Jack Straw,
That is because there is no "man's free will," only God's Will. There is only "the illusion" of free will for man when seen through carnal, worldly eyes.
Free will is a doctrine that teaches that man can act independently of God. This should already put up a red flag to the spiritually-attuned ear.
Man has always had free will. It is inherent in the very make up of man, being created in God's image and with a rational soul.
If man is not free then man is not responsible for his actions. God did not desire a creature of the same sort like an animal, but one with a soul. The whole purpose of man's existance depends on man's free will, and God's revelation to man would be meaningless if man did not have a rational soul, a free will.
Do you believe that man's will can operate independently of God? Yes or no?
absolutely. If not, then God is the cause of all actions of man. It is God who sins, not man. There is no need for man to know God, to know what God expects from him in a relationship. YOu have man even worse off that animals, yet God created man like Himself, able to communicate freely with God, to respond to God.
Of course all people have a "will" ... but that's not the issue. The problem comes from the word "free". To be free means to be independent of influence. Therefore, not even God can influence a free will... nor can Satan. If a human will is influenced, even in the smallest possible way, by anything at all, then that will cannot, by definition, be free.
Free will has NEVER meant without influence. That is an autonomous will. Man has a will that is free from force, coercion from outside forces, namely God and satan. Neither God nor satan can force man to do something against man's will. Man would not be responsible for his actions if they were actually done by others. Man operates, and can actually only operate with influences. Man is incapable of creating the influences, they exist mostly external including the flesh or his own passions against his will.
Free will replaces Christ, and instead, man becomes the deciding factor in his own salvation. Jesus Christ's work on the cross, according to this doctrine, was only a potential salvation,
Man's individual salavation has nothing directly to do with Christ's work on the Cross. Christ did not save you individually on the Cross. Christ overcame death and sin which man could not do.
But man was created specifically to have the relationship in which we freely enter into union with Christ. That is why He saved the world from death, for the power of satan, so that God and man could again be united in an eternal relationship, which man enters freely and is the sole determinate of his eternal abode.
this is why most of those texts you cited have nothing to do with man, because they all deal with What Christ did for mankind and the world. Man does not effect or affect anything that Christ did on the Cross. He cannot change it, he cannot add to it, he cannot subtract from it. All men receive God's grace in the salvation from death, from the fall.
Jesus Christ's work on the cross, according to this doctrine, was only a potential salvation, not an actual salvation.... it's one's OWN BELIEF that does the saving. According to this doctrine, the cross of Christ never saved anybody; the cross only saves those who decide to be saved. What about the verse that says "no one can come to Christ unless the Father draws him?" (John 6:44)? That has nothing to do with man's free will? How about: Romans 9:16: "It is NOT of him that WILLS or of him that runs, but of GOD that shows mercy."
there is no potential at all. It is a matter of factual completion that Christ saved the world, Christ overcame death, the power of satan. It is why all Christians have always beleived in the resurrection of the dead. All men were given life, an eternal existance. This is what Col 1:20, II Cor 5:18-9, I Cor 15:22, John 6:39, Rom 5:18, Heb 2:12, Rom 11:32 are all saying.
Christ saved mankind so that man could freely choose again. Without Christ overcoming death, we are all condemned to death through Adam, annihilation, ceasing to exist as human beings, dust to dust, Gen 3:19.
This it is one's one belief, one's own desire, decision to be joined with Christ. Crhist saved all men just so that all men could have the same choice as Adam. So that the Holy Spirit can call all men to repentance, After all, God loves mankind, He created man to have an eternal union with Him, why would He not save all, so that all could free choose?
YOur text of JOhn 6:44 would not be possible if Christ had not overcome death. God draws all men to Himself, John 32:12 because God is just and will give every human being the choice. Man can never say that He was not given the chance to know God. God makes sure of that, but man must decide whether to accept that call.
Rom 9:16 is about what Christ will do, not what man will do. YOur answer to that three chapter discourse is Rom 11:32.
Even if Adam had free will, God is responsible for what happened in the Garden.
NOt at all. ADam is the sole individual responsible for what happened. Not God, not even Satan. Adam could have remained faithful to God. But he accepted the wiles of the devil in deceiving him and freely sinned.
God is responsible for it if He made him a free moral agent with free will. If God made man with free will, then God created within man the propensities for either good or evil which determined his choices. If God made man with free will, He knew beforehand what the result would be, and He would be just as responsible for the acts of that person with free will as He would be for the act of a pre-programmed mechanical "drone" that He made.
NOt at all. Man did not need to or was compelled to sin. He could have remained faithful and never sinned. Just because created man with a free will, does not make God ressponsible fo the actions of that free individual. This understanding is probably based on your incorrect understanding of what constitutes free will as you described above.
Saving faith is the GIFT OF GOD, NOT AN EXERCISE OF MAN'S "FREE WILL" ... Ephesians 2:8-9: "For by grace are you saved through faith, and that NOT OF YOURSELVES; it is the Gift of God."
Everything is a gift from God. But man was given the freedom to use those gifts wisely or unwisely. He has given you air to breathe also, but you can hold your breath and die. God did not cause you to die.
People must believe, of course, but it is not the old desperately wicked heart or the old carnal mind which believes, but the faith graciously given by God as a gift is the instrument of a person's believing.
every single human being has been given everything possible so that all men have the ability, the capability to believe. NO man will be lost, or forgotten and have an excuse that he did not have the chance or opportunitity to believe. Rom 1:18-24.
Another example is Lazarus. Lazarus was a physical example of a Spiritual truth. Unregenerate man (not reborn in the Spirit) is DEAD (spiritually). Unregenerate man does not seek the Lord: Romans 3:10-11: "There is none that understands, there is NONE THAT SEEKS after God.... nor does unregenerate man comprehend the things of the Spirit: 1 Corinthians 2:14 "Natural man does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; and HE CANNOT UNDERSTAND THEM, because they are SPIRITUALLY discerned."
one can take texts out of context and make them say anything which is what happens with this text.
First, Paul is quoting the Ps. In the Ps it is those that have rejected God in which this phrase is given. In Rom Paul is trying to make a point with his Judizers who thought they were special and they only should be saved by the Messiah. Paul then uses part of the Ps text to show that all men have sinned, all men have fallen short.
And to whom will God give grace and mercy, all, Rom 11:32, God does so, then recreated man in God Image by His Incarnation and resurrection. God makes sure all men come to HIm because He calls all men, all men will come to Him, but man will make the choice of whether he will actually join with God or reject God. That decision is an active one of man which is why God can judge justly. It is not a passive act of man, or an ignorant act of man, but one with knowledge and free choice.
The Shepherd will not lose even ONE of them. And the lost sheep do not seek after The Shepherd, but rather, The Shepherd seeks after the lost sheep. The majority of Christendom has it backwards.
the fact that the shepherd is going out looking, says he has already lost one. But God does, by the work of the Holy Spirit influence man, chastens believers to come back. But man can and does quench the Holy Spirit. Man can and does reject Christ even after believeing and living a life in Christ for a time. God cannot force you to remain, just as He could not force Adam not to sin. It was a free choice, a choice we will all answer to at the judgement.
Free will is unbiblical. So many believe in free will because it's a tradition of men that's been around for a long time, but it's a lie.
it is one of the most basic foundational aspects of God revelation to man. Without free will, revelation is totally useless and meaningless.
Faith and commitment are gifts from God, not something that comes from our own independent WILL within.
scripture never says it is. They are gifts, but gifts that man uses or abuses. The parable of the talents is about gifts being used wisely, faith being one of them.
The danger of the free will doctrine is that the end result can only result in self-righteousness. People believe their good faith and belief are matters of human accomplishment that separate them from those who are less accomplished than they are. They think their commitment and faith are what separate them eternally from those faithless no-good unbelievers who have neither faith nor commitment. People soon forget (if they ever realized) that the source of their faith and belief is from God, and ONLY God, not themselves: 1 Corinthians 4:7: "For what makes you different from anybody else, and what have you got that was not given to you? And if anything has been given to you, WHY BOAST OF IT AS IF YOU HAD ACHIEVED IT YOURSELF?"
this statement is mostly based on your incorrect understanding of "free will". Most of this has already been explained above.
Free will is extremely deceptive and dangerous because man becomes the deciding factor in his own salvation
which is precisely what scripture teaches. It is why God will judge you justly, because it is based on what you desired and did with all that God has given each human being.
SELF (one's OWN belief in Jesus) becomes Savior, not Jesus Himself and His Sacrifice. Very tricksy!
What Jesus did as Savior of the world is not effected or affected by what you do. He saved you for the sole purpose that you could live eternally, and freely choose or reject Him as you were created to do. a choice ADam denied to you by His sin and the judgement of death against Him and mankind.
No one can come to Jesus on their own free will: John 6:44: "NO ONE is able to come to Me UNLESS the Father Who sent Me DRAWS HIM unto Me."
correct, but only man decides whether to accept that call. Which is why all men will be judged. All men have been called, all men will have made an active choice regarding that call. NO one will be left out. Thus God draws all men, John 32:12, and calls all to repentance, II Pet 3:5, Mark 2:17.