Tessa
Member
Good point.A fast is an abstaining from the faster's choice of material. While that traditionally means a fast from all or some food, It need not be. For example, one could choose to fast from the Internet, or from their cellphone.
Also about the fasting in secret, we know The people who have openly committed to the fast of meat, but there is nothing to stop us from adding other things to the fast, without saying so.
I would not be surprised if others were joining us but not saying so.