Christian Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Who are the Elect

I already got that one, JM.

Romans 8:29-30 For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren. Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.

When were these people foreknown?
Those who were known by God to be believers when Jesus preached (the common people who received his word gladly and those who had died whose spirits Jesus took out of death’s prison house) were predestinated to be ‘washed in his blood’ and born again after he had risen from the dead.
 
unred typo said:
I already got that one, JM.

Romans 8:29-30 For whom he did foreknow, he also did predestinate to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brethren. Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified.

When were these people foreknown?
Those who were known by God to be believers when Jesus preached (the common people who received his word gladly and those who had died whose spirits Jesus took out of death’s prison house) were predestinated to be ‘washed in his blood’ and born again after he had risen from the dead.

That would mean God needed man to decide before He could know who was going to decide. This means God at some point in time didn't know the future, this is called open theism is you're consistent...if not, it's called Arminianism.

:lol:
 
JM said:
That would mean God needed man to decide before He could know who was going to decide. This means God at some point in time didn't know the future, this is called open theism is you're consistent...if not, it's called Arminianism.

:lol:

JM
I believe this is Open Theism.. How Ironic that the guy who started this thread is an open thiest.. Atleast we know one thing for sure. There is NOWAY that an open Theist is one of the elect.

JM
Your input will be very valuable on the thread on salvation.
Thanks Oscar
 
JM wrote: That would mean God needed man to decide before He could know who was going to decide. This means God at some point in time didn't know the future, this is called open theism is you're consistent...if not, it's called Arminianism.

You can label it whatever you wish. I just believe what matches what the Bible has shown to be the case. The future does not exist yet. There is nothing to know or not to know about it. God knows what he is going to do but he changes when events change. His goals and character do not change. Some things are pre ordained to happen and God is perfectly capable of making those things happen. Nothing or no one can thwart his plan or mess up anything he determines will happen. He knows every thought ever conceived, everything that has ever happened as soon as it happens and as soon as it is inevitable to happen and at any nanosecond, God can change the course of events to suit his will.

When you say the future is known by him, does that means no detail can change from what God knows? Can I have any thought that he has not always known millions of years ago? Do you have scripture that says that?

But all that is off topic. I believe the ‘elect’ in that verse are just those people who listened to Jesus preach the gospel and believed then but were not able to be born of the Spirit until after the resurrection, and it really doesn’t have anything to do with the foreknowledge from the beginning of creation.
 
unred typo said:
JM wrote: That would mean God needed man to decide before He could know who was going to decide. This means God at some point in time didn't know the future, this is called open theism is you're consistent...if not, it's called Arminianism.

You can label it whatever you wish. I just believe what matches what the Bible has shown to be the case. The future does not exist yet. There is nothing to know or not to know about it. God knows what he is going to do but he changes when events change. His goals and character do not change. Some things are pre ordained to happen and God is perfectly capable of making those things happen. Nothing or no one can thwart his plan or mess up anything he determines will happen. He knows every thought ever conceived, everything that has ever happened as soon as it happens and as soon as it is inevitable to happen and at any nanosecond, God can change the course of events to suit his will.

When you say the future is known by him, does that means no detail can change from what God knows? Can I have any thought that he has not always known millions of years ago? Do you have scripture that says that?

Another Open Theist :o :roll: :o :roll: :o :roll: :robot:
 
unred typo said:
When you say the future is known by him, does that means no detail can change from what God knows? Can I have any thought that he has not always known millions of years ago? Do you have scripture that says that?

Yes.
No.
Yes.

I've posted them in over a dozen threads.

Exodus 33:19 God's mercy based on his will
Deuteronomy 7:6-7 (esp. 7) chosen-ness not based on something good in the chosen.
Deuteronomy 7:6 God chose the nation of Israel for no good thing in the nation.
Luke 6:13 Jesus chose disciples whom also he named apostles
John 17:16 A group of men belonged to the Father and he gave them to Christ
Acts 9:15 Paul was also a chosen vessel, as were the other apostles
Exodus 33:19 God will be gracious to whom he pleases
Deuteronomy 4:37 chosen-ness based on being beloved
Joshua 11:20 Decisions of the wicked are result of God's hardening
Job 23:14 God does that which he has appointed
Psalm 65:4 The man is blest who is chosen to enter God's house
Jeremiah 1:5 God knew Jeremiah before he was formed in the womb
Matthew 20:16 external call not the same as election
Matthew 25:44 The kingdom prepared for some people from foundation of the world
2 Timothy 1:11 Paul appointed a preacher, an apostle, a teacher
2 Timothy 2:10 Paul endures all things for the elect's sake
2 Timothy 2:19 The Lord knows them that are his
Hebrews 2:13 Behold, I and the children God gave me - applied to Christ
John 17:2 Christ gives life to those who were given to him by the Father
Ephesians 1:5 God predestinated us to adoption according the
good pleasure of his will.
Revelation 13:8 God chose people, not just a plan
Revelation 17:8 God chose people, not just a plan
Romans 9:11-13 God's choice not based on anything creaturely
Romans 9:16 Not based on man's will or man's exertion
Romans 10:20 God found by those who did NOT seek him
1 Corinthians 1:27-29 God chose the foolish, weak, low and despised
John 15:16 Apostles did not choose Christ, but he chose.
Acts 13:48 Those who were ordained believed.
Acts 18:27 Those who believed did so through grace
Philippians 1:29 Granted to us to believe
1 Thessalonians 1:4-5 Because chosen, the word came in
power of Holy Spirit and not just words of men.
2 Thessalonians 2:13-14 God chose them from the beginning to be saved.

A Future Someone Knows (vv5-8) – In all times, men have tried to know the future. In this passage we see that Jehoshaphat assumed that God did know the future. There is a belief system today that claims that God does not know the future because there is no future to be known. Scripture declares quite the opposite. God knows all His works from eternity (Acts 15:18), and there is nothing in His creation disconnected from His works (Col 1:16-17, Heb 1:2-3). Prophecy is not about God’s great skills in prediction. God knows the future perfectly. Occasionally, He lets us in on some specifics. Not only will Peter deny the Lord; he will do so three times, and then a rooster will crow. Cyrus will be the name of the ruler who releases the Jews from exile. Judas will betray the Lord, and the number of pieces of silver is set. Micaiah knows God is never wrong (v 28).

God’s Relation to Time – God’s dwelling is eternity (Is 57:15). His house is forever. This is saying more than simply He has lived there a long time. The scriptures do not teach that from everlasting to everlasting He was and will be God, but that He is God (Ps 90:2). This is why God’s prophecies are perfect. Trying to grasp this is too high for us (Psalm 139:6), and we are warned that we cannot exhaustively comprehend it (Eccl 3:11).



The Things God Knows – In the midst of this story, we see the exhaustive knowledge and providence of God.

Evil Men and Wicked Angels (vv 19-23) – God directed the evil spirits and used them to direct the actions and words of the false prophets. Notice that He does this without taking from them their own free actions. They are doing precisely what they want. God does the same thing with the wicked nation of Assyria (Is 10:5-7) and promises to judge them and hold them accountable for their arrogance (Is 10:12). Human responsibility is never taken away even as God sovereignly decrees those same actions. The words of God to those who crucified Jesus Christ is clear (Acts 2:22-23, 1 Pet 2:8); they freely rebelled and God decreed it so.

Random Actions (v 34) – God knew what that arrow was going to do as well as the stone with which David slew Goliath. He controls the gambling casinos (Prov 16:33). It rains in Bellevue and not in Kirkland according to His decree (Amos 4:7). How often does the day of death look as though it came randomly? But God teaches us otherwise (Job 14:5, Psalm 139:16).

The Seemingly Trivial (v 38) – God decreed dogs to be somewhere doing something at a particular time. He controls the sparrows and the hairs on your head (Matt 10:29-30). He controls the sleep of animals (Is 63:14). He knows how many steps you have taken today (Job 31:4). God sees everything outside and inside (Prov 15:11). And He knows all these things having decreed them all from the beginning (Is 46:9-10).



The Gospel Before the World Began – The story of Micaiah illustrates the exhaustive sovereignty of God in His knowledge, decrees, and providence of all things. Micaiah’s story is just a part of the larger story – the story of the gospel which was written before the foundations of the world.

Before Time Began (2 Tim 1:8-10, Titus 1:1-3) – God promised eternal life through the preaching of the gospel to sinners “before times eternalâ€Â. Grace was extended to sinners before time began in the mind and purpose of God – before there ever was a sinner. This was not done because God looked down the corridors of time, saw the future, and then made choices (Rom 9:10-11). Rather, it was made according to the counsel of His own will (Eph 1:11).



The Purpose of Predestination – God, the Creator of all things, knows all things, decreed all things, directs all things – the seemingly small, to the most significant. What is His purpose in ordering His Creation in such a way?

To Give Himself a Glorious Name (Is 63:14).

To Allow His Church to Declare That Glory (Eph 3:10).

To Declare His Power over Everything (Rom 9:17).

To Preserve a People According to His Promises to Abraham (Gen 45:7).

That We Might Sing of His Righteousness and Goodness (Ps 145:7).

Part of modern man’s problem with the doctrine of God’s exhaustive sovereignty, knowledge and providence, is that it puts all the importance on God and not us. But God did not create the heavens and the earth to declare their glory. He didn’t create us to declare our glory. He created everything and orders all things for His glory. And this means our chief reason for existence is to glorify God, enjoying His wisdom, His goodness, His grace and mercy, and doing so forever.
 
Acts 15:18
Known unto God are all his works from the beginning of the world.


Known unto me are all my works from the beginning of kindergarten. Well, I’ve forgotten a few things but God has perfect recall. Does that say either of us know the future? No. Scratch that one.

Colossians 1:16-17
For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:
17And he is before all things, and by him all things consist.


He created everything. He was there before he created anything. He holds everything together. Does that say he knows the future? No, scratch another. In fact, just go through your list and give me your best, most indestructible proof. I’m not going to waste time on these trumped up lists.
 
18`Known from the ages to God are all His works;
Acts 15:18 (Young's Literal Translation)

16because in him were the all things created, those in the heavens, and those upon the earth, those visible, and those invisible, whether thrones, whether lordships, whether principalities, whether authorities; all things through him, and for him, have been created,

17and himself is before all, and the all things in him have consisted.
Colossians 1:16-17 (Young's Literal Translation)

Sometimes you just have to know when to quit. See ya around.
 
unred typo said:
Acts 15:18
Known unto God are all his works from the beginning of the world.


Known unto me are all my works from the beginning of kindergarten. Well, I’ve forgotten a few things but God has perfect recall. Does that say either of us know the future? No. Scratch that one.

Colossians 1:16-17
For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:
17And he is before all things, and by him all things consist.


He created everything. He was there before he created anything. He holds everything together. Does that say he knows the future? No, scratch another. In fact, just go through your list and give me your best, most indestructible proof. I’m not going to waste time on these trumped up lists.

Unread
You do know that God is not bound by time right? :-?
 
JM wrote:18`Known from the ages to God are all His works;
Acts 15:18 (Young's Literal Translation)


So God knows all his works from the ages… that does not say God knew all the future from before the beginning of time. First of all, we don’t use that archaic expression so it doesn’t make a clear understanding. If it were ‘to the ages’, we could say he had plans to do something for a long, long time, not that he saw into the future. So since it is from the ages, he remembers all his works from the ages past until now. Nice try but no better the second time around.


JM wrote:16because in him were the all things created, those in the heavens, and those upon the earth, those visible, and those invisible, whether thrones, whether lordships, whether principalities, whether authorities; all things through him, and for him, have been created,
17and himself is before all, and the all things in him have consisted.
Colossians 1:16-17 (Young's Literal Translation)
Sometimes you just have to know when to quit. See ya around.


That doesn’t change a thing. He created everything. He was there before he created anything. He holds everything together. Why on earth do you think that says he knows the future?

Keep trying. Maybe you can find something so ambiguous and antiquated that you can make it say what you want it to. Sometimes, you just have to come up with a real argument, or let the topic drop off the board unanswered. Are you leaving? :wink:
 
unred typo

I think you have a contradiction. God is soverign and knows everything, and time doesn't work for him as it does for us. You say God knows what he is going to do but he changes...contradiction, if God is sovereign and all knowing, he already knows he will do this 'change'

Back on topic, the verses about predestiny. If you are predestined, you are called and you will come because God is sovereign.
 
Dancing Queen wrote: I think you have a contradiction. God is soverign and knows everything, and time doesn't work for him as it does for us. You say God knows what he is going to do but he changes...contradiction, if God is sovereign and all knowing, he already knows he will do this 'change'
Back on topic, the verses about predestiny. If you are predestined, you are called and you will come because God is sovereign.


God is not bound by his plans. He is unchangeable in his character and purposes. He can do as he pleases to accomplish what he pleases.

If God is truly sovereign, can he choose to make a world in which every person is able to choose of his own free will, no matter how bound he is in sin? I think this is the world we see in scripture and around us. A person who is totally consumed with addictions of any kind, has to but choose to seek to God for help and he is there strengthening them and bringing resources into their life. Doesn’t he promise that he is faithful who will not suffer man to be tempted above that they are able, and will with the temptation also make a way of escape? There may be a time that we are too wasted from the pleasures of sin for a season and it’s crippling after effects to do anything more than pray, “God help me.†Of course there is a point of no return in everyone’s life, when God takes even their miserable life from them.

Before the death of Christ, this might have gone against the sovereign laws that required a sacrifice but since Jesus bought us all with the price of his blood, we all are free to turn from sin and follow him. The enemy has told us we cannot obey, we are still slaves of sin and that it is impossible to live a life pleasing to God. One of Satan’s most viciously subtle tools are teachers who tell us how useless it is to claim this freedom to choose to follow Christ.
 
You're right, He is not bound by plans. But when you can see everything past, present, future, as no different, and know everything, then you surely know the outcome?
 
Dancing Queen wrote: You're right, He is not bound by plans. But when you can see everything past, present, future, as no different, and know everything, then you surely know the outcome?

That might be true if there is such a place or destination such as ‘the past’ or ‘the future.’ Do you have scripture for that assumption?
 
dancing queen said:
You're right, He is not bound by plans. But when you can see everything past, present, future, as no different, and know everything, then you surely know the outcome?

Dancing Queen.
Your post are right on target. I have mentioned some of what you mentioned as well.

Keep in kind that Unread is An ''Open Thiest''
So while he may say God is soverign, he contradicts himself with his answers as you have already seen.
 
dancing queen said:
You're right, He is not bound by plans. But when you can see everything past, present, future, as no different, and know everything, then you surely know the outcome?
 
As the OP. I have no objection to this branch into the "does God know the future" issue...I suspect, of course, that all these issues are indeed interconnected.

More directly addressing the question of "the elect", here is a repost of something that I have written in the past.

It is my understanding that some claim that God chooses an "elect" but that the way God chooses the members of the elect is in a manner such that He does not make this choice based on any characteristics of the person. If this is not what you believe, fine - this post may not be of interest to you. If you do believe that God's choice is neither arbitrary (essentially random) nor based on individual characteristics, then I submit the following for your consideration:

It does not appear that this a coherent position, because, unless God's choice is truly random, His choice must be based on some discriminating characteristic of the person He chooses (or does not choose).

There is a famous illustration of a hungry donkey presented with two buckets of oats. We imagine that the brain of the donkey is magically altered to render it incapable of identifying any distinguishing characteristics of the two buckets (although it does recognize the existence of 2 buckets). So, for example, the donkey can make no judgements like the following:

- Bucket A has more oats so I'll choose A
- The oats in bucket B look fresher, so I'll choose B
- etc.

If the donkey is not allowed (through this magical intervention) to make his choice based on characteristics that inhere in (belong to) the buckets, then the only option left for him is to choose randomly. Otherwise, he will starve.

For the situation of election, even God has no choice but to use discriminating properties to differentiate us one from another. You may say that I am imposing a human restriction on God. I don't think that I am. I think I am simply acknowledging the fact that God has created a universe where objects are differentiated from one another based on their inherent characteristics. If we think carefully about what makes Fred "Fred" and Joe "Joe" to an observer, we seem unavoidably drawn to conclude that it is only inherent characteritics that allow a third party observer to distinguish them: Fred is taller. Joe is smarter, Fred has more money, etc.

I submit that in order for God to choose to elect Fred (and not Joe), He has no option but to base that choice on something about Fred (or about Joe). Once you take away distinguishing characteristics. Fred and Joe seem absolutely identical to an external person, even God. So unless God "flips a coin", any selection He makes must be based on distinguishing characteristics.
 
Drew, it's time to pray and ask Christ into your heart. All this debate will not answer the questions your soul is seeking answers to.

jm
 
JM said:
Drew, it's time to pray and ask Christ into your heart. All this debate will not answer the questions your soul is seeking answers to.

jm
I am here to engage in the very difficult and serious work of understanding the truth. If you do not have the time for serious work, fair enough - life is busy, that's no crime.

As to asking Christ into my heart - that would make things a little crowded as He is already there......
 
Drew said:
As the OP. I have no objection to this branch into the "does God know the future" issue...I suspect, of course, that all these issues are indeed interconnected.

More directly addressing the question of "the elect", here is a repost of something that I have written in the past.

It is my understanding that some claim that God chooses an "elect" but that the way God chooses the members of the elect is in a manner such that He does not make this choice based on any characteristics of the person. If this is not what you believe, fine - this post may not be of interest to you. If you do believe that God's choice is neither arbitrary (essentially random) nor based on individual characteristics, then I submit the following for your consideration:

It does not appear that this a coherent position, because, unless God's choice is truly random, His choice must be based on some discriminating characteristic of the person He chooses (or does not choose).

There is a famous illustration of a hungry donkey presented with two buckets of oats. We imagine that the brain of the donkey is magically altered to render it incapable of identifying any distinguishing characteristics of the two buckets (although it does recognize the existence of 2 buckets). So, for example, the donkey can make no judgements like the following:

- Bucket A has more oats so I'll choose A
- The oats in bucket B look fresher, so I'll choose B
- etc.

If the donkey is not allowed (through this magical intervention) to make his choice based on characteristics that inhere in (belong to) the buckets, then the only option left for him is to choose randomly. Otherwise, he will starve.

For the situation of election, even God has no choice but to use discriminating properties to differentiate us one from another. You may say that I am imposing a human restriction on God. I don't think that I am. I think I am simply acknowledging the fact that God has created a universe where objects are differentiated from one another based on their inherent characteristics. If we think carefully about what makes Fred "Fred" and Joe "Joe" to an observer, we seem unavoidably drawn to conclude that it is only inherent characteritics that allow a third party observer to distinguish them: Fred is taller. Joe is smarter, Fred has more money, etc.

I submit that in order for God to choose to elect Fred (and not Joe), He has no option but to base that choice on something about Fred (or about Joe). Once you take away distinguishing characteristics. Fred and Joe seem absolutely identical to an external person, even God. So unless God "flips a coin", any selection He makes must be based on distinguishing characteristics.

Drew
You really don't understand that God is sovereign do you?
That God knows the beginning from the end.... :-?
That God knew those that would choose him from eternity past....

''One'' of the problems with open theism is that it takes away Gods sovereignty and this comes from the mind of man who tries and understand the mind of God....

Another thing that will be difficult for you to grasp is that the lambs book of life is already written. It was written before the foundation of the earth was even laid out.....God even knew of this converstaion we are having....

Another thing... There is no way to have faith that pleases God while being an Open Theist...Since we are saved by Grace through faith, what does that tell you...
 
Back
Top