pasture.

And He gave some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers, (Ephesians 4:11).

Pastor... Shepherd.... same thing.

Hisfriend,

I know you did not address this to me but I hope you don't mind my answering it.

I am a woman, I looked for church I could attend. I searched about 5 years and could not find any godly church. All of them seemed more focused on the popularity rather than following Jesus. So I gave up and found my own way of serving God. I know He is supporting my decision from the spiritual blessing He has giving me by being useful for other brethren and my family and my own ministry.

The Bible tells us to not to have anything to do with fruitless deeds of darkness. I came to conclusion that many of the organized churches are fruitless. My church is my family, VOM and my ministry.

Not sure what that had to do with my post.

What is VOM?

I have not been able to find a church that is not following other gods. They all have a creed that has become a god for them to serve at all costs. Nothing wrong with having intellectual beliefs, however, none of these churches can entertain their beliefs might be found incorrect at some point. In this way, they make their creed a god that absolutely must be served at all costs and they thereby prevent their flocks from following Jesus instead. Indeed, few people can even comprehend the difference between a description of Jesus in concept and Jesus himself anymore. Moreover, Jesus is not followed by having right creeds anyway. Creeds are images. Their is only one creed anyone should have, "Jesus is Lord." Servants always follow their Lord. "Jesus is Lord" means "Listen to his voice and do what he says." And we must allow our intellectual beliefs to change as the Good Teacher teaches each of us the truth. Today's creeds do not allow such a thing. He lives in us to guide us all. We are to follow our Master in faith. Too many people ignore his call to instead serve the creed of their desire and convince themselves that this is the way Jesus wants it to be. It is no wonder they do this for they have been taught that creeds are the way Jesus calls them.

Leaving idols and their worshipers behind is not forsaking the assembly. A Christian is a follower of Christ, not someone who claims they are. Claimants are not necessarily assemblies of Christ. We are called to gather together wherever true believers might be, not where people claim to be true believers by their own account.
 
His friend,

VOM is the Voice of Martyrs, an organization that supports persecuted brethren.

My pastor is Jesus. I follow His teachings in the NT. I hope you don't mind me asking but do you read the Bible? Please forgive me if I am wrong. You are not mentioning anything about the Bible.
 
gingercat said:
His friend,

VOM is the Voice of Martyrs, an organization that supports persecuted brethren.

My pastor is Jesus. I follow His teachings in the NT. I hope you don't mind me asking but do you read the Bible? Please forgive me if I am wrong. You are not mentioning anything about the Bible.

Well Jesus is the Chief Shepherd. But he also calls other shepherds, pastors, to watch over his flock. And again, this does not thereby mean all claimants to be pastors were called by Jesus.

Yes I read the Bible.

You can follow his teachings in the NT. Of course, you could just follow Him too. This is how he wants you to mature. The teachings in the Bible are just there to give you an idea what it looks like to follow him.

His sheep know his voice.
 
gingercat said:
Free said:
The problem I see here is that gingercat doesn't like to be told what to believe, which is the same as many people who reject the traditional notion of church. She has admitted such several times.
Free,

Jesus is telling many things what to do to me every day in His NT. I just don't obey people who are not showing much fruit.

The Bible tells us to look for the fruit. This is very simple. Why do you keep avoiding it?

You have thousands of doctrines and denominations. That proves thousands of deceptiveness. Truth is only one. The only way to find the true church is to look for the fruit. Do you get it? I already told you that my church is my family, VOM and my ministry. I know you don't want to accept anything less than your traditional mentality of "church" which I wholeheartedly disagree.
And yet by doing things "your own way" all you have done is created another break in His Church. You are once again doing the very thing you accuse others of doing. When are you actually going to address these contradictions in your beliefs that I've pointed out?


HisFriend said:
That is absolutely and unequivocally dead wrong. You have it completely backwards.
"Absolutely and unequivocally dead wrong," is it? Do you really want to be that adamant about it, that wrong belief leads to wrong practice? Do you need me to give you an example? Think about it as you read through the rest of this post.

HisFriend said:
God is not going to be giving you a theology test on judgment day my friend. If you think God is going to judge you or anyone by the thoughts you had then you are living in a fantasy world. Theology is not a bad thing but neither is eating halibut steak.
So do you really think that if two people have the exact same outward fruit but one believes that Jesus is God and the other that Jesus was a mere man, that that means nothing? What if one believes that Jesus didn't physically rise from the dead, another that Jesus never really died and a third that believes Jesus died and rose aagain? To be consistent you now have to admit that that is all meaningless, as long as they all have good fruit.

But a quick glance at the NT proves you wrong. Look at the huge importance Paul, John and Peter place on believing the right thing. Look at the importance Christ himself put on believing the right thing.

HisFriend said:
It will be fruits on which Judgment day is based. His fruit in your life or your own fruit that leads to destruction. Read Matthew 25 and learn how to give the little ones a cup of water to drink. And then you mighty be lucky enough to be watching the "Lord, Lord" theologians be cast into the fire.
How about you post your Scriptural proof and then I'll post mine. Believers are judged on the basis of their fruits, unbelievers are judged on the very fact that they are not believers. This most certainly implies that there are certain things to be believed in order to become a believer, things which if not believed makes one an unbeliever.

HisFriend said:
In fact, Paul makes it abundantly clear to the Corinthians and those who are willing to understand, that theology is a wisdom on a human level that is foolishness to God -child's play. On the other hand, the way of Christ in suffering and love is the Wisdom of God. And that is what Paul means by becoming mature in Christ.
Again, you post your Scriptural proof and then I'll post mine. I strongly recommend you read the whole passage in which Paul makes this supposed statement to get the real meaning of what he says.

I will restate this because it needs restating: wrong belief leads to wrong practice. Perhaps I should also add that wrong belief can lead to the wrong Christ and the wrong God, in which case any good fruit was in vain.


Henry said:
You are very talented at reading into things, I am not the judge of anyones heart nor do I want to be.
I didn't read into anything. I'll even repost it so that I can point it out more clearly: "You see, a true fruit of the spirit is not so much about the act but the heart that is behind the act. Which is a LOVE. The mormons and JW both have fruits but they do the things they do for reward, to be gods or what ever."

You said it with your own mouth Henry - "the heart that is behind the act".

Henry said:
The modern office of the church pastor is totally unbiblical you are correct finally. Oh and the gift of pastor is not in the list, he calls men to be leaders by example not by rule and never is one ever called by such titles, actually Jesus said not to use titles.
I'll let you put two and two together:

1Co 12:29 Are all apostles? Are all prophets? Are all teachers? Do all work miracles?

And He gave some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers, (Ephesians 4:11)

And please post the passage where Jesus said not to use titles. And you haven't answered the point that shepherds look after the sheep.
 
Free,

One thing you are not considering is this. If a true believer departs from a false assembly, he is not doing the same thing as false assemblies departing from each other.

Unless of course, you would advocate JW's stay right where they are.
 
Free said:
And yet by doing things "your own way" all you have done is created another break in His Church.


Free,

When are you goint to get it? I don't have my own way. I follow Jesus. I follow His way. I have a Bible as everyone else does!

How do I know He is supporting my decision? He is enableing us to support VOM on regular basis, My family is serving Him powerfully. He is enabling me financially in my own ministry. You are too close-minded to see anything more than your own traditional way of thinking which is not very fruitful.

BTW, I asked you if you know your church is fruitful or not. Have you examined your church to see if it is fruitful in every way?
 
gingercat said:
When are you goint to get it? I don't have my own way. I follow Jesus. I follow His way. I have a Bible as everyone else does!
But that is what everyone else claims, so why are you right and they wrong?
 
Free said:
gingercat said:
When are you goint to get it? I don't have my own way. I follow Jesus. I follow His way. I have a Bible as everyone else does!
But that is what everyone else claims, so why are you right and they wrong?

I am here to voice my convictions. Isn't that what every one is doing too?
 
Free you just are not getting it at all.

10 He who descended is the very one who ascended higher than all the heavens, in order to fill the whole universe.) 11 It was he who gave some to be apostles, some to be prophets, some to be evangelists, and some to be pastors and teachers, 12 to prepare God's people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up 13 until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.

There is a difference in being an apostle or a prophet (or what ever gifting God has given you) and holding an office with in institution. These are GIFTS given to the body for WHAT “to prepare God's people for works of service†and “until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become matureâ€Â

I am not at all saying there are not apostles, prophets, evangelists, and pastors and teachers. I am saying they are not an office in a heirachial system of government.

You are missing the point, I am not saying NO leadership, I am saying that the modern church has the WRONG kind of leadership structure. The Lord NEVER wanted us to build ladder up leadership just like the world.

Luke 22: 24 Also a dispute arose among them as to which of them was considered to be greatest. 25 Jesus said to them, "The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them; and those who exercise authority over them call themselves Benefactors. 26 But you are not to be like that. Instead, the greatest among you should be like the youngest, and the one who rules like the one who serves. 27 For who is greater, the one who is at the table or the one who serves? Is it not the one who is at the table? But I am among you as one who serves.
We are NOT TO BE LIKE THAT, meaning the form of gentile government, and yet what has the church done but in fact built that very thing.

The authority of a church leader is no greater then that of a child or servant says JESUS Himself. So when we have pastors and what ever else titles men bestow on each other, who think themselves as being OVER the flock (and well meaning as they are they think that very thing) where is the authority? It is not that of a child but that of a ruler and Jesus said NOT TO BE LIKE THAT.

Look at what you have to do here, you actually will have to explain away what Jesus said in order to satisfy the modern system “well Jesus really meant this and that...†No, He said exactly what he meant.

1 Peter 5:1 To the elders among you, I appeal as a fellow elder, a witness of Christ's sufferings and one who also will share in the glory to be revealed: 2 Be shepherds of God's flock that is under your care, serving as overseersâ€â€not because you must, but because you are willing, as God wants you to be; not greedy for money, but eager to serve; 3 not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock.

Look here, Peter said that he was a fellow elder but do we ever find him saying “Elder Peter†or for that matter is there any time in the NT that anyone is ever called by a title like that? NO NOT ONE SINGLE TIME ! But here we are tossing them about like yesterdays news, no one even realizing what exactly they are doing.

Now, look what Peter says to the elder (not a title, but merely to acknowledge the older mature men) He tells them “Be shepherds of God's flock that is under your care, serving as overseers†Do you see what is going here, he is not saying you are pastors and you are bishops and what ever, he is saying BE SHEHPERDS and SERVE AS OVERSEERS, these are all words used for the same GUYS. Not offices at all, a man who is wise should just naturally BE doing these things, but he is not called by them anymore then I would runner Henry for running a race.

Do you think Peter remembered what Jesus said? YES

not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock.

Hmm not Lording it over them, Jesus said you are not to be like that. He said the church leader had no true authority in the worlds way over anyone, anymore then that of a Child or servant. Here Peter says NOT LORDING IT OVER THEM and then what VERY IMPORTANT the lead by being examples to the flock, of whom they are a part of not over and above.

Sorry Free but you are wrong, the church is not to be lead by this ladder up system of who is the boss of who, the pastor of the modern day church is not in the bible, and he can not justify his job with out twisting, explaining away or just ignoring much of what the bible says. Even what Jesus said himself.


This is not very hard at all, there is no real debate that the modern church and the NT church are not doing the same things, shoot we only need to look at the denominations to see that. The question is not is it ok to not do what they did, but why wouldn't we want we want to do what Jesus taught them to do? Do you obey the Lord or men, if you have a pastor and are in a IC you obey men.
 
What is Church?

The "Church" is the combined body of Christ, composed of all nations and tongues. The greatest need the Church has is fellowship with her respective members, for in each other will we find fulfillment in prayer and fasting: and eveything else will flow from these.

I have found that there are only two churches in this world: the True Church, and the false. The True Church has the Gospel in common; while the false will have confusion in common.
 
There is an earthly church which is a building that houses both believers and wolves in sheep's clothing. And there is a spitiual church which is simply the true sheep of Christ, born again of the Holy Spirit. The head of the church is Christ, not the pope or any pastor who as Paul says, are mere servants of God, not our Father.

All those born of God by receiving the Holy Spirit which is from God, are now sons of God which is why in Hebrews, Jesus calls us his brothers because we are now born again of one Father who is our Father in heaven. This is our new spiritual family of which wolves in sheep's clothing are not a part because they haven't received the Holy Spirit. :)
 
The idea of the earthly building church or some call it the visible church is an apolgetic designed to make justification for the building and paid clergy. The Church of the bible knows nothing of such things.
 
Back
Top