Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

OSAS....Not !

Merry, it is so strange that so many people I know that believe OSAS are not showing Jesus in them. I wonder why. My practice of my faith in Jesus is not like yours. But you know what? He is making life so easy for me and my family. I used to hate working for anybody else when I was non-believer but now because of His teaching and commands He is helping us to be grateful for working for Him. I can never thank Him enough. My life as mother is so easy because my kids are determined to be obedient to Him. We know by our fruit if we are true believers. OSAS supporters are not showing much of His power in them.
 
Why because they're not doing what you're doing the exact way you're doing it? I can assure you that the OSAS believers, the ones who are TRUE christian and who actually understand the theology, (are you sure the ones you know fit into these catagories?) do so show the power of God in their lives. You see Jesus reflected from them time and time again. The giving is from Jesus, the obedience is from Jesus the love is from Jesus and NONE of it is from 'them'.

Here's my suggestion for you, instead of looking at the failings of others and saying "It must be because they believe..blah blah blah" why not keep your eyes fixed on Jesus instead...that way the the righteousness of Christ will shine through more and not your self righteousness. That's what I 'try' to do anyway - fix my eyes on Jesus...the author and finisher of my faith :)
 
I've also noticed in OSAS believers (the ones who are true christian and who understand the theology properly) also never ever glorify or boast about their own works. Instead all the works they they do they give all glory to Christ and Christ alone because they understand that it's not them but rather Christ that's performing the work in them and through them.
 
Merry Menagerie said:
Why because they're not doing what you're doing the exact way you're doing it? I can assure you that the OSAS believers, the ones who are TRUE christian and who actually understand the theology, (are you sure the ones you know fit into these catagories?) do so show the power of God in their lives. You see Jesus reflected from them time and time again. The giving is from Jesus, the obedience is from Jesus the love is from Jesus and NONE of it is from 'them'.

Here's my suggestion for you, instead of looking at the failings of others and saying "It must be because they believe..blah blah blah" why not keep your eyes fixed on Jesus instead...that way the the righteousness of Christ will shine through more and not your self righteousness. That's what I 'try' to do anyway - fix my eyes on Jesus...the author and finisher of my faith :)

Most church goers believe your theories. Are you judging them as they are not following your way? Why do so many people misunderstand your theory? They are not as smart as you? It is not so hard to see if Christisns are showing the fruit. The Bible tells us not to have anything to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness. Are you sure your church is producing fruit?
 
[quote="gingercat]
Most church goers believe your theories.[/quote]

I really don't know what most church goers believe...but in my experience it's been the other way round for me...must be where we live and whatever 'trend' happens to be 'in' in that area. Nevertheless I really don't care what most churches believe. I prefer to base my beliefs on what the bible says and try not to follow the doctrines of man if I can help it. Been there - done that and it almost destroyed me. Never again!

Are you judging them as they are not following your way?

I don't believe I judge anyone. But if you've seen anywhere that I have actually judged anyone and told them they are going to hell then I'll gladly apologise but it's not my position to judge the hearts of man because I don't know their hearts. And I really don't care who follows who's way. The reason I post is - number one - to learn and number two - to share what it is and why I believe what I do in the hopes to edify and perhaps make people see a different perspective which may or maynot lead to change. I certainly do not post so as to make anyone conform to whatever I believe.

Why do so many people misunderstand your theory?

Well it's not exactly 'my' theory. It's the theory of man really. I subscribe to it because I see the parrallel in the bible and feel that it's closest to what I believe is what the bible says. Why don't they understand the theology? I don't really know - it took me a while to grasp it as well because I too thought that OSAS subscribers had a licence to sin and went around sinning everywhere - until I actually met some and researched the theology itself. But I could ask - why do so many people misunderstand the bible? I don't really know! They just do. I know I misunderstand certain aspects. Thank God that salvation is not dependant upon how much we understand of the bible eh? ;)

They are not as smart as you?

Smart? Aahh I don't really know. I don't see myself as particularly smart - I'm a bit of a dummy really. But over the years I have learned a few things by trial and error. Fallen over a few stumbling blocks and have overcome a lot of obstacles to get to the point I am today. But there's plenty more to come and as I grow - so too will my understanding of certain things. Just like everyone else.

It is not so hard to see if Christisns are showing the fruit.

Quite true but I do know of some who could be going through some trials and tribulations who may not necessarily show the fruits during that time - that doesn't make them any less Christian than you or I but it does show that they are troubled and possibly immature and in need of healing and guidance. But generally, true Christians do show the fruits of the Holy Spirit when they are walking in the spirit - just every now and again such people would go through things that might make them look less like a christian than other times. Doesn't mean they are no longer a child of God just becuase they're going through something. I've been there myself. I was 'troubled' not 'unsaved'.

The Bible tells us not to have anything to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness.

Well you better not have anything to do with anyone since we all sin and we all produce bad fruit from time to time. It's the overcomers that we fellowship with - not the perfect. None of us are perfect.

Are you sure your church is producing fruit?

If by 'church' you mean a building with people in it then - I dont' actually go to church. But if you are meaning the spiritual body of Christ who fellowship and get together for the Lord - then yes I do see the fruits of the Holy Spirit and I'm in fellowship with them because I am in the light. I don't fellowship with the 'sin' part of them rather I fellowship with the 'christ' part of them. And there is a difference - since we're all in the flesh and we all sin then it's possible to be in fellowship with each other and not really be in fellowship with the 'dark' or 'sinful' part of ourselves.

Hard to explain but hey - I get there eventually ;)
 
I must add here that the people I fellowship with - some believe in OSAS and some don't and yet I'm in fellowship with them because we are in the light.

"If we are in the light as he is in the light we have fellowship one with another....."
 
Merry Menagerie said:
[quote="gingercat]
Most church goers believe your theories.

I really don't know what most church goers believe...but in my experience it's been the other way round for me...must be where we live and whatever 'trend' happens to be 'in' in that area. Nevertheless I really don't care what most churches believe. I prefer to base my beliefs on what the bible says and try not to follow the doctrines of man if I can help it. Been there - done that and it almost destroyed me. Never again!

Are you judging them as they are not following your way?

I don't believe I judge anyone. But if you've seen anywhere that I have actually judged anyone and told them they are going to hell then I'll gladly apologise but it's not my position to judge the hearts of man because I don't know their hearts. And I really don't care who follows who's way. The reason I post is - number one - to learn and number two - to share what it is and why I believe what I do in the hopes to edify and perhaps make people see a different perspective which may or maynot lead to change. I certainly do not post so as to make anyone conform to whatever I believe.

Why do so many people misunderstand your theory?

Well it's not exactly 'my' theory. It's the theory of man really. I subscribe to it because I see the parrallel in the bible and feel that it's closest to what I believe is what the bible says. Why don't they understand the theology? I don't really know - it took me a while to grasp it as well because I too thought that OSAS subscribers had a licence to sin and went around sinning everywhere - until I actually met some and researched the theology itself. But I could ask - why do so many people misunderstand the bible? I don't really know! They just do. I know I misunderstand certain aspects. Thank God that salvation is not dependant upon how much we understand of the bible eh? ;)

They are not as smart as you?

Smart? Aahh I don't really know. I don't see myself as particularly smart - I'm a bit of a dummy really. But over the years I have learned a few things by trial and error. Fallen over a few stumbling blocks and have overcome a lot of obstacles to get to the point I am today. But there's plenty more to come and as I grow - so too will my understanding of certain things. Just like everyone else.

It is not so hard to see if Christisns are showing the fruit.

Quite true but I do know of some who could be going through some trials and tribulations who may not necessarily show the fruits during that time - that doesn't make them any less Christian than you or I but it does show that they are troubled and possibly immature and in need of healing and guidance. But generally, true Christians do show the fruits of the Holy Spirit when they are walking in the spirit - just every now and again such people would go through things that might make them look less like a christian than other times. Doesn't mean they are no longer a child of God just becuase they're going through something. I've been there myself. I was 'troubled' not 'unsaved'.

The Bible tells us not to have anything to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness.

Well you better not have anything to do with anyone since we all sin and we all produce bad fruit from time to time. It's the overcomers that we fellowship with - not the perfect. None of us are perfect.

Are you sure your church is producing fruit?

If by 'church' you mean a building with people in it then - I dont' actually go to church. But if you are meaning the spiritual body of Christ who fellowship and get together for the Lord - then yes I do see the fruits of the Holy Spirit and I'm in fellowship with them because I am in the light. I don't fellowship with the 'sin' part of them rather I fellowship with the 'christ' part of them. And there is a difference - since we're all in the flesh and we all sin then it's possible to be in fellowship with each other and not really be in fellowship with the 'dark' or 'sinful' part of ourselves.

Hard to explain but hey - I get there eventually ;)[/quote]

You are the kind that I would avoid talking to because you are good at making your faith mystical and more complicated than it is. God is not a God of confusion. He is very clear. Good day Merry. I am sorry I bothered you.
 
Two questions.

1. Does the OSAS philosophy mean that one can't possibly reject the Holy Spirit even if a former Christian should later choose to follow a nonChristian religion? People DO do this, by the way!

2. Where is the doctrine of OSAS found in the Bible? Or, is this a relatively recent frame of thought popularized by the modern church who are 'ho-hum' about obedience to God?

These questions may well have been raised before but I'm too lazy to browse through the entire thread.
 
gingercat said:
Merry Menagerie said:
[quote="gingercat]
Most church goers believe your theories.

I really don't know what most church goers believe...but in my experience it's been the other way round for me...must be where we live and whatever 'trend' happens to be 'in' in that area. Nevertheless I really don't care what most churches believe. I prefer to base my beliefs on what the bible says and try not to follow the doctrines of man if I can help it. Been there - done that and it almost destroyed me. Never again!

Are you judging them as they are not following your way?

I don't believe I judge anyone. But if you've seen anywhere that I have actually judged anyone and told them they are going to hell then I'll gladly apologise but it's not my position to judge the hearts of man because I don't know their hearts. And I really don't care who follows who's way. The reason I post is - number one - to learn and number two - to share what it is and why I believe what I do in the hopes to edify and perhaps make people see a different perspective which may or maynot lead to change. I certainly do not post so as to make anyone conform to whatever I believe.

[quote:8ded7]Why do so many people misunderstand your theory?

Well it's not exactly 'my' theory. It's the theory of man really. I subscribe to it because I see the parrallel in the bible and feel that it's closest to what I believe is what the bible says. Why don't they understand the theology? I don't really know - it took me a while to grasp it as well because I too thought that OSAS subscribers had a licence to sin and went around sinning everywhere - until I actually met some and researched the theology itself. But I could ask - why do so many people misunderstand the bible? I don't really know! They just do. I know I misunderstand certain aspects. Thank God that salvation is not dependant upon how much we understand of the bible eh? ;)

They are not as smart as you?

Smart? Aahh I don't really know. I don't see myself as particularly smart - I'm a bit of a dummy really. But over the years I have learned a few things by trial and error. Fallen over a few stumbling blocks and have overcome a lot of obstacles to get to the point I am today. But there's plenty more to come and as I grow - so too will my understanding of certain things. Just like everyone else.

It is not so hard to see if Christisns are showing the fruit.

Quite true but I do know of some who could be going through some trials and tribulations who may not necessarily show the fruits during that time - that doesn't make them any less Christian than you or I but it does show that they are troubled and possibly immature and in need of healing and guidance. But generally, true Christians do show the fruits of the Holy Spirit when they are walking in the spirit - just every now and again such people would go through things that might make them look less like a christian than other times. Doesn't mean they are no longer a child of God just becuase they're going through something. I've been there myself. I was 'troubled' not 'unsaved'.

The Bible tells us not to have anything to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness.

Well you better not have anything to do with anyone since we all sin and we all produce bad fruit from time to time. It's the overcomers that we fellowship with - not the perfect. None of us are perfect.

Are you sure your church is producing fruit?

If by 'church' you mean a building with people in it then - I dont' actually go to church. But if you are meaning the spiritual body of Christ who fellowship and get together for the Lord - then yes I do see the fruits of the Holy Spirit and I'm in fellowship with them because I am in the light. I don't fellowship with the 'sin' part of them rather I fellowship with the 'christ' part of them. And there is a difference - since we're all in the flesh and we all sin then it's possible to be in fellowship with each other and not really be in fellowship with the 'dark' or 'sinful' part of ourselves.

Hard to explain but hey - I get there eventually ;)[/quote:8ded7]

You are the kind that I would avoid talking to because you are good at making your faith mystical and more complicated than it is. God is not a God of confusion. He is very clear. Good day Merry. I am sorry I bothered you.[/quote]

That's your call. God bless you and your family in the new year gingercat :)
 
SputnikBoy said:
Two questions.

1. Does the OSAS philosophy mean that one can't possibly reject the Holy Spirit even if a former Christian should later choose to follow a nonChristian religion? People DO do this, by the way!


If reject means to blaspheme then no I don't believe that a true born again child of God would blaspheme the Holy Spirit. If one is SEEN to be doing such, as you have described then the bible says that he was never one of us to begin with.

2. Where is the doctrine of OSAS found in the Bible? Or, is this a relatively recent frame of thought popularized by the modern church who are 'ho-hum' about obedience to God?

There are plently of verses that have already been spouted throughout this site. There are the ones where it clearly states that it's God who keeps his children and will complete the work he has done in them. I don't know the definition of the 'modern church' for the church that I'm a part of has been around since the day of pentecost but the 'ho hum'ness about obedience that you see is not about "hey I can do whatever I want" it's about knowing that when you walk in the spirit you do mind the things of the spirit. Walking in the spirit to me is to crucify the flesh and to put my faith in Christ and rely on HIS OBEDIENCE for my obedience. So I'm 'seen' to be obedient by those around but in essence it's not me rather it's Christ in my that they see. "It's no longer I that liveth but Christ that liveth in me".

These questions may well have been raised before but I'm too lazy to browse through the entire thread.

Well I hope I have answered them to your satisfaction :)
 
Merry Menagerie said:
The only work that is required of us is belief. And it's this belief in Jesus is what will fulfill the works of God THROUGH US.

In a way. What's your scriptural support? (And I already know of John 6:29).

However, what works Yahweh wants to do in us is the problem between us. And I believe since people don't wanna submit themselves to Yahweh's Torah, they must form preconditions like this based off their opinion and judge you off of them.

Concepts like "robotism", as one guy was trying to argue with me earlier. Messiah can live in us, but not for us.

The problem with those who do not want to submit themselves to Yahweh's Torah is that they believe if it doesn't come "morally", then it doesn't need to be done.

They always say, "I don't have to look at the commandments to not kill. I don't want to kill".

That's not the point. That's good, but not the point. The point is that Yahweh does give us his Word for us to look in it and be obedient to it because we love him. It doesn't have to come across as a "moral" precept in order for our works to be true obedience.

If you heard Yahweh speak right now and he told you to go build a house made of legos (for whatever reason), would you tell him "no" because building lego houses is not "moral"? Building lego houses is not a "feeling" that comes naturally?

Of course you wouldn't say "no". Same thing with Yahweh's Torah. It's not divided into "moral" and "ceremonial" etc, where you have to figure out which ones are "moral" to perform, or that the "moral" ones will just "flow" through you as "all you have to do".

Nonsense. All of Yahweh's Word is "moral". Why do I say this? Why is something like keeping kosher "moral"?

Because of Matthew 22:37-40. It's about loving Yahweh and just doing what he tells you to do. And when the bible says "love is the fulfilling of the Torah", it doesn't mean a "feeling" replaces all commandments that aren't "moral" and are just "ceremonial".

It's speaking of the Ruach/Spirit behind from which the rest hang. If you participate in what the bible calls "dead works" and lack the main principle (Deuteronomy 6:4-5, Leviticus 19:18), then the Torah has not been "full" (another accurate translation for the Greek word pleroo, which is usually translated "fulfil").

Love fills it up. Makes it meaningful. That was Messiah's point in Matthew 22, Mark 12 and Luke 10.

Because I believe in Jesus and because Christ is the one who's living and I'm dead - then I don't murder. I don't steal. I love my neigbour. I love one another (the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts BY THE HOLY GHOST). And the only effort that comes in is the work of God - BELIEF!!!

Well, it all depends on how one understands your words. You're only saying this (forgive me if this is untrue) because you would deny something like the keeping of the sabbath. It's not "moral". It's not something you could "automatically" do without looking at the bible.

But that was never and still is not nor will ever be Yahweh's point! That is not in scripture. From Yahweh's perspective, just doing what he says because you love and believe him is the point. That's the only "moral" principle you need to understand.

And whether that is keeping kosher, keeping the sabbath, wearing tassels, studying to show yourself approved, or offering up your own son, then that's what you have to do.

So no one (not me at least) is boasting of any works ("I do this" and "I do that"). People are just trying to tell some of us that the way of thinking as presented above is wrong. They are not trying to work for salvation, or boast of works, and are not trying to bring people into bondage.

I can tell you right now....that I don't obey any of the commandments. Nope! I don't wake up in the morning and think 'Gee I better not kill anyone today' - I don't have to. Why? Because it's no longer I that liveth but Christ that liveth in me. Christ does not murder so I don't murder because he's the one that's living and not me. Therefore HE FULFILS the law through us and not me.

My exact point, as above. This is no point at all. It's good that you know not to kill. But that has no effect on the whole of what Yahweh commands us. By your logic, we shouldn't be baptized. No one can conclude they need to be baptized without reading the bible.

So this logic fails (no offense). And I personally believe that there are many other wrong things many people would or wouldn't do if there was nothing written. The only reason you say you know what to do is because it's written! "Christ lives in me" is something written in the bible.

If it was left up to me then I'd be doomed and so would you. Anything that YOU DO from your own strength is seen as filthy rags to the Lord. The only works that mean anything are the righteous works of Christ in you - nothing more.

Again, more preconditions upon a believer based off of your own belief system. Our works are only filthy rags if they are for the self, or if we think they will merit us anything apart from Yahweh's righteousness.

But it's not about that. It's about hearing the Word of Yahweh and doing it (Luke 8:21). People take that filthy rags scripture out of context. He wasn't saying "don't obey my Torah because you cannot".

Begin in Isaiah 64, see who that scripture pertains to, and see the reason why that statement was made. Had nothing to do with faithful obedience.

Once you've realised this then you are no longer under a schoolmaster but you are graduated and walking in grace through faith.

David walked in grace and faith and yet kept the Torah. :-D So have many. The schoolmaster reference you are referring to in Galatians I believe you have taken out of context. Paul's writings must be read in the context of all the rest of what he says. We can discuss this, if you want to.

Dead people can't obey anything - they're crucified with Christ (or should be)...it sounds like you are trying to resurrect your flesh and trying to obey the law with this 'flesh' of yours. IF this is what you're doing - then you WILL fail!!!! Good luck with that :)

Again, more of your preconditions based off of your belief system of "feeling" what to do is right.

It is not about "trying" to obey the Torah! It's about just doing it because he said to do it. If you stumble, repent and pray for forgivness. We have an Advocate with the Father.

"I sin so I will throw out his Torah and just 'believe'" is not in the bible!
 
wavy said:
Merry Menagerie said:
The only work that is required of us is belief. And it's this belief in Jesus is what will fulfill the works of God THROUGH US.

In a way. What's your scriptural support? (And I already know of John 6:29).

That's the one. Do you deny the words of your Lord?

However, what works Yahweh wants to do in us is the problem between us. And I believe since people don't wanna submit themselves to Yahweh's Torah, they must form preconditions like this based off their opinion and judge you off of them.

Ok - that's nice for those people whoever they are.

Concepts like "robotism", as one guy was trying to argue with me earlier. Messiah can live in us, but not for us.

It's no longer I that liveth but Christ that liveth in me. We should be dead to sin and alive to God. If Christ isn't living for us then where is your life?

The problem with those who do not want to submit themselves to Yahweh's Torah is that they believe if it doesn't come "morally", then it doesn't need to be done.

"Doesn't need to be done" yes it needs to be done but not by us but by the one who can fulfill the Torah once and for all. Our fulfilment of the Torah means nothing because it's US doing the fulfilling. But if we actually have faith in Christ's finished work on the Cross then we rely on HIS fulfillment of the Torah in us and through us. Without him - we're nothing!

They always say, "I don't have to look at the commandments to not kill. I don't want to kill".

And the problem with that? That comes along with my new nature in Christ.

That's not the point. That's good, but not the point. The point is that Yahweh does give us his Word for us to look in it and be obedient to it because we love him. It doesn't have to come across as a "moral" precept in order for our works to be true obedience.

Yes he gives us his word to follow and in the word is the law. Now the law was our schoolmaster while we were sinners and in need of a saviour. Then Jesus came along and FULFILLED IT and nailed the law to the cross so now we no longer are we in need of a schoolmaster because he has sent the Holy Spirit and has written the law on our hearts. The law was to lead us to Christ...and now...my friend I am in Christ. How much more righteous can I be than in the one who saved me? Why do you think that any of my 'law abiding' is going to match up to the fulfillment of my Lord Jesus Christ in me?

If you heard Yahweh speak right now and he told you to go build a house made of legos (for whatever reason), would you tell him "no" because building lego houses is not "moral"? Building lego houses is not a "feeling" that comes naturally?

HE wouldn't! And he won't! Because Jesus will be the one to build the house ONCE and PERFECTLY!!! And he will do it THROUGH ME. That way HE gets the glory and not me! It's his works and obedience - not mine!

Of course you wouldn't say "no". Same thing with Yahweh's Torah. It's not divided into "moral" and "ceremonial" etc, where you have to figure out which ones are "moral" to perform, or that the "moral" ones will just "flow" through you as "all you have to do".

God wouldn't ask me to do something I could not do!

Nonsense. All of Yahweh's Word is "moral". Why do I say this? Why is something like keeping kosher "moral"?

If you are living under the law then you are not living in Grace. If you so much as disobey ONE of the laws then you disobey them ALL. Wouldn't it be much easier for you to actually put your faith in Christ's finished work on the cross? The Galatians found out how foolish this was - I'm surprised you haven't learned from their mistakes.

Because of Matthew 22:37-40. It's about loving Yahweh and just doing what he tells you to do. And when the bible says "love is the fulfilling of the Torah", it doesn't mean a "feeling" replaces all commandments that aren't "moral" and are just "ceremonial".

"For the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Ghost which is given". Love is the fulfillment of the Law - that's what the bible says. And not just any love - no...the love of God. The love of God which is shed abroad in our hearts by the HOLY GHOST - not us. NOT US!!!

It's speaking of the Ruach/Spirit behind from which the rest hang. If you participate in what the bible calls "dead works" and lack the main principle (Deuteronomy 6:4-5, Leviticus 19:18), then the Torah has not been "full" (another accurate translation for the Greek word pleroo, which is usually translated "fulfil").

I would agree with you on the 'dead works' part. I believe that a lot of people perform these 'dead works' because they think it makes them righteous. They don't and never will.

Love fills it up. Makes it meaningful. That was Messiah's point in Matthew 22, Mark 12 and Luke 10.

Love fulfills the Law.

Well, it all depends on how one understands your words. You're only saying this (forgive me if this is untrue) because you would deny something like the keeping of the sabbath. It's not "moral". It's not something you could "automatically" do without looking at the bible.

Jesus fulfilled the sabbath in me. He is my rest and my refuge and my fortress. I rest from my works in him - who is the sabbath. So yes that commandment is being obeyed in me through JEsus Christ my Lord. Praise God!

But that was never and still is not nor will ever be Yahweh's point! That is not in scripture. From Yahweh's perspective, just doing what he says because you love and believe him is the point. That's the only "moral" principle you need to understand.

No - when you believe in Jesus' finished work on the cross and have faith in the one he sent - then and ONLY then can ANY of the law be fulfilled in you. I can't DO what he says - only Jesus can. And when Jesus does what God says in me - then it's me who walks in HIS obedience and not my own. Then the obedience is truly righteous and not dead!

And whether that is keeping kosher, keeping the sabbath, wearing tassels, studying to show yourself approved, or offering up your own son, then that's what you have to do.

None of those things we need to do because they have already been done. The son was offered up, that son kept kosher, he kept the sabbath - not only did he keep the sabbath but he IS the sabbath, in fact he did all of those things ONCE AND FOR ALL. So that now that he abides in me - I TOO have been imputed with all that righteous obedience. What makes you think that anything that WE DO can match up to what the son has already done? To think that we can actually do anything is arrogant and prideful in my opinion.

So no one (not me at least) is boasting of any works ("I do this" and "I do that"). People are just trying to tell some of us that the way of thinking as presented above is wrong. They are not trying to work for salvation, or boast of works, and are not trying to bring people into bondage.

Yes they are!

My exact point, as above. This is no point at all. It's good that you know not to kill. But that has no effect on the whole of what Yahweh commands us. By your logic, we shouldn't be baptized. No one can conclude they need to be baptized without reading the bible.

I don't believe in baptism (physical baptism) ;) I cannot do what God commands that's why I need Jesus - that's the whole point of Jesus dying on the cross. If I was to physically obey all the law it would be like Jesus never came...or die on the cross.

So this logic fails (no offense). And I personally believe that there are many other wrong things many people would or wouldn't do if there was nothing written. The only reason you say you know what to do is because it's written! "Christ lives in me" is something written in the bible.

So you believe that the Holy Spirit would fail me if I never had a bible to 'refer' to? You believe that if I didn't have a bible and I relied fully on the guidance of his Holy Spirit that God would allow me to 'disobey'? Have you never heard of 'conviction'? I have no doubt that if all the bibles were burned up today that no true born again child of God would have any trouble obeying anything if they keep their faith in the one who has already done the obeying - Christ. The word of God was made flesh and now resides in my heart.

Again, more preconditions upon a believer based off of your own belief system. Our works are only filthy rags if they are for the self, or if we think they will merit us anything apart from Yahweh's righteousness.

The bible says that the works that are performed by us and not Christ in us are as filthy rags. We are dead remember! We are only alive IN CHRIST. When God looks upon us he sees Christ not us. So you can work all you like he won't be seeing anything but Christ's works anyway so it's all for naught.

But it's not about that. It's about hearing the Word of Yahweh and doing it (Luke 8:21). People take that filthy rags scripture out of context. He wasn't saying "don't obey my Torah because you cannot".

I know exactly what he was talking about. He was talking about our own works. We cannot do anything - it's Christ that does it in us. "Its no longer I that liveth but Christ that liveth in me".

Begin in Isaiah 64, see who that scripture pertains to, and see the reason why that statement was made. Had nothing to do with faithful obedience.

I know why that statement was made - it was talking about unrigheousness and works done in that unrighteousness.

David walked in grace and faith and yet kept the Torah.

David was under the old covenant.

The schoolmaster reference you are referring to in Galatians I believe you have taken out of context. Paul's writings must be read in the context of all the rest of what he says. We can discuss this, if you want to.

The context is the exact context that I used here. Please don't play me for a fool.

Again, more of your preconditions based off of your belief system of "feeling" what to do is right.

It is not about "trying" to obey the Torah! It's about just doing it because he said to do it. If you stumble, repent and pray for forgivness. We have an Advocate with the Father.

But don't you understand? The Torah is obeyed THROUGH US by the only one who will not stumble and fail at it - Christ! He is my saviour and deliverer.

"I sin so I will throw out his Torah and just 'believe'" is not in the bible!

No but Christ coming to fulfil the Torah and telling us to believe in him IS!!!
 
Merry Menagerie said:
SputnikBoy said:
Does the OSAS philosophy mean that one can't possibly reject the Holy Spirit even if a former Christian should later choose to follow a nonChristian religion? People DO do this, by the way!


If reject means to blaspheme then no I don't believe that a true born again child of God would blaspheme the Holy Spirit. If one is SEEN to be doing such, as you have described then the bible says that he was never one of us to begin with.

I'm referring to someone who has - for argument's sake - converted to Islam from Christianity. He/she was once a dedicated Christian, believed implicitly in Jesus Christ, was saved, had continued assurance of salvation ...then, for whatever reason, chose to become a Muslim. Are you saying that such a person was never REALLY saved to begin with? Doesn't this kind of example throw the OSAS doctrine into somewhat of a spin?
 
I did originally put more in this post, Merry. But I decided that was fruitless.

I will say that I don't believe you have answered my points, and I will say you have the traditional, abstract, non-Hebraic, lawless view of scripture.

But I don't mean any offense. This is only my opinion. I don't think engaging in more conversation will be fruitful. Be cool.
 
Hi all,

I don't believe one is saved the moment they receive the Lord. I believe one is reborn at that time, and as a babe in Christ the goal should be to work out your salvation.

Philippians 2:12 NIV.
[ Shining as Stars ] Therefore, my dear friends, as you have always obeyedâ€â€not only in my presence, but now much more in my absenceâ€â€continue to work out your salvation with fear and trembling,

It is clear one can not begin to do that until they have received Jesus.

It is my opinion that there are people who have received Jesus that have not worked out their salvation. In other words there are probably Christians who have not been saved. And I suspect that these are the ones who divert to other things, and make it appear that they have lost their salvation. when in fact they may never have acquired it in the first place.

I can tell you for a fact that I was not able to know (from personal experience) that I had been saved until after I had been a Christian for over ten years. When I knew I was saved was when God gave me some things that I did not know existed. That helps me deal with the sins of others, as well as the sins that I thought I still had in me.
 
Hebrews 7:12 NIV.
For when there is a change of the priesthood, there must also be a change of the law.

After the cross there was a change in the priesthood, and that meant a change in the Law.

Hebrews 7:19 NIV.
(for the law made nothing perfect), and a better hope is introduced, by which we draw near to God.

Obeying the old law makes nothing perfect.

Hebrews 9:22 NIV.
In fact, the law requires that nearly everything be cleansed with blood, and without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness.

Jesus shed his blood once and he is not about to do it again. Yes he fulfilled the requirements of the law by the shedding his blood.

James 1:25 NIV.
But the man who looks intently into the perfect law that gives freedom, and continues to do this, not forgetting what he has heard, but doing itâ€â€he will be blessed in what he does.

The new law gives us freedom that the old law did/does not.

James 2:8 NIV.
If you really keep the royal law found in Scripture, "Love your neighbor as yourself," [ Lev. 19:18] you are doing right.

James 2:10 NIV.
For whoever keeps the whole law and yet stumbles at just one point is guilty of breaking all of it.
James 2:12 NIV.
Speak and act as those who are going to be judged by the law that gives freedom,

That clearly states that I am not to speak and act as though I have to be judged the old law.
 
Windozer said:
Hebrews 7:12 NIV.
For when there is a change of the priesthood, there must also be a change of the law.

After the cross there was a change in the priesthood, and that meant a change in the Law.

Indeed. The next verses will tell us what the change was: a shifting from Levi to Messiah. :)

Hebrews 7:19 NIV.
(for the law made nothing perfect), and a better hope is introduced, by which we draw near to God.

Obeying the old law makes nothing perfect.

You misrepresented this. Again, the whole context of this chapter (and the ones before and the ones after) deal with Messiah's priesthood in the heavens and the setting aside of the Levitical order.

This scripture is speaking of atonement sacrifices (specifically the Yom Kippur sacrifice). Although they atoned for sin, they could not may you complete/perfect by keeping you from sinning again.

Hebrews 9:22 NIV.
In fact, the law requires that nearly everything be cleansed with blood, and without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness.

Jesus shed his blood once and he is not about to do it again. Yes he fulfilled the requirements of the law by the shedding his blood
.

You also misreprsented what this is saying. This is not saying he fulfilled the requirments of the "law" (I assume you mean in the context of so we don't have to -- sorry if this is not true). This is saying that he shed blood for sins according to Torah. That's the only way for things to be cleansed.

James 1:25 NIV.
But the man who looks intently into the perfect law that gives freedom, and continues to do this, not forgetting what he has heard, but doing itâ€â€he will be blessed in what he does.

The new law gives us freedom that the old law did/does not.

James quotes several Torah commandments in this book. You have superimposed "new law" and "old law" into this context. We are in bondage when we sin against the Torah (John 8:34) and are encased in our lustful flesh (Romans 7:23-25). The Torah is freedom when we obey. David spoke of this in Psalm 119:44-45. :)

James 2:8 NIV.
If you really keep the royal law found in Scripture, "Love your neighbor as yourself," [ Lev. 19:18] you are doing right.

Yes, and from this, according to Messiah's words in Matthew 22:37-40, hang all the Scriptures. So in essence, James is touching on what's weightier for true obedience to the rest to be realized. It all means nothing if you lack this, as the scripture you quote below says:

James 2:10 NIV.
For whoever keeps the whole law and yet stumbles at just one point is guilty of breaking all of it.

You can keep all the rest of Torah on the outside. But if love is not in you, you have broken it all. Context is a wonderful thing. :)

James 2:12 NIV.
Speak and act as those who are going to be judged by the law that gives freedom,

That clearly states that I am not to speak and act as though I have to be judged the old law.

Again, no indications of "new law" and "old law" are made here. You put them there. Rather, this is a clear reference to obedience (not offending in one point) and being free. Not a reference to "old law" and being free in some "new law".

Again, Messiah made it clear the the Torah and Neviim/Prophets and all the Ketuvim hung off of the two greatest principles (Deuteronomy 6:4-5; Leviticus 19:18).

Let's heed the words of Messiah. :)

As far as what you said this last verse is saying, that is nowhere indicated. It's saying act as if you were going to be judged according to freedom (true obedience). If you speak, act. Do as the Torah says. What you said is not there.
 
SputnikBoy said:

2. Where is the doctrine of OSAS found in the Bible?
It is satan's personal doctrine as shown in Genesis 3:4.
Or, is this a relatively recent frame of thought popularized by the modern church who are 'ho-hum' about obedience to God?
satan keeps promoting it in his, WAR...against God's commandments (Revelation 12:17)
 
Wavy said:
Again, no indications of "new law" and "old law" are made here. You put them there. Rather, this is a clear reference to obedience (not offending in one point) and being free. Not a reference to "old law" and being free in some "new law".

I did hey. Son you have got some learning to do.

Romans 8:2 NIV.
because through Christ Jesus the law of the Spirit of life set me free from the law of sin and death.

The law of the Spirit of life is the new law
the law of sin and death is the old law.

Hebrews 7:12 NIV.
For when there is a change of the priesthood, there must also be a change of the law.

At the cross there was a change in the priest hood. That is where Jesus took over.

Romans 10:4 NIV.
Christ is the end of the law so that there may be righteousness for everyone who believes.

Hebrews 7:11 NIV.
[ Jesus Like Melchizedek ] If perfection could have been attained through the Levitical priesthood (for on the basis of it the law was given to the people), why was there still need for another priest to comeâ€â€one in the order of Melchizedek, not in the order of Aaron?

Hebrews 10:17 NIV
Then he adds: "Their sins and lawless acts I will remember no more."

Who is he talking about there Wavy?

Romans 7:6 NIV.
But now, by dying to what once bound us, we have been released from the law so that we serve in the new way of the Spirit, and not in the old way of the written code.

Romans 7:25 NIV.
Thanks be to Godâ€â€through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself in my mind am a slave to God's law, but in the sinful nature a slave to the law of sin.

Wavy also said:
You also misrepresented what this is saying. This is not saying he fulfilled the requirements of the "law" (I assume you mean in the context of so we don't have to -- sorry if this is not true). This is saying that he shed blood for sins according to Torah. That's the only way for things to be cleansed.

Son the requirements of the law were that if you sinned you needed to be sprinkled with blood to be cleansed. Jesus fulfilled those requirements by shedding his blood which put an end to the requirements of the old law. That is how he fulfilled the law.

You need to be careful of who you are accusing of misrepresenting things, and perhaps look in the mirror.

I too knew all there was to know at your age. I have since forgot most of what I knew at that time.
 
Windozer said:
I did hey. Son you have got some learning to do.

We could go back and forth with comments like these all day just because we disagree. So let's just soundly conversate without this extra baggage. :)

Romans 8:2 NIV.
because through Christ Jesus the law of the Spirit of life set me free from the law of sin and death.

The law of the Spirit of life is the new law
the law of sin and death is the old law
.

Again, you have superimposed this. The Torah of the Spirit of life is obedience in spirit and truth. Torah obedience in true faith.

The law of sin and death is Romans 8:7. These people don't subject themselves to the Torah, but rather live in the flesh and can't or won't escape breaking it without renewal.

Deuteronomy 30:15 See, I have set before thee this day life and good, and death and evil;

Torah is life and good if we obey it in truth, but death and and evil if we walk in the flesh. This is what Paul is speaking of. He delights in it through a renewed mind and in the Spirit (which is obedience and true worship).

So again, you have created the distinction between some form of "old law" and some "new law"; making the "old law" what is in the Tanach and the "new law" in the NT. Manmade division. :)

Hebrews 7:12 NIV.
For when there is a change of the priesthood, there must also be a change of the law.

At the cross there was a change in the priest hood. That is where Jesus took over.

Again, as I said the change of law was the fact that since he was not from Levi, that commandment pertaining to which tribe had to "shift" (the meaning of the word "change" here) to the Messiah who came from Yahudah.

Romans 10:4 NIV.
Christ is the end of the law so that there may be righteousness for everyone who believes.

Yeah, this is a popular, misunderstood, butchered proof passage to prove that the Torah is done away with. That neither fits the context or the Greek word for "end" here, which is telos, meaning "goal" or "purpose".

Same word used here:

James 5:11 Behold, we count them happy which endure. Ye have heard of the patience of Job, and have seen the end of the Lord; that the Lord is very pitiful, and of tender mercy.

Is the Master "ended"?

Hebrews 7:11 NIV.
[ Jesus Like Melchizedek ] If perfection could have been attained through the Levitical priesthood (for on the basis of it the law was given to the people), why was there still need for another priest to comeâ€â€one in the order of Melchizedek, not in the order of Aaron?

Alrighty. I don't see what point you're trying to convey here though.

Hebrews 10:17 NIV
Then he adds: "Their sins and lawless acts I will remember no more."

Who is he talking about there Wavy?

Both houses of Israel, of course.

Romans 7:6 NIV.
But now, by dying to what once bound us, we have been released from the law so that we serve in the new way of the Spirit, and not in the old way of the written code.

Yes. Delievered from it in what way? You quoted it above in Hebrews as the author of Hebrews quotes from Jeremiah 31:34.

Romans 7:25 NIV.
Thanks be to Godâ€â€through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself in my mind am a slave to God's law, but in the sinful nature a slave to the law of sin.

Exactly.

Son the requirements of the law were that if you sinned you needed to be sprinkled with blood to be cleansed. Jesus fulfilled those requirements by shedding his blood which put an end to the requirements of the old law. That is how he fulfilled the law.

This made no sense to me whatsoever. It seems a very vague excuse to form an opinion about an "old law" that is "done away" (a.k.a. the first five books) and a "new law" that is put in it's place. No scripture justifies a "new law" though. You have inserted that into the scripture...

You need to be careful of who you are accusing of misrepresenting things, and perhaps look in the mirror.

Sure...

I too knew all there was to know at your age. I have since forgot most of what I knew at that time.

And yet I'm sure what you believed at my age was never what I believe currently. I used to believe what you believe, actually. I have since thrown all that traditional view of scripture away. :)
 
Back
Top