Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What Saved You?

Bubba said:
"However, my premise does differ to many within Christendom it seems but if you would care to, I can send you a doc written by a friend with my collaboration on the gospel. This will give you insight into my premise."

Mutzrein, sure, how would you send it and if I decide to comment on it, would that be problem?
Bubba

I would email it - it is in PDF format. PM me your email address if need be. And as far as comments - no problem with that - would be appreciated.

Regards
 
Bubba said:
"I missed this. The context you are forcing upon the passage is imputed only righteousness. I do believe that Christ's righteousness is imputed to us. That however allows the Holy Spirit to come in and do a real cleaing which is what "CLEANS US FROM ALL UNRIGHTEOUSNESS" means. How can a surficial cleansing be "CLEANSE US FROM ALL UNRIGHTEOUSNESS". It just doesn't work."

Thess, do me a favor, it doesn't have to be done immediately, but would you actually work through the passages of my first post and the article I included from A.W. Pink. You do not even have to comment back with me, this whole issue is not about Protestantism or Catholicism, it is about what the Bible says happen at the cross. For me, God revealing the "dovetailed" truths of justification and sanctification as a finished work of the cross, which is worked out in the believers life in this realm and already established in the heavenly realm, I found to be absolutely liberating. I actually, want to be holy and pleasing to my Lord. Where before I just went through the motions.

In Christ, Bubba

What is wrong with the view that the grace from the cross earned by Christ 2000 years ago is applied to our lives so that we may overcome sin? Most certainly we are predestined to justifcation and sanctification if we are among the saved and that grace was earned 2000 years ago on the Cross but how is it wrong to say that grace has to be applied to our lives and bring us to faith and repentence allowing the Holy Spirit to dwell within us? That's the Bible dude.
 
Mutzrein,
I got the article, I tried to reply by home email but it didn't go through.
Thanks, Bubba
 
Thess wrote:
“What is wrong with the view that the grace from the cross earned by Christ 2000 years ago is applied to our lives so that we may overcome sin? Most certainly we are predestined to justifcation and sanctification if we are among the saved and that grace was earned 2000 years ago on the Cross but how is it wrong to say that grace has to be applied to our lives and bring us to faith and repentence allowing the Holy Spirit to dwell within us? That's the Bible dude.â€Â



Here in is the difference of our theology of the cross, we would be more in agreement then disagreement in regards to God’s grace being applied to our lives, causing us to grow and have victory over specific sin issues. This is the aspect of being “simultaneously a sinner†I alluded to earlier in my responses. Certainly, by the end of our life, we should have spiritually matured, or one must question if they ever were saved (2 Cor.13:5). Where we would disagree, is that though one is never perfect in this life, when they crossover they become actually perfect both body and soul (1Cor.15:52-54), thus, no need for an intermediate state. In regards to the aspect of being “simultaneously a saint†even in this realm, Pink states it well:


“The justification of the believer is absolute, complete, final. "It is God that justifieth" (Rom. 8:33), and "I know that, whatsoever God doeth, it shall be for ever: nothing can be put to it, nor any thing taken from it" (Eccl. 3:14). So absolute and inexorable is this blessed fact that, in Romans 8:30 we are told, "Whom He justified, them He also glorified": notice it is not simply a promise that God "will glorify," but so sure and certain is that blissful event, the past tense is used. "Them He also glorified" is speaking from the standpoint of the eternal and unalterable purpose of God, concerning which there is no conditionality or contingency whatsoever. To be "glorified" is to be perfectly conformed to the lovely image of Christ, when we shall see Him as He is and be made like Him (1 John 3:2). Because God has determined this, He speaks of it as already accomplished, for He "calleth those things which be not as though they were" (Rom. 4:17).â€Â

Hopefully, you can recognize that our position has already been established in the heaven according to Scripture. The penalty already
Paid in full as Pink also states:




‘So far as the believer is concerned, the penal side of the sin question has been settled once and for all. His case has been tried in the supreme court, and God has justified him: in consequence thereof the Divine decision is "There is therefore now no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus" (Rom. 8:1). Once those very persons were under condemnationâ€â€"condemned already" (John 3:18); but now that their faith has united them to Christ there is no condemnation. The debt of their sin has been paid by their great Surety; the record thereof has been "blotted out" by His cleansing blood. "It is God that justifieth. Who is he that condemneth" (Rom. 8:33, 34). Who will reverse His decision! Where is that superior tribunal to which this cause can be carried? Eternal justice has pronounced her fiat; immutable judgment has recorded her sentence.â€Â

That is why I can state with confidence that your hypothetical situation with Billy and the last day on earth convert, that the latter went straight to heaven. Though he never had the chance to make right his many transgressions. Thank fully he was covered by the blood of Jesus.
Bubba.
 
Bubba,

That is the kind of response I have been trying to get out of you all along and I thank you for it. I will try get back to you later on it as it raises more questions. :D

Thess
 
Where we would disagree, is that though one is never perfect in this life, when they crossover they become actually perfect both body and soul (1Cor.15:52-54), thus, no need for an intermediate state. In regards to the aspect of being “simultaneously a saint†even in this realm, Pink states it well:

Actually I really have no problem with this (though I do think it is possible for one to become perfect by God's grace but most don't). Actually that crossover point that you are talking about is purgatory. You have to admit that there is the action of the grace of Christ during that crossover in which the cleansing is completed. That there is a difference in the cleansing that needs to take place in different indivuals based on what has been completed in this life. The point is that the cleansing has to be completed before heaven. There is no definition of time for purgatory. It may well be instantaneous.

I have no problem with someone being said to be a saint in this realm. The communion of saints doctrine speaks of those on earth as saints IN THIS REALM. It is not improper to call those in Christ saints. So from what I see is that with regard to what you believe (unless you don't think any kind of cleansing and completion really takes place in the crossover point) is that we are arguing a distinction without a difference with regard to purgatory.

“The justification of the believer is absolute, complete, final. "It is God that justifieth" (Rom. 8:33), and "I know that, whatsoever God doeth, it shall be for ever: nothing can be put to it, nor any thing taken from it" (Eccl. 3:14). So absolute and inexorable is this blessed fact that, in Romans 8:30 we are told, "Whom He justified, them He also glorified": notice it is not simply a promise that God "will glorify," but so sure and certain is that blissful event, the past tense is used.

By your definition of justification, there is no justification in purgatory.


Hopefully, you can recognize that our position has already been established in the heaven according to Scripture. The penalty already
Paid in full as Pink also states:

I agree that it has been paid in full. Actually it has even for those who don't accept the payment. Christ earned more than enough grace for all the sins of man. Once again the grace must be applied. It will be applied before entry to heaven for all whom God forknew would go to heaven by his grace.



That is why I can state with confidence that your hypothetical situation with Billy and the last day on earth convert, that the latter went straight to heaven. Though he never had the chance to make right his many transgressions. Thank fully he was covered by the blood of Jesus.
Bubba.

That there is no condemnation has nothing to do with my arguement. I fully agree they both go to heaven. But you admit there is that crossover point above. And as I read your words there is a cleansing going on then.

when they crossover they become actually perfect both body and soul

Do you admit that a different level of cleansing has to take place in each or is the cleansing an optional thing. From the quote above it sounds like you would have to admit that since Billy had some of this grace applied in his life and the other guy didn't there has to be more perfecting going on in the other guy in this crossover period. Why does Billy go through the cleansing in life and the other guy just go straight to heaven? As I said before sins cannot just be covered up. You say they ACTUALLY become perfect. This to mean means that the righteousness is no longer imputed and the sinner becomes actually righteous and "cleansed of all unrighteourness'. From what I read the only real difference in this area is that you don't like the word purgatory. Well the other difference is that you don't really understand it either.

Anyway, thanks for finally answering.

Blessings
 
Thess,
I am going to call it quits on this subject, but I just want you to know that I appreciate that our responses stayed civil. I know a while back things got out of hand, for that again accept my apologies.
Your brother in Christ, Bubba
 
Bubba said:
Thess,
I am going to call it quits on this subject, but I just want you to know that I appreciate that our responses stayed civil. I know a while back things got out of hand, for that again accept my apologies.
Your brother in Christ, Bubba

Not really out of hand. It's been fun. Blessings.
 
Back
Top