francisdesales
Member
- Aug 10, 2006
- 7,793
- 4
mutzrein said:Scripture does say that to see or enter the kingdom of God man MUST be born of water AND be born of the Spirit.
No, it doesn't say that. You are dividing what Christ said. It says one must be born from above (one action) BY water and the Spirit. This is one act. Not "act one - water" and "act two - spirit", separated by many years. Nicodemus made that mistake and Christ corrected him. "What is flesh is flesh". He is not refering to things of the flesh, but the Spirit. Being born from above is clearly NOT refering to natural childbirth. And childbirth is NOT being born of water!
mutzrein said:Being born of water I know to be natural birth – ie born of the flesh. Being born of the Spirit, is being born again.
Christ is ignoring the first birth of the flesh by His words 'what is flesh is flesh". In other words, "that is not what I am talking about". There is not a "rebirth", since we are only born ONCE from above - that is the whole point of the idea of original sin, being born WITHOUT God's Spirit.
The problem is the Greek adverb, that can be taken to mean "born again" or "born from above". Jesus corrects Nicodeumus misunderstanding, and by the context, it becomes clear He is speaking of being born from above, not again.
mutzrein said:That is, when one is born of the Spirit he passes from death (the result of Adam’s sin) to life (made possible because Christ defeated sin and death, rose again and returned to the Father).
Yes, that is true, the womb and the tomb are different motifs of baptism.
mutzrein said:Jesus said to the disciples that the spirit that was WITH them would be IN them because when he returned to the Father the Father would send the Spirit which would from that point on, dwell within them and endue with power. This event which many readily accept as the ‘baptism of the Holy Spirit’ is (to me) synonymous with being born again.
How can they be spiritually born again if the Spirit had not given birth to anyone, according to you. There is no "born again" in the spiritual world. It is "born from above" the first time.
Regards