Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Real Trinity please stand up!

Just so Godhead is complete from Jude:
Jude 19
These be they who separate themselves, sensual, having not the Spirit.
Jude 20
But ye, beloved, building up yourselves on your most holy faith, praying in the Holy Ghost,

I Corinthians 14:15
What is it then? I will pray with the spirit, and I will pray with the understanding also: I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also.

Romans 8:26
Likewise the Spirit also helpeth our infirmities: for we know not what we should pray for as we ought: but the Spirit itself maketh intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered.

We are at times seeing through a glass darkly. Not blind, but with a welding helmet on. LOL. When words fail us, we must rely on Holy Spirit. Holy Spirit does not violate scriptures, but there are: mentions of mysteries, things hidden, hard to understand, etc.

eddif
 
(Removed, ToS 2.1 Declaring false the basic tenets of Christianity and teaching that to others. Obadiah)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just so Godhead is complete from Jude:
Jude 19
These be they who separate themselves, sensual, having not the Spirit.
Jude 20
But ye, beloved, building up yourselves on your most holy faith, praying in the Holy Ghost,

I Corinthians 14:15
What is it then? I will pray with the spirit, and I will pray with the understanding also: I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also.

Romans 8:26
Likewise the Spirit also helpeth our infirmities: for we know not what we should pray for as we ought: but the Spirit itself maketh intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered.

We are at times seeing through a glass darkly. Not blind, but with a welding helmet on. LOL. When words fail us, we must rely on Holy Spirit. Holy Spirit does not violate scriptures, but there are: mentions of mysteries, things hidden, hard to understand, etc.

eddif

We all need to learn more. Our understanding is very limited here.

I did read a Baptist article about the Cathloic church FAlse Doctrine of the Trinity. They went and posted the real scriptural deal according to them.

Like telling the guy that invented the Rubic's Cube, we will make a real Rubic Cube.

There Is no Trinity Doctrine without the Roman Cathloic Church!!!!!! You would have to call it something else, becaue Rome already invented the Trinity Doctrine. That is plegerizzm at it's finest. However you spell that.

Was Reading the Southern Baptist Version of what they call their Trinity Doctrine.

"Finite Man can not understand"

It almost makes you want to cry that believers can be so dumb.

If you claim normal man can't understand, how do YOU even know it's Real in the first place?

Jesus said, I'll show you plainly of the FAther.................. PLAIN.

Anything that can't be explained then, can't be God, or Scripture. Jesus said.

I'll take his word over any Doctrine that is the mystery of Christain faith, that came out of Rome.

The problem is, the Trinity Doctrine is fine, it's the Modern mans addition that changed Jesus being of the same substance of God, to being just ONE GOD.

Modern man did that to the Doctrine and called it the Mystery of Christain faith. It's no mystery if you stick to the Real and Original Doctrine.

They were defending Jesus not being a created being. They were not defending Monotheism, was not even on the table, and Hence not even in the True and original Trinity Doctrine.

What my thread is about, the Original Trinity Doctrine, and it reads just like it reads.

(Removed, ToS 2.1 Declaring false the basic tenets of Christianity and teaching that to others. Obadiah)

Ummm, I suppse I won't get to read His thoughts, but says He is not Christian. I like Scripture only, so must be a good thing I can't read his post.
 
Free you postsed the same scriptures I did above, there is Only One Lord God. Jud said the same thing, and I asked something very simple.

Count how many God's you see in that scripture.

One Lord God, One Lord Jesus Christ.

IF Larry and Joy were standing side by side, and I asked you to count how many humans you see, you would have no issues.

That tells me a lot Free.

You can't acknowledge in 52 sciptures there is a son and FAther, 2 God's, but believe a handful of scriptures you think you believe say only one God.

52 V.S 5
You are creating a false division between "Lord God" and "God," based on zero evidence that they are speaking of two different beings. "Lord God," "Almighty God," "God," etc., all refer to the one and only God.

Here is the significant problem for your position: you want to think that, like all anti-trinitarians I have debated, that it's a matter of how many verses "support" each side, as though the person with the most verses in their favor win. But this is completely and utterly false; it simply is not how proper interpretation is done.

A theology of God proper must include all that Scripture reveals. So what we see throughout the Bible is that there is only one God. That is abundantly clear. Moses and Isaiah could not have made it more clear. So either you have to admit that God is lying or he is mistaken or perhaps Moses and Isaiah were mistaken in what they wrote down, which undermines the authority of Scripture.

You have no basis for saying that Moses and Isaiah said that there is one God but Paul says there are two, so therefore, there are two Gods. Either there are two Gods and God himself was wrong about it and you know more than God, or God is correct and he is the only one.

Your analogy to people is false, btw. You simply cannot compare the nature of God and the nature of humans in such a way. Regardless, I am not denying that the Father and the Son are distinct. That is a foundation of the doctrine of the Trinity.

You say the scriptures only make sense with the Doctrine of the Trinity, but the scriptures came first Free.
Well, not really. God has always existed, so the Trinity has always been. As for the revelation of that to us, of course the Scriptures came first. We are then to make the best sense we can of what is revealed to us.

The Trinity Doctrine never said there was one God, you said that based on what?
Based on Scripture.

Jesus is of the same Substance and essence of the Father. That is all the Doctrine said.
It need not mention any more than that since Judaism and Christianity are monotheistic religions; that there is only one God is a given.

You can't acknowled the Father and Son, You Say things can only be understood by a Cathloic Doctrine but not Cathloic and a doctrine much newer than the Word of God.
I don't believe it because it may or may not be Roman Catholic. That is completely irrelevant. I believe the doctrine of the Trinity as I have given it because it best takes into account all that Scripture reveals about God.

Free I am lost for Words. I was hoping after time passed by, you would have had time to look over things once again. I am hoping you still do.
And I am hoping you do.

And no Free, there is no Scripture stateing The Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are YHWH. In Fact the ONly Lord God called the Son Servant, not YHWH in ISa and Acts.
Matt 28:19 Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, (ESV)

Singular name but refers to the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, who are kept distinct. They share the same name, the three of them, so one can rationally conclude that it is YHWH.

Rom 10:9-13, 9 because, if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. 10 For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved. 11 For the Scripture says, "Everyone who believes in him will not be put to shame." 12 For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; for the same Lord is Lord of all, bestowing his riches on all who call on him. 13 For "everyone who calls on the name of the Lord [YHWH] will be saved." (ESV)

Paul is clearly linking this passage in Joel 2 to Jesus, which means that one is saved, in part, by the confession that Jesus is YHWH.

The FAther did not call the Son God until Hebrews.
What do you mean with that statement?

I know the scriptures Free, to believe something You need scripture. You see the Son with the Father at the Tower of Babel, and making Adam. Nothing there denotes they are the same being. Trinity would say there are two anyway, until pressed then they say they are one. Trinity keeps the seperate.
Where do you see both at the making of Adam and at the Tower of Babel?

Until your able to be honest and say, I see One Lord God and One Lord Jesus Christ in that Scripture, that makes Two. No point in continuing here
.
I have never said there weren't two but there is only one God. You cannot continue ignore the Scriptures which make that clear.

I know the scripture Free.
Knowing how to read and understanding what is said are two different things.

If you think you know the Scriptures, how about you address the passages I have given in Deut and Isa., one at a time so we can go over what they say.
 
Free, the issue is that we are both quoting the same scriptures. Zero places that tell us the Holy Spirit, Jesus and the Father or all the same person, or One God.

In Fact, the Holy Spirit does not even speak of his own. Not very God like free, but by definition of Theos, is a god.

Isa says there is but One Lord God, God knows of no other God. That is perfectly correct.

God calls the son a servant, ISa 48. Acts 3:26

So, since the Father is Giving the Word, we don't see Jesus getting the offical title until much later. Not that He has not always been God, but it's not in scriptures that way.

So you admit you never said there are not two. Glad we have come that far, I know you can at least see two now.

You could have used the Modern expression the God the father the first Peson in the Godhead, and Jesus the 2nd person in the Godhead.

You see Two, but there is One God. That is what Your saying.

I am saying the same exact thing Free, but I don't add the Cathloic mystery part at the end of that. I Count Two. that are still two, No mystery added.

There is only One Lord God, none like Him. Given a different description in Eze on His throne than the description Jesus was given on His throne.

Two different Visual descriptions Free, I can post the scriptures if you like.

We both used the same scriptures, same things, I am leaving out the mystery part though. The part that was added to the Original doctrine much later.
 
I wonder how this verse is understood?

1 John 5
20 And we know that the Son of God has come and has given us an understanding, that we may know Him who is true; and we are in Him who is true, in His Son Jesus Christ. This is the true God and eternal life.​
 
I wonder how this verse is understood?

1 John 5
20 And we know that the Son of God has come and has given us an understanding, that we may know Him who is true; and we are in Him who is true, in His Son Jesus Christ. This is the true God and eternal life.​
1 John 5:20
Each member of the Trinity is God.The Father is God,the Son is God,the Holy Spirit is God.One God 3 persons.
 
Yes, this would be the standard Christian understanding. But a person is defined as 'a human being'. How can God or the Spirit 'be a' human being?
 
Yes, this would be the standard Christian understanding. But a person is defined as 'a human being'. How can God or the Spirit 'be a' human being?
God is not a human being.God is the Supreme Being,the Creator and ruler.A human should never put them self on the save level as God.
 
1 John 5:20
Each member of the Trinity is God.The Father is God,the Son is God,the Holy Spirit is God.One God 3 persons.

You have just proven the whole reason I made this thread Kathi. One God, 3 persons is not Trinity at all, not even close. What you just quoted split a major denomination in 1928. You just quoted Oneness

One God is 3 persons.
Modern Trinity doctrine states It's 3 persons that are One God.

Once again, the Original said Jesus is the same essence as the father, Begotten, not created, God of God.

In 381ad the Holy Spirit was added to the doctrine.

Oneness:
This doctrine states that there is one God, a singular divine Spirit, who manifests himself in many ways, including as Father, Son, and Holy Ghost (a.k.a. Holy Spirit). This stands in sharp contrast to the doctrine of three distinct and eternal "persons" posited by Trinitarian theology.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oneness_Pentecostalism

I wonder how this verse is understood?

1 John 5
20 And we know that the Son of God has come and has given us an understanding, that we may know Him who is true; and we are in Him who is true, in His Son Jesus Christ. This is the true God and eternal life.​

It's understood just like it's written. Jesus is the FAther of Eternal life, and is a True God.

God the Father Called Jesus God, so there is no question Jesus is not God. Jesus is not His Father though or Creator. Trinity does not state that. Oneness says that. Trinity says all 3 are distinct, seperate, and not each other in role of function, but are One.

Oneness says there is One God that manifest as 3 persons, or is 3 persons plus however many other persons the One God needs to be.

However, this thread is about the original Trinity Doctrine that did not bring the mystery part added later by Rome. The mystery was how 3 divine beings, suddenly become One God.

All denominations say that part of the doctrine is a mystery because it's not in scriptures at all.

Methodist say it's a puzzle.
Baptist say its to hard for finite man to understand.
Cathloics say it's a mystery.

More Modern doctrines that don't like the mystery part and want to adhere to the Original say that Jesus is the same Nature as the Father.

There are many different versions of the Original doctrine.
 
You have just proven the whole reason I made this thread Kathi. One God, 3 persons is not Trinity at all, not even close. What you just quoted split a major denomination in 1928. You just quoted Oneness

One God is 3 persons.
Modern Trinity doctrine states It's 3 persons that are One God.

Once again, the Original said Jesus is the same essence as the father, Begotten, not created, God of God.

In 381ad the Holy Spirit was added to the doctrine.

Oneness:
This doctrine states that there is one God, a singular divine Spirit, who manifests himself in many ways, including as Father, Son, and Holy Ghost (a.k.a. Holy Spirit). This stands in sharp contrast to the doctrine of three distinct and eternal "persons" posited by Trinitarian theology.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oneness_Pentecostalism



It's understood just like it's written. Jesus is the FAther of Eternal life, and is a True God.

God the Father Called Jesus God, so there is no question Jesus is not God. Jesus is not His Father though or Creator. Trinity does not state that. Oneness says that. Trinity says all 3 are distinct, seperate, and not each other in role of function, but are One.

Oneness says there is One God that manifest as 3 persons, or is 3 persons plus however many other persons the One God needs to be.

However, this thread is about the original Trinity Doctrine that did not bring the mystery part added later by Rome. The mystery was how 3 divine beings, suddenly become One God.

All denominations say that part of the doctrine is a mystery because it's not in scriptures at all.

Methodist say it's a puzzle.
Baptist say its to hard for finite man to understand.
Cathloics say it's a mystery.

More Modern doctrines that don't like the mystery part and want to adhere to the Original say that Jesus is the same Nature as the Father.

There are many different versions of the Original doctrine.
Choose what you want to believe.The Bible tells us that the Trinity is one God in three persons.
 
Yes, this would be the standard Christian understanding. But a person is defined as 'a human being'. How can God or the Spirit 'be a' human being?

Your a spirit being with a flesh body. Your just not flesh, but a spirit covered in flesh. This is not the point of the thread though to define Jesus being God or not, or to define anything. The thread is about the Original Trinity Doctrine.

It's not a debate on if the Trinity doctrine is true or not. It is written, so it's real, it's just an examination of the Real doctrine compared to all the modern versions people have made up through the years.

I would start a new thread if you want to talk about spirit beings V.S Human ones.
 
Choose what you want to believe.The Bible tells us that the Trinity is one God in three persons.

I just posted you the Oneness doctrine. What are you even talking about. It's not what I want to believe, it's what the doctrine says. Hello?
 
I just posted you the Oneness doctrine. What are you even talking about. It's not what I want to believe, it's what the doctrine says. Hello?
Please be more kind next time when discussing or debating issues.Attitude is not wanted.Life is full of choices.I read the Scriptures literally and I see that the Trinity is one God 3 persons.This is my choice.Have a nice day and God's Blessings to you.
 
God is not a human being.God is the Supreme Being,the Creator and ruler.A human should never put them self on the save level as God.
I agree, God is not a human being. But the wording of the 'trininty' does identify God as 'a person'. Which by definition is 'a human being'.

Messiah was a human who put himself on the same level as God, no?
 
Your a spirit being with a flesh body. Your just not flesh, but a spirit covered in flesh. This is not the point of the thread though to define Jesus being God or not, or to define anything. The thread is about the Original Trinity Doctrine.

It's not a debate on if the Trinity doctrine is true or not. It is written, so it's real, it's just an examination of the Real doctrine compared to all the modern versions people have made up through the years.

I would start a new thread if you want to talk about spirit beings V.S Human ones.
No thank you. I'm just trying to engage in these forums. New here. Not trying to derail your thread.

Though your opening remark did remind me of one of my favorite songs; Spirits dancing in the flesh.....
 
I agree, God is not a human being. But the wording of the 'trininty' does identify God as 'a person'. Which by definition is 'a human being'.

Messiah was a human who put himself on the same level as God, no?
Persons as in three different individuals not human.
 
No thank you. I'm just trying to engage in these forums. New here. Not trying to derail your thread.

Though your opening remark did remind me of one of my favorite songs; Spirits dancing in the flesh.....

It's all good, there is another thread sort of like this in the same area you might want to check into about Jesus Being God. I think that is what that thread is about.

christianforums.net/Fellowship/index.php?threads/is-jesus-god.56923/

CAREFUL THOUGH, lots of folks get rowled up when you attack their doctrines.
 
Persons as in three different individuals not human.
Please don't think I'm being difficult here. But a person is a human being. Would you define an extra terrastrial as a human being (person)? Beings not from this world are not persons. The very first and most definitive explaination for person is 'a human being'. So to me defining God as a person just doesn't equate or work.

I realize you hold to a trinitary belief and am not trying to change your mind/faith. I'm merely expressing my inablity as a Jewish believer to understand the trinity doctrine as defined within orthodox Christianity.
 
It's all good, there is another thread sort of like this in the same area you might want to check into about Jesus Being God. I think that is what that thread is about.

christianforums.net/Fellowship/index.php?threads/is-jesus-god.56923/

CAREFUL THOUGH, lots of folks get rowled up when you attack their doctrines.
Thank you, Brother Mike.
 
Back
Top