Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eternal damnation

Where in that parable is he tormented forever?
Let's consider all of God's Word. Not just snippets from it. btw, the story of Lazarus wasn't a parable, because Jesus named names. Parables don't do that. And He didn't say that the story was a parable. And He specifically mentioned Abraham, who spoke to the rich man. He was giving mankind a glimpse of life after death before His own death and resurrection. It is clear that the rich man was conscious and in torment.

Couple that story with Rev 20:10 and it is unambiguous that those in the Lake of Fire will be tormented forever and ever.

No question.
 
Do you not accept all of God's Word, or just what has been quoted from Jesus?

Rev 20:10 - And the devil who deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are also; and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever. NASB

I find this verse to be unambiguous about how long one exists in a conscious state in the lake of fire. Or is "forever and ever" not that clear?
It is very clear, Who does it say is tormented? The devil, the ten headed beast, and the false prophet. Not EVERYONE, not all sinners. Jesus said that they will be destroyed. Do you not accept all of God's Word?
If you look at all of God's word, it is clear that throughout scripture the fate of those that reject God is said to be destruction, perishing, being no more, and so on.

poetof parables said:
He doesnt want to see that view free, because the alternative is unthinkable to him.
No, I believe what is written in the Bible and I reject what is NOT written in the Bible. The other side has not proven their case that God will torture the lost forever in hell when they die.
DO NOT ascribe false motives to me. If the Bible said that the lost will go to hell when they die where they will be tortured alive forever, and if the Bible didn't say that the wicked will be destroyed, then I would agree with their unbiblical view. Understand?
 
Okay, this thread is taking another trip down the eternal conscious torment vs. annihilation path and like about the previous six threads on the same topic, it will probably go downhill into the abyss rather quickly and get a shiny lock applied with warning point for rude behavior as I have already recognized enough in this thread. I will repeat the question from the opening post and ask that we get back on topic.

The question is, "Why is eternal suffering necessary." The question is not about debating total annihilation and eternal conscious torment.
 
Let's consider all of God's Word. Not just snippets from it. btw, the story of Lazarus wasn't a parable, because Jesus named names. Parables don't do that. And He didn't say that the story was a parable. And He specifically mentioned Abraham, who spoke to the rich man. He was giving mankind a glimpse of life after death before His own death and resurrection. It is clear that the rich man was conscious and in torment.

Couple that story with Rev 20:10 and it is unambiguous that those in the Lake of Fire will be tormented forever and ever.

No question.
I hope you're wrong.
 
I like you're explanation of the smoke rising up forever and ever, as an everlasting destruction as John 3:16 says. But its easy to read into many verses like that when they are very vague.
I asked you to comment on John 3:16.
I commented on the verse you wanted me to comment on. The deal was then you would also respond to John 3:16. You didn't do it.
 
It is very clear, Who does it say is tormented? The devil, the ten headed beast, and the false prophet. Not EVERYONE, not all sinners. Jesus said that they will be destroyed. Do you not accept all of God's Word?
If you look at all of God's word, it is clear that throughout scripture the fate of those that reject God is said to be destruction, perishing, being no more, and so on.


No, I believe what is written in the Bible and I reject what is NOT written in the Bible. The other side has not proven their case that God will torture the lost forever in hell when they die.
DO NOT ascribe false motives to me. If the Bible said that the lost will go to hell when they die where they will be tortured alive forever, and if the Bible didn't say that the wicked will be destroyed, then I would agree with their unbiblical view. Understand?
K.
 
I asked you to comment on John 3:16.
I commented on the verse you wanted me to comment on. The deal was then you would also respond to John 3:16. You didn't do it.
I agree with you Tim, and I agree with the opposite opinion.
 
I want to have a decent discussion. I don't want to be rude to anyone or have anyone be rude to me. I asked from my first post in this thread that the other side would be respectful of opposing POVs.
If this thread is closed, it is because those who hold the view that the lost are tormented forever in hell cannot act decently to anyone who holds an opposing POV.
 
Okay, this thread is taking another trip down the eternal conscious torment vs. annihilation path and like about the previous six threads on the same topic, it will probably go downhill into the abyss rather quickly and get a shiny lock applied with warning point for rude behavior as I have already recognized enough in this thread. I will repeat the question from the opening post and ask that we get back on topic.

The question is, "Why is eternal suffering necessary." The question is not about debating total annihilation and eternal conscious torment.

I agree. So to answer the question, it is not necessary, and the OP's premise is incorrect and the thread should be done. Tim and Tim here just went a round-about way to say that, so I rest my case.
 
There are no other verses that say that man will be tormented forever in hell. Both Tim and I adequately covered those points.
Yes there are, there's both. Don't you get why you're all fighting about it. It's because the bible says both, vaguely and conspicuously.
 
There are no other verses that say that man will be tormented forever in hell. Both Tim and I adequately covered those points.
Aren't the beast and the false prophet both human?

Rev 20:10 And the devil that deceived them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.

I like poetofparables response in post #98: "I would agree with you if the bible didnt say "tormented" forever. You have to remain alive to be tormented. What do you think?"
 
Matthew 25:46 says eternal punishment, not eternal torment. I agree with Jesus Christ that there is to be eternal punishment. And I agree with Jesus Christ that this punishment is destruction, as He said in Matthew 7:13, Matthew 10:28, and Luke 13:3.

You ask "why would it matter if they were just going to die?" Don't you believe that eternal life is MUCH better than death? Wouldn't you warn your son or daughter if they were "just going to die"? And Jesus in fact DID warn us of that. He said "fear the one who is able to destroy both body and soul in hell" and He said "the road is wide that leads to destruction". Why would He warn us of destruction if we weren't actually in danger of destruction? If nobody was actually going to be destroyed?

Are you just arguing with me because you don't want to give up your position? What about what the Bible says? What about what Jesus says?


Then He will also say to those on the left hand, 'Depart from Me, you cursed, into the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels:
And these will go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous into eternal life." Matthew 25:41-46

The everlasting punishment is being cast into the everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.


The key phrase here is ... into the everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.


The scripture is specific in Revelation, in describing the fate of the Devil.

The devil, who deceived them, was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone where the beast and the false prophet are. And they will be tormented day and night forever and ever.
Revelation 20:10


They represents those who were cast into the lake of fire... the beast, the false prophet, the devil.

Jesus said to those whom He sentenced to be cast into the everlasting fire for everlasting punishment, was the same fire as the devil and his angels.

The devil is cast into the lake of fire, and will be tormented day and night forever, along with the beast and the false prophet.

The destroying process for these will last forever, as the punishment is everlasting, and the fire which brings about the eternal destruction is also everlasting.


'Depart from Me, you cursed, into the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels: And they will be tormented day and night forever and ever.



JLB
 
Let me add this verse to the mix.

Mark 9:49New International Version (NIV)
49 Everyone will be salted with fire.

Can someone get that verse in context, because I'm having trouble at bible gateway while on my phone.
 
Then He will also say to those...
According to Jesus Christ, as recorded in Matthew 7:13 and in Matthew 10:28 they will be destroyed.
According to John 3:16, they will perish. According to Jesus as recorded in Luke 13:3, unless a man repents, he will perish.
According to the Bible, as recorded in Romans 6:23, the wages of sin is death.

Now. Why should I believe that the wages of sin is NOT death, but eternal conscious torment instead of death?
Why shouldn't I believe what Jesus says instead of what you say?

And I'm not even asking you to believe that the wicked will be destroyed as the Bible says.
I'm only asking that the ultimate destruction of the wicked be considered as biblical view alongside the traditional view that the wicked will not be destroyed in hell.

P.O.P. Does "salted with fire" mean "tormented alive forever in fire without end"? Isn't that reading A LOT into that verse?
 
Aren't the beast and the false prophet both human?
No. Three reasons why:

Rev 16:13 (LEB) And I saw coming out of the mouth of the dragon and out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false prophet three unclean spirits like frogs. 14 For they are the spirits of demons performing signs that go out to the kings of the whole inhabited world, to gather them for the battle of the great day of God the All-Powerful.
1. John says his vision was that of three unclean spirits coming out of these demons' mouths. I take John at his word over/above what some people tell me.

2. Plus, since The Beast and The False Prophet are cast into the LoF and remain there forever prior to the Final Judgment, then they don't appear at the Great White throne Judgment. Yet Jesus says it is appointed for all humans to die then face judgment. (Either the GWTJ or Bema Seat Judgment). I take Jesus at His Word.

3. The LoF is prepared for The Devil and His _______? Answer = His angels (i.e. demons).

4. [There's other very good reasons that John's vision of The Beast and The False Prophet are NOT meant to be understood as humans as well, but 1), 2) and 3) should be sufficient for a reasoned conclusion. If the conclusion that they are meant to be understood as Demons is not reasonable, then why not?]
 
Then that would be his problem. Rev 20:10 is the Biblical view. All other views are unbiblical.
John 3:16 is unbiblical?
Romans 6:23 is unbiblical?
2 Thessalonians 1:9 is unbiblical?
Are ALL of these verses from the Bible unBiblical? Luke 13:3, Matthew 10:28, Matthew 7:13, Psalm 37:10, Psalm 37:20, Ezekiel 18:4, Malachi chapter 4, The book of Jude, The letter to the Romans, the book of John, are ALL of these things unbiblical? I find that hard to believe.
 
Back
Top