You would have a case if I was purposely doing it but I'm not. Your posts are very contradictory, that's where the issue is.
As I have already pointed out, and will do so again, your first two posts very strongly implied that there is no final bodily resurrection. I simply cannot see how they could be understood any other way.
And all I have stated is that you are wrong in what you are making those passages in the Bible say, in your understanding of them.
I have not refused anything and, again, I have not misrepresented what you have said, nor have I put words in your mouth. I will here post exactly what you posted in the first two posts:
"I am starting this thread so that we might take a closer look at what we believe the resurrection to be,
and do those beliefs actually align with what the scriptures says, or have we allowed other images and ideas to influence our understanding of the true resurrection.
I know there are some here on this board who will insist repeatedly that the Resurrection is still yet sometime out in the future waiting on the return of Jesus and the rapture, and they have a habit of repeating the same thing over and over again to reaffirm their belief. I thought about putting this thread in the Bible Study forum where debate would be limited, but I think the Apologetics forum will provide more discussion on the subject. I hope that we can have an honest open and respectful dialog and carefully look at the scriptures concerning the Resurrection.
I do not know what other people believe when it comes to the resurrection.
Is the resurrection connected with the dead rising up from the graves? Have we allowed the story of Lazarus coming forth from the grave to create an image of the resurrection from the dead in our minds? What is the nature of the resurrection: is it physical or is it spiritual?"
Those statements alone imply that what we believe about a future, bodily resurrection is wrong. But it doesn't stop there:
"
I believe the resurrection to be spiritual in nature, so in my posts when I am referring to the dead or the living in context with the resurrection, I consider the dead to be spiritually dead, though in the flesh they are yet alive, and those that are living are as a living spirit."
Those bolded words sound exactly what JWs teach about Jesus' resurrection--that it was spiritual, not physical. It is also a belief of Gnosticism.
And note that you have said all this within a context that implies that what we believe about a physical resurrection is not correct.
And then what I previously posted:
"From these passages and from
Acts 23:8 we are told that the Sadducees say there is no resurrection, but the Pharisees did believe in a resurrection. As to what the Pharisees actually believed I do not know, but the line of questioning
the Sadducees are applying here tends toward the belief in a physical bodily resurrection where they will once again pick up their lives in heaven. But to this line of thinking Jesus told them they were in error, not knowing the scriptures or the power of God. And then he corrected them saying God is not the God of the dead, but of the living. I wonder if Martha believed in a resurrection like the Pharisees or as the Sadducees tried depicting it?
John 11:24-26 Martha saith unto him, I know that he shall rise again in the resurrection at the last day. Jesus said unto her, I am the resurrection, and the life: he that believeth in me, though he were dead, yet shall he live: And whosoever liveth and believeth in me shall never die. Believest thou this?
I will have more to say on this passage as it relates to
John 5:28-29 and
Rev 20:5-6 later on, but
for now I want to stay focused on Martha’s belief in a resurrection at the last day, and Jesus correcting her saying I am the Resurrection. This is the first key to understanding the resurrection of the dead: JESUS IS THE RESURRECTION."
And from the start of your second post:
"
So if your thinking on the resurrection at the last day is more in line with that of Martha, or whatever the Pharisees believed, or how the Sadducees presented their understanding of the resurrection,
then know that Jesus said that you are in error, not knowing the scriptures nor the power of God. So lets look closer at the response that Jesus gave the Sadducees, because this is the second key to understanding the resurrection of the dead"
To sum then, your posts very clearly state that if I (we) believe the same as Martha regarding "resurrection at the last day...the know that Jesus said you are in error."
Nowhere in either of those posts is it stated that you actually do believe in a physical resurrection on the last day, and why would you since you've stated it is error.
You will note that I have not put words in your mouth but that I have used your very words. There simply is no way to take them except that you are saying that belief in a bodily resurrection on the last day is error. Not to mention that I have stated twice now that all the passages you gave have been misapplied and your understanding of them is wrong. Yet you have still failed to address that.