Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Atonement: What did it REALLY Accomplish?

Hey, just because they think you may be going to hell is no reason to bring me along ....LOL

You confused them by saying ONLY THE DISOBEDIENT ARE SAVED.

They don't get it. They're trying to save you now. LOL
We're too dumb to get it Fred.
Not smart and super intelligent like calvinists that can accept a monster God.
 
From the beginning God had a plan on how salvation would be achieved.

Salvation would be IN HIM....
In Jesus.

God chose us IN HIM before the foundation of the world.
IOW,,,God would save us according to what Christ did in the atonement...
Those that would be "of Christ" would be saved.
We are saved IN HIM...
Don't see how your reply pertains to those verses
 
From the beginning God had a plan on how salvation would be achieved.

Salvation would be IN HIM....
In Jesus.

God chose us IN HIM before the foundation of the world.
IOW,,,God would save us according to what Christ did in the atonement...
Those that would be "of Christ" would be saved.
We are saved IN HIM...

The N.T. has many verses re how we abide IN HIM:

John 15:6
1 John 2:24
1 John 3:6
2 John 1:9
Hebrews 12:2
Galatians 2:20

and so many more....

God planned that we who choose Christ will abide IN HIM.
Will be saved IN HIM.
typo again in my reply to you. didn't mean "do see" meant "don't see"
 
Don't see how your reply pertains to those verses
Have to leave.
I guess what we really should be doing is trying to understand the nature of God.
Trying to understand why God created us to begin with.
Could it really be that He did this just to send most of us to hell?
Pretty sadistic God I'd say....
even if we DO deserve it.

You know...my cat might scratch me and deserve to sleep out in the cold...
but my love for him will not allow me to do that.

Imagine a God that sends persons to hell FOR NO REASON AT ALL.

I can see how the words predestine, chose, elect, could be confusing...
but only when someone preconditions us as to what they mean.

If we believe God is not a sadistic God then we can come to understand what they mean.
We would have to believe God is loving, merciful and just.
I don't really understand how anyone could believe He is anything else.
 
typo again in my reply to you. didn't mean "do see" meant "don't see"
Saw both.
Thought I was hallucinating when you changed it!!
Thanks for explaining.

I didn't even hope that you accepted my explanation...
but that maybe you came to UNDERSTAND it...
that would even be nice.
'night.
 
From the beginning God had a plan on how salvation would be achieved.

Salvation would be IN HIM....
In Jesus.

God chose us IN HIM before the foundation of the world.
IOW,,,God would save us according to what Christ did in the atonement...
Those that would be "of Christ" would be saved.
We are saved IN HIM...

The N.T. has many verses re how we abide IN HIM:

John 15:6
1 John 2:24
1 John 3:6
2 John 1:9
Hebrews 12:2
Galatians 2:20

and so many more....

God planned that we who choose Christ will abide IN HIM.
Will be saved IN HIM.
This might help

[Eph 1:11 KJV] 11 In whom also we have obtained an inheritance, being predestinated according to the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will:
[Eph 18-19 KJV] .
18 The eyes of your understanding being enlightened; that ye may know what is the hope of his calling, and what the riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints,
19 And what [is] the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power,

Still addressing the saints at Ephesus
 
Have to leave.
I guess what we really should be doing is trying to understand the nature of God.
Trying to understand why God created us to begin with.
Could it really be that He did this just to send most of us to hell?
Pretty sadistic God I'd say....
even if we DO deserve it.
Yeah that's a really good idea
 
Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, to the saints which are at Ephesus, and to the faithful in Christ Jesus:
God only "willed" Paul because Paul willed God. That self-determination (free will)


chosen us in him" doesn't say he chose anyone?
God only choses us because we chose Him. When we were nothing in eternity past, God determined by looking at nothing who would believe and the all knowing God learned what He would do according to what He saw nothing would do. This is how self-determination (free will) works. So in eternity past nothing some how was something and that controls God future decisions and providence. Simple Arminian metaphysics.
When it comes to salvation, man casts the deciding vote. Some free will proponents even preach that people today who never heard of Christ can save themselves. When it comes to whom God will adopt it is the children that tell the Father whom He will call His child. We are that powerful and important.
 
God only "willed" Paul because Paul willed God. That self-determination (free will)



God only choses us because we chose Him. When we were nothing in eternity past, God determined by looking at nothing who would believe and the all knowing God learned what He would do according to what He saw nothing would do. This is how self-determination (free will) works. So in eternity past nothing some how was something and that controls God future decisions and providence. Simple Arminian metaphysics.
When it comes to salvation, man casts the deciding vote. Some free will proponents even preach that people today who never heard of Christ can save themselves. When it comes to whom God will adopt it is the children that tell the Father whom He will call His child. We are that powerful and important.
Tomorrow....
your homework is to find out what God willed regarding Paul
and to find scripture to support it.
It has to do with a measure of faith.
 
lol, sorry, I go, you go
Well, let's not determine our ultimate destination by having a vote by those in the forum. Between the forum vote and self-determination, I pick self-determination.
Gee, I think I just converted.:rolleyes
 
God only "willed" Paul because Paul willed God. That self-determination (free will)



God only choses us because we chose Him. When we were nothing in eternity past, God determined by looking at nothing who would believe and the all knowing God learned what He would do according to what He saw nothing would do. This is how self-determination (free will) works. So in eternity past nothing some how was something and that controls God future decisions and providence. Simple Arminian metaphysics.
When it comes to salvation, man casts the deciding vote. Some free will proponents even preach that people today who never heard of Christ can save themselves. When it comes to whom God will adopt it is the children that tell the Father whom He will call His child. We are that powerful and important.

Wow, I'd better get going and let God know then- I'm late (kidding)
 
Well, let's not determine our ultimate destination by having a vote by those in the forum. Between the forum vote and self-determination, I pick self-determination.
Gee, I think I just converted.:rolleyes
No one here thinks you're going to hell.
And, if all your systematic theology books are correct,
you won't know till your life is almost over whether or not
you were really saved.
 
Wow, I'd better get going and let God know then- I'm late (kidding)
It's too late. When you were nothing you told God what you would do.

Hey, maybe like the Mormons who believe their soul is eternal and God asked that soul what it would do when it was given a body?
 
I feel that its best not to accidentally blaspheme the holy spirit by way of the Atonement.

What I mean is this: I can try to make atonement for my wife's behavior last night at dinner. Which in its context would be an absolutely correct way to say such a thing. Not by blood, but by making good on a wrongful deed.

In religious context: Its through the sacrifice of Christ on the Old Rugged Cross that reconciles mankind back to God. All mankind, but it's by the spirit of God that we are drawn to Him. To deny the Atonement or the affect it has on the human race, is taking away spirit thereof.

Atonement made in Old Testament was through an annual ceremony of a sacrifice of a lamb for the sins of that tribe.

Atonemrnt in the New Testament was made by God's Sons Blood which carries forever through Jesus Christ.
 
Eph 2:4-6

When did God make us alive together with Christ ?

Eph 2:4-6

4But God, who is rich in mercy, for his great love wherewith he loved us,

5Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ, (by grace ye are saved)

6And hath raised us up together, and made us sit together in heavenly places in Christ Jesus:


The answer to the question is in purpose and objectively we were raised up together with Christ at the same time He was raised up by The Father. That is what Paul is teaching here.24
 
God only choses us because we chose Him. When we were nothing in eternity past, God determined by looking at nothing who would believe and the all knowing God learned what He would do according to what He saw nothing would do. This is how self-determination (free will) works. So in eternity past nothing some how was something and that controls God future decisions and providence. Simple Arminian metaphysics.

Do you believe people are saved without believing the Gospel?
 
Do you believe people are saved without believing the Gospel?
Can someone (example: the 1282 North American Indian) be saved without believing the gospel? If so, what must he do/believe to be saved?
 
God has written onto the heart of men, His laws. How the Eternal King, the God of Glory judges that individual is God's doing.

More importantly though, what about our neighbor? Does our neighbor know the Gospel? Has the Eternal King put on your hearts to testify on His behalf, The truth? JESUS

Christians can get entrapped in these types of conversations, and it's great to learn wisdom and knowledge - but the truth is, only God Himself knows how he will judge those individuals. We can ask and seek answers but in the end, we still have questions and are still seeking answers. No one can possibly answer this line of question(s).

So let's as Christians put our energy into something we can do, tell our neighbors about the love of God and the Gospel.
 
Agreed ... only the disobedient can be saved.

I'll simplify it again.
Name one person that never disobeyed God that is saved (from His wrath)? If you can do that, I will change my opinion.

I wrote "Only the disobedient are saved"? That's a question, not a declaration. BTW, I don't agree with you.
 
Back
Top