• Love God, and love one another!

    Share your heart for Christ and others in Godly Love

    https://christianforums.net/forums/god_love/

  • Want to discuss private matters, or make a few friends?

    Ask for membership to the Men's or Lady's Locker Rooms

    For access, please contact a member of staff and they can add you in!

  • Wake up and smell the coffee!

    Join us for a little humor in Joy of the Lord

    https://christianforums.net/forums/humor_and_jokes/

  • Need prayer and encouragement?

    Come share your heart's concerns in the Prayer Forum

    https://christianforums.net/forums/prayer/

  • Desire to be a vessel of honor unto the Lord Jesus Christ?

    Join Hidden in Him and For His Glory for discussions on how

    https://christianforums.net/threads/become-a-vessel-of-honor-part-2.112306/

  • Have questions about the Christian faith?

    Come ask us what's on your mind in Questions and Answers

    https://christianforums.net/forums/questions-and-answers/

  • CFN has a new look and a new theme

    "I bore you on eagle's wings, and brought you to Myself" (Exodus 19:4)

    More new themes coming in the future!

  • Read the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ?

    Read through this brief blog, and receive eternal salvation as the free gift of God

    /blog/the-gospel

  • Focus on the Family

    Strengthening families through biblical principles.

    Focus on the Family addresses the use of biblical principles in parenting and marriage to strengthen the family.

Is faith or works necessary for Salvation ?

The Only Faith and Works necessary for a sinner to be saved, is that which Christ did. His Faithfulness and Work on the Cross shall make many Righteous. Rom 5:19

19For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.
 
The Only Faith and Works necessary for a sinner to be saved, is that which Christ did. His Faithfulness and Work on the Cross shall make many Righteous. Rom 5:19

19For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.

You must apply your faith in order to be Saved. Without faith you will not have eternal life bestowed upon you...
 
Thank God for lack of knowledge in traditional theologies. I can see for myself the results of that.

I think you fear the church too much. I understand not liking organised religion and wanting to be free to read and interpret the scriptures yourself. I support that. What do you think the reformed moment was about back in the day?

It's great to read and study the bible, but it's foolish to do so, and figure we have stumbled upon something that has not been discovered before by greater minds in these last 2,000 years, and then have the audacity to claim these greater minds, who have made major contributions to the understandings of Christian doctrines; who have given their very lives in some cases, and devoted their every waking hour to the very words we read today in the Holly Bible .....are in some vast heretical error. THEY ARE NOT! Especially when the opinions of these minds have been widely accepted as Orthodox Christianity, even by others who don't necessarily fully agree with every detail.

Luther and Calvin Changed the world in their time, but they where not alone. There where others. Ulrich Zwingli, William Tyndale, Philip Melanchthon, Katharina Von Bora, John Knox, Martin Bucer, Theodore Beza, John Wycliffe, Peter Waldo, Girolamo Savonarola, Jan Hus....and many others. There where people before theses, and people after, all the way up to day, who have made major contributions to the Christian faith by their study of the word, and that torch will be passed on by the will of God and not man.

We live in a biblically ignorant era today, and it's only going to get more so. People today are taken away from the word by a man made culture, and their own desire to be ignorant of God. We are all distracted by conveniences, imagery and sounds, designed to grab our attention and part with our money. Worse than that, most people are willing to work harder for this worthless culture than for God.

Those of us who do study the bible, might read a little here and there. Some make a bigger effort, some less. But it does not matter, because none of us can claim near the amount of study and dedication that these men and women have on that short list I provided.

All those people have something else in common. They are all dead. They did what they did, not for themselves but for the kingdom of God; for you and for me and generations to come. They deserve far more respect, consideration and study than they have been given, especially on forums like this by people who profess to know the word of God after reading a nicely printed bible that was bought off the shelf of a local book store in the comfort of a climate controlled room.

It was because of these men and women and others like them that you even have a bible today. Maybe, just maybe they have something good to say beyond what you've read in your bible.

Perhaps they'd like for you know more about what you are reading, and impart to you their wisdom, knowledge, and experience to add to what you have on your own.

A little history would open you up to even more.
 
Guess I don't understand how this answers the original question:

"Is faith or works necessary for Salvation ?"

Works are not needed to be saved. They are needed to show the world you ARE saved.

........................

Faith saves us. Good works show others how vital our faith is. I really don't get the source of any disagreement over this. :chin

The argument now is more about details and theologies. Where does faith come from...that sort of thing.

If we all agree that faith not works is necessary for salvation, what does it mean to have faith? Is it something we do? or is it something God does? is it both?

There are some other issues in regards to logical understandings of scripture and what's been said of it. Some contradictions have been expressed and some challenges to those thoughts have been initiated.
 
I think you fear the church too much. I understand not liking organised religion and wanting to be free to read and interpret the scriptures yourself. I support that. What do you think the reformed moment was about back in the day?

It's great to read and study the bible, but it's foolish to do so, and figure we have stumbled upon something that has not been discovered before by greater minds in these last 2,000 years, and then have the audacity to claim these greater minds, who have made major contributions to the understandings of Christian doctrines; who have given their very lives in some cases, and devoted their every waking hour to the very words we read today in the Holly Bible .....are in some vast heretical error. THEY ARE NOT! Especially when the opinions of these minds have been widely accepted as Orthodox Christianity, even by others who don't necessarily fully agree with every detail.

Luther and Calvin Changed the world in their time, but they where not alone. There where others. Ulrich Zwingli, William Tyndale, Philip Melanchthon, Katharina Von Bora, John Knox, Martin Bucer, Theodore Beza, John Wycliffe, Peter Waldo, Girolamo Savonarola, Jan Hus....and many others. There where people before theses, and people after, all the way up to day, who have made major contributions to the Christian faith by their study of the word, and that torch will be passed on by the will of God and not man.

We live in a biblically ignorant era today, and it's only going to get more so. People today are taken away from the word by a man made culture, and their own desire to be ignorant of God. We are all distracted by conveniences, imagery and sounds, designed to grab our attention and part with our money. Worse than that, most people are willing to work harder for this worthless culture than for God.

Those of us who do study the bible, might read a little here and there. Some make a bigger effort, some less. But it does not matter, because none of us can claim near the amount of study and dedication that these men and women have on that short list I provided.

All those people have something else in common. They are all dead. They did what they did, not for themselves but for the kingdom of God; for you and for me and generations to come. They deserve far more respect, consideration and study than they have been given, especially on forums like this by people who profess to know the word of God after reading a nicely printed bible that was bought off the shelf of a local book store in the comfort of a climate controlled room.

It was because of these men and women and others like them that you even have a bible today. Maybe, just maybe they have something good to say beyond what you've read in your bible.

Perhaps they'd like for you know more about what you are reading, and impart to you their wisdom, knowledge, and experience to add to what you have on your own.

A little history would open you up to even more.

Unfortunately, men from the past and present who think of themselves more highly than they ought, have done damage to the "purity" and "simplicity" of God's message to humanity...Cults, false teachings, and heresies abound throughout the century's...Due to men who "thought" they had the answers to perplexing questions within the Scriptures... Adding their own "imaginative reasoning's" and misinterpretations. The simplicity of the message has been "overlaid" with the falsehoods, and heresies of "scholars" and laymen alike. Paul , we know, was concerned about keeping the "purity" of the message... Look how many cults, denominations, religions, philosophy's, we have today, that preach falsehood, blasphemy, heresy, etc,. all in the name of Christianity...Because someone lived century's ago doesn't mean they had it right...A lot of damage, has at times, been done by men such as these...
 
The argument now is more about details and theologies. Where does faith come from...that sort of thing.

If we all agree that faith not works is necessary for salvation, what does it mean to have faith? Is it something we do? or is it something God does? is it both?

There are some other issues in regards to logical understandings of scripture and what's been said of it. Some contradictions have been expressed and some challenges to those thoughts have been initiated.

God created "every" man with a free-will to choose what he would believe...God desire's ALL men to come to a "saving knowledge of His Son..." You ask, what does it mean to have faith? It means God gave you the ability to choose...
 
=Grubal Muruch;586020]God created "every" man with a free-will to choose what he would believe...
Grubal respectfully, to believe whatever one wanted to believe and then be able to choose not to, that would be called "ignorance" not a "freewill". To be able to believe the Truth of God is faith, but to choose not to is not faith. Romans one says God created man with the knowledge that there is a Truth of the Creator and what a man has that is good are God's attributes. Hence God did not leave man able to believe anything he chose.
God desire's ALL men to come to a "saving knowledge of His Son..."
Yes, that is a healthy view since knowledge is to heal the ignorance of vanity. So it cannot be that men can choose what they believe and that is their "freewill" since this would be ignorance of vanity.
You ask, what does it mean to have faith? It means God gave you the ability to choose...
God never gave us the ability to choose to be vain as that is not an attribute of God but an attribute of Satan. Do you actually believe God gave us the power to sin? Scripture identifies Satan as the Father of sin, not God. So Jesus came to destroy the vanity of Satan that thinks it is his prerogative to believe whatever he wants in vanity.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Unfortunately, men from the past and present who think of themselves more highly than they ought, have done damage to the "purity" and "simplicity" of God's message to humanity...Cults, false teachings, and heresies abound throughout the century's...Due to men who "thought" they had the answers to perplexing questions within the Scriptures... Adding their own "imaginative reasoning's" and misinterpretations. The simplicity of the message has been "overlaid" with the falsehoods, and heresies of "scholars" and laymen alike. Paul , we know, was concerned about keeping the "purity" of the message... Look how many cults, denominations, religions, philosophy's, we have today, that preach falsehood, blasphemy, heresy, etc,. all in the name of Christianity...Because someone lived century's ago doesn't mean they had it right...A lot of damage, has at times, been done by men such as these...

Well, we need to all make sure we are not on that list as well then don't we?

The people on that list I provided are some of the greatest minds in the history of Christianity, and well accepted. They deserve more respect than they get, regardless. I can list great minds of the Catholic faith as well. There are other great protestants that I don't exactly agree with. John Westley was a great mind who did a lot to spread the word. I don't agree with a lot of areas of his theology, but he was not wrong as a Christian. I'm not about to trash him.
 
I think you fear the church too much. I understand not liking organised religion and wanting to be free to read and interpret the scriptures yourself. I support that. What do you think the reformed moment was about back in the day?

It's great to read and study the bible, but it's foolish to do so, and figure we have stumbled upon something that has not been discovered before by greater minds in these last 2,000 years, and then have the audacity to claim these greater minds, who have made major contributions to the understandings of Christian doctrines; who have given their very lives in some cases, and devoted their every waking hour to the very words we read today in the Holly Bible .....are in some vast heretical error. THEY ARE NOT! Especially when the opinions of these minds have been widely accepted as Orthodox Christianity, even by others who don't necessarily fully agree with every detail.

Luther and Calvin Changed the world in their time, but they where not alone. There where others. Ulrich Zwingli, William Tyndale, Philip Melanchthon, Katharina Von Bora, John Knox, Martin Bucer, Theodore Beza, John Wycliffe, Peter Waldo, Girolamo Savonarola, Jan Hus....and many others. There where people before theses, and people after, all the way up to day, who have made major contributions to the Christian faith by their study of the word, and that torch will be passed on by the will of God and not man.

We live in a biblically ignorant era today, and it's only going to get more so. People today are taken away from the word by a man made culture, and their own desire to be ignorant of God. We are all distracted by conveniences, imagery and sounds, designed to grab our attention and part with our money. Worse than that, most people are willing to work harder for this worthless culture than for God.

Those of us who do study the bible, might read a little here and there. Some make a bigger effort, some less. But it does not matter, because none of us can claim near the amount of study and dedication that these men and women have on that short list I provided.

All those people have something else in common. They are all dead. They did what they did, not for themselves but for the kingdom of God; for you and for me and generations to come. They deserve far more respect, consideration and study than they have been given, especially on forums like this by people who profess to know the word of God after reading a nicely printed bible that was bought off the shelf of a local book store in the comfort of a climate controlled room.

It was because of these men and women and others like them that you even have a bible today. Maybe, just maybe they have something good to say beyond what you've read in your bible.

Perhaps they'd like for you know more about what you are reading, and impart to you their wisdom, knowledge, and experience to add to what you have on your own.

A little history would open you up to even more.

I don't fear the church at all, and I'm totally open to the Word of God.
Organizations are not the church, so what I am skeptical of are organizations.

I have great respect for the founding church fathers, but I also see how their beliefs have been adulterated over time. It's like the whisper game...the truths change with each retelling.

The fact is that we don't have to go back and read what all those men taught, because believers have the Holy Spirit WITHIN us, and because we have a body of believers that are being taught by the same Holy Spirit right now..today.

I'll often go back and read sermons by Spurgeon, Tozer, Oswald Chambers, and many other men of God. I don't study their doctrine, I read the words they speak and find much truth there. Not all truth, mind you, for no man has all truth, and that can only be found in the Word of God. We have the ability, through the Holy Spirit within, to recognize when something doesn't ring quite true. Then we search the Scripture for ourselves. We should never accept something as truth no matter how great the man's reputation, or how big a following he has.

Personally, I beieve in the body ministry...not one man led organizations. My neighbor next door can deliver as great a truth, and sometimes greater, than any of those you've listed above. It doesn't take years of study, it takes years of spending time in the Word of God.
 
The Only Faith and Works necessary for a sinner to be saved, is that which Christ did. His Faithfulness and Work on the Cross shall make many Righteous. Rom 5:19

19For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.

You forgot one step. We are made righteous when we are justified by faith in the Righteous One.
 
The argument now is more about details and theologies. Where does faith come from...that sort of thing.

If we all agree that faith not works is necessary for salvation, what does it mean to have faith? Is it something we do? or is it something God does? is it both?

There are some other issues in regards to logical understandings of scripture and what's been said of it. Some contradictions have been expressed and some challenges to those thoughts have been initiated.

{3} For through the grace given to me I say to everyone among you not to think more highly of himself than he ought to think; but to think so as to have sound judgment, as God has allotted to each a measure of faith. Romans 12:3 (NASB)

While this verse does not speak specifically of the lost, I believe the Bible is clear: every single human being - having been created in God's image - has the capacity for saving faith: the knowledge of God. Without that, free will (the capacity to choose between good and evil) would make no sense at all.

In other words the capacity for faith is as much a part of every human heart as is the propensity to sin. It's as much a gift from God as original sin is a curse.

More later.
 
I don't fear the church at all, and I'm totally open to the Word of God.
Organizations are not the church, so what I am skeptical of are organizations.

I have great respect for the founding church fathers, but I also see how their beliefs have been adulterated over time. It's like the whisper game...the truths change with each retelling.

The fact is that we don't have to go back and read what all those men taught, because believers have the Holy Spirit WITHIN us, and because we have a body of believers that are being taught by the same Holy Spirit right now..today.

I'll often go back and read sermons by Spurgeon, Tozer, Oswald Chambers, and many other men of God. I don't study their doctrine, I read the words they speak and find much truth there. Not all truth, mind you, for no man has all truth, and that can only be found in the Word of God. We have the ability, through the Holy Spirit within, to recognize when something doesn't ring quite true. Then we search the Scripture for ourselves. We should never accept something as truth no matter how great the man's reputation, or how big a following he has.

Personally, I beieve in the body ministry...not one man led organizations. My neighbor next door can deliver as great a truth, and sometimes greater, than any of those you've listed above. It doesn't take years of study, it takes years of spending time in the Word of God.

Your missing and or twisting my point. This is the Apologetics and "THEOLOGY" section.

In this area people discuss theology; doctrines of thoughts related to the Christian faith.

No one is saying you can't be a Christian and not have studied history or great writings of theology, but if your going to come here and belittle John Calvin, then maybe you should know what your talking about. otherwise it's pointless. And when others who've studied these doctrines try to come in here and educate others on them, rather tan keep comparing these great thoughts against your own, you should try to first understand these thoughts rather than simply assume others are blindly lead by the feeding of a dead preacher or organised religion; because when you compare your thoughts of the bible to some of these well established theologies as if to argue them, you're not disproving anything, or countering anything Just saying what you think.

No one has argued, that I've seen, your "beliefs". No one thinks, that I've seen, that your not a Christian or that you don't love the lord. I have no doubt you do.

What's being argued are cognitive logical thoughts as such thoughts relate to theology. So much so, that it's difficult to pin-point what the theology is you are expressing to have a conversation. Then it deteriorates into no discussion on "THEOLOGY":...which is what this section is for.

This thread started out OK, but it sounded like a thread to argue works or faith, which is juicy because we can get into various types of known theology and doctrines and go from there, but when it becomes obvious that someone does not have a grasp of well established theological thoughts, yet they want to argue well established theological thought with their love of God, it's pointless to say we are discussing "theology".

I'm glad your a Christian Glory. I think your spot on in your faith and love of Jesus Christ and there is nothing in your core belief that I can say I disagree with. I'm not arguing your belief. You believe in Jesus Christ, that he died for you sins and you place your faith, hope and trust in him. You are my brother in Christ, but if your going to come to a bar fight, bring a weapon, or wait outside....it's a figure of speech my friend. I know you would not be in a bar fight. :-)

If I've been too harsh please accept my apology. I don't come to the A&T section to have a friendly discussion, and I don't come to the A&T section to talk about my personal love for Jesus Christ. I come here to defend certain theologies, or the faith itself.

All this mess in here on this thread and in the end, everyone agrees that faith is the key to salvation, well how about that. That's what we've accomplished. No one brought up any theologies. GM, me tried to discuss Calvin, and a few others, but most of it was all about how others are linking their own logic to the scriptures, and not to theology. That's it. What a disappointment don't you think?

Honestly there aren't too many people on this forum that have a very well established understanding of theology. There is one I've seen, and he's not a protestant. There are others who lean a little one way or another and know it, but the vast majority of reads in here are not really digging into theology much at all.

I've seen atheist in here with a better knowledge of theology then many Christians, who inevitably end up just making up their own straw-men argument .

Usually either someone states what they believe and if they are not clear they open themselves up for questions until it is clear, then a discussion takes place that can lead into a real debate with each party clearly knowing where they and the other stand. This thread was a "poser". It started off looking like something it was not, then when it was fully investigated it turned out to be empty and not prepared to present anything, other than "I Love Jesus"....great! So do I.
 
Well, it wasn't because He kept leading them into captivity, that's for sure.

They knew God was merciful because he gave them a way to have their sins forgiven.
The Atonement. They knew they served a Holy and Righteous and Wrathful and Jealous God.

Please point to me from the OT about any mention of the "Atonement" - no negative remark implied with the quotes.

You want your cake and eat it, too. How is it the Jews knew God was merciful in YOUR paradigm? If you were correct, wouldn't we see SOMETHING about God forgiving the jews based upon a future perfect person????

Please. I am asking you, explain to me about God forgiving sins in the OT - and the Jews understanding of it. Do we see anywhere that God is doing things as you state?

I realize you have been taught this, but has it occured to you that you were taught wrong???

Think about it. Open your mind to common sense and truth. How did the Jews know about God's mercy if they were totally unaware of the "Atonement" by the Perfect Man?

Regards
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How did the Jews know about God's mercy if they were totally unaware of the "Atonement" by the Perfect Man?

The obvious answer is:

They weren't!

{39} "You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; it is these that testify about Me; John 5:39 (NASB)

:thumbsup
 
The obvious answer is:

They weren't!

{39} "You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; it is these that testify about Me; John 5:39 (NASB)

:thumbsup

:thumbsup I agree. They did know. Even the Pentateuch (the first five books of the Old Testament) reveals much about the coming Messiah. One can find Christ throughout the Old Testament, and expressly within the Messianic Prophecies. God said even the heavens declare it, and that they know just from studying the sky.
 
Well, we need to all make sure we are not on that list as well then don't we?

The people on that list I provided are some of the greatest minds in the history of Christianity, and well accepted. They deserve more respect than they get, regardless. I can list great minds of the Catholic faith as well. There are other great protestants that I don't exactly agree with. John Westley was a great mind who did a lot to spread the word. I don't agree with a lot of areas of his theology, but he was not wrong as a Christian. I'm not about to trash him.

It's fine to look back in history and see what these guys had to say. However,we must use our good sense, and not turn "everything they said into "Gospel." Or, dabble in "hero worship" by placing them on a
" Pedestal" and deeming them as a "spiritual icon" in which we cannot question their doctrine...These were "mere" men, and therefore, susceptible to error...
 
What I have found immensely helpful is to read their biographies (maybe a few of them) and see where they were at, with what they were contending etc and that allows me to evaluate what they were saying in their light. Sometimes it's more like the gossip game instead. Plus, I really, really believe that we are in the age of the "increase in knowledge" and are seeing things in a light that no other generation had before... but no, we can't put anyone on a pedestal that way. But wow, what great men of faith and real fortitude in what they did believe, how they backed it with their very lives!
 
I don't fear the church at all, and I'm totally open to the Word of God.
Organizations are not the church, so what I am skeptical of are organizations.

I have great respect for the founding church fathers, but I also see how their beliefs have been adulterated over time. It's like the whisper game...the truths change with each retelling.

The fact is that we don't have to go back and read what all those men taught, because believers have the Holy Spirit WITHIN us, and because we have a body of believers that are being taught by the same Holy Spirit right now..today.

I'll often go back and read sermons by Spurgeon, Tozer, Oswald Chambers, and many other men of God. I don't study their doctrine, I read the words they speak and find much truth there. Not all truth, mind you, for no man has all truth, and that can only be found in the Word of God. We have the ability, through the Holy Spirit within, to recognize when something doesn't ring quite true. Then we search the Scripture for ourselves. We should never accept something as truth no matter how great the man's reputation, or how big a following he has.

Personally, I beieve in the body ministry...not one man led organizations. My neighbor next door can deliver as great a truth, and sometimes greater, than any of those you've listed above. It doesn't take years of study, it takes years of spending time in the Word of God.

Praise God for your "Spiritual insight."
 
gm

You must apply your faith in order to be Saved

Thats works.

The scripture states that many shall be made righteous by the obedience of ONE, that ONE being Christ. Rom 5:19

19For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.
 
You forgot one step. We are made righteous when we are justified by faith in the Righteous One.

Thats a false theology work Gospel. Faith is obeidence Rom 1:5

By whom we have received grace and apostleship, for obedience to the faith among all nations, for his name:

Rom 16:26

But now is made manifest, and by the scriptures of the prophets, according to the commandment of the everlasting God, made known to all nations for the obedience of faith:

Acts 6:7

And the word of God increased; and the number of the disciples multiplied in Jerusalem greatly; and a great company of the priests were obedient to the faith.

So if they became righteous by their obedience, and Christ obedience, thats Two obediences that made them Righteous, which contradicts Rom 5:19 which says only One obedience shall make them Righteous Rom 5:19

19For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of one shall many be made righteous.

So you deny scripture as ususal..
 
Back
Top