The fact is that many Christians get them for the specific purpose of having faith based designs; these are also proven to be effective conversation-starters; a factor hard to ignore.
So would drinking beer out of a 'Jesus Saves' beer mug at your local bar.
You can't rationalize worldliness by wrapping it in evangelism. It makes for a convenient excuse to get a tattoo, and in my example a convenient excuse to hang out in a bar drinking beer, but it isn't good for anything else.
And even if your motives are pure, all you're doing is sending the world the message that the church
is really just like the world. A very popular message these days. Has been for at least twenty-five years, I think. And it's why we have, as it's been said, a church that is a mile wide but only an inch deep.
You keep looking at this from the perspective of the naive Christian instead of the perspective of the world which knows, whether they can easily acknowledge it or not, that tattoos are vehicles of pride and sensuality. So when the church puts their stamp of approval on them they are approving of what those things still very much do represent in the world, whether we the church want to believe that, or not. Not a good thing.
My wife is a wonderful and modest lady: she wears make up and heels and when she's not wearing pants her hemline sometimes hovers above the knee: I think your comments about tattoos could in theory be applied to any of these things if one tried hard enough, but she is still modest and so can some tattoos be.
Blessings.
When tattoos become like manner of dress that used to represent in society what tattoos do now your point will be valid.
And just because, for argument's sake, the church has accepted various forms of unacceptable, worldly dress (I'm not suggesting your wife is dressing inappropriately), that makes it okay to accept the worldly practice of tattooing also? Explain that reasoning to me.
This to me is just another example of how a little leaven works through the whole batch. You know in just a few years, corseting will probably be rationalized in the church. The downhill slide into the ways, and loves, of the world will continue. Do your homework on corseting, now, so that in a few years when someone wants to have a 'faith based' corset you can explain to them it has no godly origins whatsoever that would justify Christians adopting the practice in the name of evangelism.