- Jan 23, 2011
- 4,994
- 531
I was unclear. God is Sovereign. He chose the Jews to preserve His Scripture, and they did both OT and NT. The canons that were "canonized by council" simply agreed with the evident and manifest will of GodAlfred, the context of your answer is concerning who has the right to determine the Canon of Scripture. You keep saying that the "Church Universal" has that right and has determined the Masoretic text as the proper OT for the Canon of Scrioture. That, taken with what you ssy above, is essentially proclaiming that whatever Christian agrees with you about that matter, no matter what denomination they go to, they are a true Christian and any Christian, like ne, who disagrees with you about the Canon, is a tare. You realize this?
The OT canon was formalized by the Jews, the NT canon by Gentiles but the criteria they used was "it had to be apostolic", from the Jewish apostles.
So I am consistent with this scripture:
1 What advantage then hath the Jew? or what profit is there of circumcision?
2 Much every way: chiefly, because that unto them were committed the oracles of God. (Rom. 3:1-2 KJV)
The Jews established what is OT and NT scripture. God is Sovereign, He orchastrated events that made that happen for the 66 books.
It did not happen for the apocrapha. The Jews rejected the OT apocrypha as scripture.
I live with that decision because when I inquired into this, I believe the Holy Spirit confirmed in my heart the 66 books are God's Word. He did not do that for the apocrapha.
I am following my conscience on this, not yours or that of others. I will be judged for my decisions, and if I am wrong my honest hearted defense will be, its what my conscience had me do. Therefore, I expect to be excused if I am wrong based on this text:
..."their conscience also bearing witness, and between themselves their thoughts accusing or else excusing them)"
(Rom. 2:15 NKJ)
It should be noted, Church councils haven't proved to be infallible. Moreover, the church divided. The Orthodox split from Roman Catholics because of the Filioque addition. (And I agree the Orthodox were right). But this points to a glaring problem in anyone's decision to follow Church decisions. They can contradict themselves meaning some of them are wrong. So those who follow a canon set by the church have no genuine superiority over me, who accepts what Sovereign God has made canon throughout all of Christendom and the Jews.
Last edited: