RND said:Not "was made" but "became."whirlwind said:To me it says....man was made a LIVING soul. He was already a soul.
Gen 2:7 And the LORD God formed man [of] the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.
1 + 1 = 2. Dust + God's breath = a Living soul. That doesn't mean man was already a soul it clearly means he "became" one.
He clearly became alive. Spiritually alive, a living soul, with God's breath.
Yes, that's exactly what I see. No man has ascended to heaven by way of resurrection as Jesus had. Jesus was prophesying what would happen at His death. Also, please note that "even" is bracketed or italicized and thus is not part of the original manuscript.[quote:8h93x2j6]Is that really what you see? It doesn't make sense. In our way of speaking it says...No man goes up except the same man that came down and it applies EVEN to our Savior.
Note these other translations confirm my assessment:
NIV - No one has ever gone into heaven except the one who came from heaven–the Son of Man.
ESV - No one has ascended into heaven except he who descended from heaven, the Son of Man.
RSV - No one has ascended into heaven but he who descended from heaven, the Son of man.[/quote:8h93x2j6]
I should have noticed "even"...and didn't. It does make a difference. I understand what you are saying. I still know that our souls were from Him, existed in the previous age and will continue through the following age but that verse isn't about that topic. Thank you for pointing it out.
I continue to see it being about the Son of man, of which we are part...as we are the body of Christ. When we are spiritually born with His breath of life we are in heaven. We are with Him. He lives and walks in us. We are one. We too are the sons of God, sons of man.
Evidently.[quote:8h93x2j6]I don't know diddly squat about Mormons
Sure. So do Buddist.but I will ask...do they believe in God?
Yes, as a created being.Do they believe in the Son?
Some.Are all of their beliefs unbiblical?
Rooted in paganism.How about Catholics?
Same thing. [/quote:8h93x2j6]How about Protestants?
Yes they are but the point is...all of their beliefs aren't wrong. So, if I understand something and it is also the same belief as one of the above mentioned does it mean it is wrong? Of course not. So why argue what is being put forward by saying....Mormons believe that or you got that from so and so?
I have proven it with the word. There are -zero- scriptures that suggest that man floats off to heaven without his body upon death. None.[quote:8h93x2j6] Because the Catholics bow to Mary are they wrong about everything? Because the Baptist teach rapture are they wrong about everything? If I am "spouting unbiblical doctrine" then.....PROVE IT with His Word without trying to fit me into some religious sect.[/b]
Psa 146:4 His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.
See Job 14:10-15.[/quote:8h93x2j6]
His flesh body is gone forever. His spiritual body, his soul with his spirit, is HIS BODY. His true body.
Take your example of Psalms. It tells us his breath goes forth but he returns to earth. His flesh body goes to dust as it was and his breath, his spirit goeth forth. Where does it goeth forth to?
- Ecclesiastes 12:7 Then shall the dust return to the earth as it was: and the spirit shall return unto God Who gave it
Our spirit, as you yourself pointed out, is not disembodied. It is part and parcel of our soul. We return to God.
Concerning your Job quote....I'll have to study it and reply later when I have some free time at work.
[quote:8h93x2j6]It is not!
- Job 27:3 All the while my breath is in me, AND the spirit of GOD is in my nostrils;
The breath is in him AND the spirit is in his nostrils. It is not a comparison but a decided difference in breath and spirit[/b]. :naughty
Let's try again:
Again the NIV - as long as I have life within me, the breath of God in my nostrils,
The word "and" is not used in the original Hebrew. Thus we can see that Job is comparing the breath that is in him to to the Spirit of God being in his nostrils. And what to nostrils do? They breath air. Thus it is clear that the air is being compared to God's breath. Simple stuff.[/quote:8h93x2j6]
You are comparing The Spirit of God to the air we breath. Not so simple at all. Everyone living in flesh breaths air. Everyone spiritually alive breaths air and has His Spirit.