Ok you start.So, then let's talk about what the 'work' is that may or may not get burned up at the Judgment.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Join For His Glory for a discussion on how
https://christianforums.net/threads/a-vessel-of-honor.110278/
https://christianforums.net/threads/psalm-70-1-save-me-o-god-lord-help-me-now.108509/
Strengthening families through biblical principles.
Focus on the Family addresses the use of biblical principles in parenting and marriage to strengthen the family.
Read daily articles from Focus on the Family in the Marriage and Parenting Resources forum.
Ok you start.So, then let's talk about what the 'work' is that may or may not get burned up at the Judgment.
This is in line with the traditional view of having one's work burned up and losing any reward connected with that work.
While it's certainly true these kinds of personal works you speak of will not be rewarded, and in that sense will not pass through the Judgment with us into the kingdom, the context of the passage is building the building of God (and working the field of God). Some of that which is built in the building of God will not survive the Judgment of fire, while some will. Only that which will pass through will be a reward in the kingdom for the laborer who did that work.
This is especially significant to Paul, who had such a dramatic call to the ministry. The expectation for him to bring more than himself through the flames of Judgment and into the kingdom are much greater. In fact, the scriptures suggest he simply has no excuse not to.
What you shared is correct insofar as a person doing things that, ultimately, simply have no reward in the kingdom because those works count for nothing in the kingdom anyway. I just don't think that is what Paul is addressing in this particular passage. The context is that of the worker working in the building of God building the building of God, a building that the Bible says is a building made up of people, the foundation itself being people--Christ and the Apostles and Prophets--and one in which the Spirit of God dwells.And so you don't think the traditional view is incorrect?
Er, well, I've kinda been doing that.Ok you start.
What you shared is correct insofar as a person doing things that, ultimately, simply have no reward in the kingdom because those works count for nothing in the kingdom anyway. I just don't think that is what Paul is addressing in this particular passage. The context is that of the worker working in the building of God building the building of God, a building that the Bible says is a building made up of people, the foundation itself being people--Christ and the Apostles and Prophets--and one in which the Spirit of God dwells.
Paul is saying all this to the Corinthians because he is defending his ministry among them. He wants them to know that his gospel is true and that his efforts are sincere and properly motivated in preaching it to them, for what reward is there in placing people on the foundation of Christ and the Apostles and Prophets that will perishable in the fire of the Judgment to come and who will not be in the building of God on the other side of that fire because of a gospel message, or preaching effort that fails to build them up into that which will be saved? Paul says there is none, only that he himself will be saved, but as by fire. That being true, how can he boast and glory on the Day of Christ in work completed in the building of God who is not there on the Day of Christ to boast and glory in (2 Corinthians 1:13-14 NASB)?
Ok you start.
Yes, I'm very aware of the traditional view of the passage.Well, I give you Matthew Henry and Adam Clarke says the same thing about these verses.
I always feel pretty secure when a Calvinist and a non-Calvinist agree on scriptures.
"You are God’s husbandry, you are God’s building; and therefore are neither of Paul nor of Apollos; neither belong to one nor the other, but to God: they only plant and water you, but it is the divine blessing on his own husbandry that alone can make it yield fruit. You are not our husbandry, but God’s. We work under him, and with him, and for him. It is all for God that we have been doing among you. You are God’s husbandry and building." He had employed the former metaphor before, and now he goes on to the other of a building:According to the grace of God which is given unto me, as a wise master-builder, I have laid the foundation, and another buildeth thereon. Paul here calls himself a wise master-builder, a character doubly reflecting honour on him.....But let every man take heed how he buildeth thereon. This is a proper caution; there may be very indifferent building on a good foundation. It is easy to err here; and great care should be used, not only to lay a sure and right foundation, but to erect a regular building upon it. Nothing must be laid upon it but what the foundation will bear, and what is of a piece with it. Gold and dirt must not be mingled together. Note, Ministers of Christ should take great care that they do not build their own fancies or false reasonings on the foundation of divine revelation. What they preach should be the plain doctrine of their Master, or what is perfectly agreeable with it....
2. There are others whose works shall be burnt (v. 15), whose corrupt opinions and doctrines, or vain inventions and usages in the worship of God, shall be discovered, disowned, and rejected, in that day-shall be first manifested to be corrupt, and then disapproved of God and rejected. Note, The great day will pluck off all disguises, and make things appear as they are: He whose work shall be burnt will suffer loss. If he have built upon the right foundation wood and hay and stubble, he will suffer loss. His weakness and corruption will be the lessening of his glory, though he may in the general have been an honest and an upright Christian. This part of his work will be lost, turning no way to his advantage, though he himself may be saved. "
http://biblehub.com/commentaries/mhcw/1_corinthians/3.htm
This is just Swiss Cheese and confusion reigns. I want to make sure I am Clearly reading you right.
We will lose reward(a person) if someone we labor over walks away? And That reward lost is a ex-believer or convert to Christ And the Lost reward is a human being that burns forever and ever in the lake of Fire. And we are held responsible for that persons demise in the lake of fire? Do you not see the implications of all this?
You're right that the implications are troublesome. People are not works to be rewarded to other people. This is the problem with mixing the metaphors of the bible's figurative language as if the bible was only literal. It can suggest conclusions that are not theologically consistent with the gospel.
Right. Paul is not saying the people themselves are somehow rewarded to him. They are the reason for his reward of glory and joy and praise in the kingdom to come.People are not works to be rewarded to other people. This is the problem with mixing the metaphors of the bible's figurative language as if the bible was only literal. It can suggest conclusions that are not theologically consistent with the gospel.
Yes, I'm very aware of the traditional view of the passage.
The problem with it is, they are defining the foundation of Christ as the KNOWLEDGE of Christ, instead of what it is--Christ Jesus himself, which I showed from scripture it most certainly is. Then they define what is built on that foundation in that same vein, saying if we build false doctrines and knowledge of God on the foundational knowledge of salvation in Christ those doctrines and beliefs, and the worship that springs from them, will be shown to be false and will be burned up, and all that will remain is a person's fundamental knowledge of salvation through Christ--thus they will be saved, but that's all. All the works produced by them in line with the false doctrines they built on the knowledge of Christ will burn up with that false doctrine and they will have no 'atta boy' from God at the Judgment. While all this is certainly something that can happen, the context of the passage shows us that this is simply NOT what Paul is addressing.
So you can see that by these theologians starting out with the wrong premise to begin with--that the foundation is the KNOWLEDGE of Christ--that the explanation they build on it is wrong, too. Which is rather ironic considering the metaphor being used in the passage, lol.
I'm pretty sure it's God that places people in His Kingdom, not you or me or even Paul or Apollos.The important thing to get out of Paul's teaching is whoever you place in the kingdom of God, ...
Here you misrepresent what the reward is based on. Paul’s reward was based on him taking the Gospel (The foundation) to the field. Apollos’ reward was based on ministering to the plants growing in the field. Neither of which is a sales quote based on the # of converts.... otherwise you will have no reward for your labor, because they will not be with you in the kingdom to be a crown of glory and praise for you.
No, they are not the reason for his reward. His work as an apostle is the reason for his reward. Apollos’ work as a minister was his reward. God’s the one they serve in this capacity(as servants) and God’s the one responsible for growing the building, not them. You’re anything but being consistent.Right. Paul is not saying the people themselves are somehow rewarded to him. They are the reason for his reward of glory and joy and praise in the kingdom to come.
Wrong again. It is clearly shown; “if – the Corinthians” don’t pass through successfully through the Judgment to come, that’s on God, not Paul or Apollos. Why?If Paul's work--the Corinthians--pass successfully through the Judgment to come, Paul will receive the reward for a job well done … If they do not pass through safely and are burned up, how can he receive the reward for a job well done? That's his point to these Corinthians who are his work in the building and field of God.
What are those 5 crown that will be our reward?
http://www.gotquestions.org/heavenly-crowns.html
Will there be other rewards besides the crowns?That could very well be the case.
10 According to the grace of God which was given to me, like a wise master builder I laid a foundation, and another is building on it. But each man must be careful how he builds on it. 11 For no man can lay a foundation other than the one which is laid,which is Jesus Christ.
This is what I understand Paul to be talking about.
Paul preach a message of the gospel who's foundation is Jesus Christ. Each person who witnesses or spreads the message must be careful how he builds on that gospel message so as to not corrupt it.
FOR if they build on any other foundation other than the one Paul preached, which is Christ those works that he has done will be burnt up.
It is not the people he preached to that will be burnt, for some will find the Lord even with bad preaching, but his works will be burnt up because they were not built on the correct foundation or were not completely accurate.
He will not receive any reward for those things.
Lol, this is funny.I'm pretty sure it's God that places people in His Kingdom, not you or me or even Paul or Apollos.
5 Therefore, what is Apollos and what is Paul? [Good question. Answer is…]
Servants through whom you believed, [Okay. They are servants THROUGH whom you (the Corinthians) believed. ]
and to each as the Lord gave.
My point is; as with all of Paul’s writings, he gives the credit for “placing” people in the Kingdom to God, not himself. So your commentary above that it’s important to get out of Paul’s teaching is; YOU place in the kingdom of God… is erroneous.
Even though the Corinthians came “through” Paul, it was “God who caused it”, according to Paul.
I never suggested at all that the worker makes the building/field grow. What I pointed out was that scripture says the laborer's work--the people who he ministers to, who pass safely through the Judgement--will be his crown of exultation at the second coming of Christ (1 Thessalonians 2:19-20 NASB). The Bible plainly says this.So what’s Paul working toward for his reward? Read on. He tells us.
6 I planted, Apollos watered, but God was causing it to grow. 7 So then, neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything, but God who is causing it to grow. (LEB)
Here Paul (the works planter) repeats his stance two more times (so it’s hard to believe you missed it) that neither himself or Apollos are “anything” (but servants) relative to placing people in God’s kingdom. Rather it's God that is causing it (His building, His temple, His people, in this context) to grow. Did you catch that? God is causing it to grow. It's not Paul's work to make it grow (nor is his reward based on it growing).
Paul not only set the foundation of Christ among the Corinthians, but the two letters Paul wrote to the Corinthians, preserved in our Bibles for future generations of growing saints, may be the most lengthy 'watering' epistles there are in the Bible. He indeed shares in the task of watering, not just planting.Here you misrepresent what the reward is based on. Paul’s reward was based on him taking the Gospel (The foundation) to the field. Apollos’ reward was based on ministering to the plants growing in the field. Neither of which is a sales quote based on the # of converts.
Again, it's obvious that Paul also had the task of watering them. And not only them, but hundreds of years of future generations of growing saints. So whatever argument you're trying to make falls flatulent.Again, God is the one that gave them their works tasks (two different tasks)...
But Paul says they are:No, they are not the reason for his reward.
You're not listening. The crown of glory and exultation that Paul will figuratively wear as a reward are the people who he preached to and taught in this life and who make it through the coming Judgment. So how can Paul get a crown of glory and exultation through people he's preached to that don't make it into the kingdom after the Judgment? It's a simple question. It's not a matter of why those people are there, or not there. It's a matter of whether or not Paul gets any praise and exultation for them being there, or not.Wrong again. It is clearly shown; “if – the Corinthians” don’t pass through successfully through the Judgment to come, that’s on God, not Paul or Apollos. Why?
And Paul's point is, there is no crown of rejoicing for the gospel worker who has no souls saved to rejoice in on the Day of Christ. He himself will be saved, but his work (those he labored to set in the kingdom) will not be there because they did not pass safely through the Judgment at the return of Christ.3. CROWN OF REJOICING
A crown of rejoicing is a soul winner’s crown.
[...]
What a day of rejoicing that would be.
And Paul's point is, there is no crown of rejoicing for the gospel worker who has no souls saved to rejoice in on the Day of Christ. He himself will be saved, but his work (those he labored to set in the kingdom) will not be there because they did not pass safely through the Judgment at the return of Christ.
The reason they didn't pass through the Judgment, or whether they believed and then didn't believe, is not so much the point of the 1 Corinthians 3 passage as is the simple fact that those who won't pass through the fiery Judgment will not be there present with him in the Day of Christ for them to be a crown of joy and exultation for him.
My point is; as with all of Paul’s writings, he gives the credit for “placing” people in the Kingdom to God, not himself.
6 I planted, Apollos watered, but God was causing it to grow. 7 So then, neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything, but God who is causing it to grow. (LEB)
Lol, this is funny.
Only Jesus can save a lost soul as He alone brings in the harvest. All we are called to is to be the labourers of the harvest field planting the seeds of faith. We may never know in whom that seed will grow in that we planted and the Holy Spirit waters as together we are all one body of Christ who receive the crown of glory to place before the feet of Christ.