Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Are God's powers limited?

TanNinety said:
Did you deliberately miss the "IF" in Drew's post? The rest of the response from Drew follows "IF" the initial condition of his statement "IF" is true. IF Drew was reading into your post he wouldn't preface his statement with if

Now, your turn to show HOW and WHAT STUFF Drew MADE UP that doesn't belong to your post! I know it's a hard task but give it your best shot.

Yes I did miss the "if" on purpose, Drew was setting the stage for a hypothetical argument.

ex. "IF" TanNinety, you are implying that Drew isn't trying to influence the readers following this post by creating a false argument, I submit that you are mistaken.

Someone else want to handle this one, or shall I? This is also a form of poisoning the well.
 
vic said:
Novum said:
Okay, that sounds to me like a testable claim. How, then, are you measuring things like "morality", "heresy", and "apostasy"? What are your criteria? What is your evidence?
My spiritual discernment, from a Christian point of view and the sad state of all things spiritual in this world.

Then you admit that this is entirely your opinion; moreover, you have yet to provide evidence for your claim or describe your reasoning for arriving at this conclusion.

[quote:8d184]So now you're changing your belief about advances in medicine and science? Which is it, vic?
Both. While things material do seem to getting better, all you are doing is "dressing the pig".
[/quote:8d184]

...in your opinion. :roll:
 
Reminder, the topic is about: “Are God's powers limited?â€Â

Oh and for those who don’t know what “poisoning the well†means the following might help:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Poisoning the well is a logical fallacy where adverse information about someone is pre-emptively presented to an audience, with the intention of discrediting or ridiculing everything that person is about to say. Poisoning the well is a special case of argumentum ad hominem. The term was first used with this sense [1] by John Henry Newman in his Apologia Pro Vita Sua.

This "argument" has the following form:

1. Unfavorable information (be it true or false) about person A is presented.
2. Therefore any claims person A makes will be false.

Examples:

Before you listen to my opponent, may I remind you that he has been in jail.
Don't listen to what he says, he's a lawyer.

In general usage, poisoning the well is the provision of any information that may produce a biased result. For example, if a woman tells her friend "I think I might buy this beautiful dress." then asks how it looks, she has "poisoned the well", as her previous comment could affect her friend's response.

Similarly, in written work, an inappropriate heading to a section or chapter can create pre-bias. As an example:

The so-called "Theory" of Relativity
We now examine the theory of relativity...

which has already "poisoned the well" to a balanced argument.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
This is Christian forum and I do my best to gloryfy God and Jesus. If I poisened the well then you can delete it. I don't believe I did do anything to digrace or gave a false testimony against God.
 
JM said:
Yes I did miss the "if" on purpose
Kudos for being honest that you elected to change the wording of my post, and thereby its meaning, and hence respond to a strawman version of what I actually wrote.

JM said:
Someone else want to handle this one, or shall I?
Please go ahead - another fastball down the heart of the plate is always welcome.
 
gingercat said:
This is Christian forum and I do my best to gloryfy God and Jesus. If I poisened the well then you can delete it. I don't believe I did do anything to digrace or gave a false testimony against God.

The continued fundamental disconnect between ginger and the rest of the world is amazing.
 
To all reading here, please refrain from personal insults. It is obvious that this thread is off track, and that we need to get back on as Nocturnal already pointed out. The Lord bless all of you.

Lovely
 
vic said:
To Drew, Novum and others,

It seems we are opposite sides of the meaning of "better". You are referring to material things like advances in science and medicine. To that end, I will agree with you. We are referring to the state of spiritual things like morality, heresy, apostasy, etc. To that end things are not progressing. Our very Bible warns this will happen.

You are confusing quality of life with things spiritual. The two don't always mix. Paul walked around with a "thorn" in his side but he was spiritually healthy. People may walk around in better health and that is even questionable, but most are spiritually void.
Greetings:

I think that we draw a false dichtomy when we distinguish between the "material" and the "spiritual". This a whole complex issue on its own, however I think that we look at things like Greeks. We should remember that the Scriptures emerge out of a Hebrew mind-set. I will boldly suggest that medical technology is just as "spiritual" as silent meditative prayer.

In any event, I am starting to believe that things are generally getting better - human morality is actually improving (albeit there have been some downturns) along with our science and technology.

I submit the following for the reader's consideration: There are at least 2 reasons why we Christians think that things are getting worse "morally":

1. Increased "bad news" in the media.

2. Scriptures such as the ones that lovely has posted that talk of the bad things that will happen in the last days.

I think that the media over-represents bad news. In a country of 300 million, you are bound to have the occasional postal worker gone nutz or 45 year old male celebrity cruising around town in his car wearing lingerie and looking for transvestites. We have an appetite and the media is willing to satsify it.

I think that, as in many other areas, Christian culture (at least in N. America) tends to dumb things down to "scripture bites". I do not deny the content of texts such as those in 2 Timothy, I just think that they may actually speak largely to a very specific and narrow window of time that precedes the dramatic convulsions associated with the end times.

On the other hand, I think we give short-shrift to what Jesus' teaching about the kingdom of heaven. My sense of his teaching is that the cross is a seminal point in human history. In Christ, God has begun to work in history to subtly but inexorably establish his Kingdom right here on this Earth. To me, this should mean that things are getting better in all senses, not worse. The Cross has to mean something for the evolution of the world, not just at some vague point in the future, but from the day of the Crucifixion forward.

Of course, the quality of the evidence for this claim is highly debatable.

But, I would bet a paycheck that many Christians get their opinions about this matter "handed to them" via some text snippets that speak of moral decay at the end times.

I think we would be wiser to look at Jesus' extensive teachings about the kingdom. I think that these teachings speak of God's intervention in history and the initiation of a subtle revolution whereby the work of Christ initiates a new age of moral progress as God inevitably works out his plans.
 
One more reminder, this topic is about ““Are God's powers limited?â€Â

Anymore off topic posts and personal insults will result in the topic being locked. Also, the person who makes a personal insult will be officially warned.
 
Drew said:
In any event, I am starting to believe that things are generally getting better - human morality is actually improving (albeit there have been some downturns) along with our science and technology.

This was my opinion when I was a non-believer.

God is seeking our tender loving heart. Look at the world. It is all about how smart you are, how powerful you are. Look at the rich countries and rich people. We have plenty of riches but never get to the oppressed and poor. It is because our overall wicked hearts. God is not happy with this kind of world. He will end this kind of world very soon and will have those obedient to God's kingdom.
 
Novum said:
gingercat said:
He will end this kind of world very soon and will have those obedient to God's kingdom.

How soon, ginger?

Noone knows except God. That's what the Bible says. But the Bible is clealy telling how the end of times will be like. It is decribing exactly now aday's world.
 
gingercat said:
Novum said:
gingercat said:
He will end this kind of world very soon and will have those obedient to God's kingdom.

How soon, ginger?

Noone knows except God. That's what the Bible says. But the Bible is clealy telling how the end of times will be like. It is decribing exactly now aday's world.

We've been here before in other threads. People have been predicting the end of the world since as early as 175 AD, always certain that the events of their day pointed towards the end being near. How can you be so sure that your predictions are any different from the failed predictions of the last 1900 years?
 
I suspect that God's powers are indeed limited in the sense that even His choices have consequences that constrain the set of other possible actions He can undertake. Consider the "God cannot make a round square" argument. Such a possibility is ruled out by the very meaning of the terms involved - it is a logical contradition. While I am not sure that logical contradictions are not really grounded in physically impossible things, I think that the limitations on God's power do not involve simply things that are logically impossible, but rather things that are simply "physically" impossible.

Perhaps even God cannot make certain physical things happen because of the ripple effect of such actions. Perhaps action X would cause the universe to self-destruct, so God would not really be able to perform action X.

Now I suspect that some will ask about the Old Testament miracles. I have not thought about them, but perhaps while they did violate natural law (regular patterns of behviour) they might not be physically impossible (I am speculating that there is a conceptual distinction between "lawful behaviour" and the physically impossible). And I admit that I have not thought through what I mean when I refer to the "physically impossible".

I think that we underestimate the "realness" of the created order when we assume that God can do any old thing He wants. To the extent that this world is "really real", God himself may have trouble with arranging for physically impossible things to happen.
 
Drew said:
I suspect that God's powers are indeed limited

That's not what the Bible says. It seems that you are making your own image of God.
 
Novum said:
gingercat said:
Novum said:
gingercat said:
He will end this kind of world very soon and will have those obedient to God's kingdom.

How soon, ginger?

Noone knows except God. That's what the Bible says. But the Bible is clealy telling how the end of times will be like. It is decribing exactly now aday's world.

We've been here before in other threads. People have been predicting the end of the world since as early as 175 AD, always certain that the events of their day pointed towards the end being near. How can you be so sure that your predictions are any different from the failed predictions of the last 1900 years?

The Bible says that noone can predict the end. If they did they are lying. All we can do is near time which is in the Bible.
 
To say that God is anything but omnipotent reduces God to the level of any of the multitude of beings worshipped as gods by pagan religions.

It is true that there are things that God wouldn't do, that fits with what the bible tells us of God's character. For example he wouldn't wipe out the entire human race again.

That doesn't mean he couldn't

For God's plan for creation to play out certain things can and can't happen. The world can not be wiped out before Christ returns.

God has given us his word that he will not make an attempt on humanity as he did with the flood, but we should never mistake unwillingness to do something, with an inability to do something.

I personally don't think there are any limits to the powers of the truly sovereign God of creation.
 
Back
Top