Hey Ms. Wondering,
You qualify the definition of "love", "mercy" and "justice" of God differently than Calvinists. You put a condition on these terms. The condition seems to me to be: (now I am stating as best I can my interpretation of your thoughts, so pardon me where I error) that
Hi FF,
This conversation is good. We're trying to understand each other and this is a good thing.
Jesus said we should love one another and that this is how we would be known to be His disciples. John 13:35
Although I do not agree with any of your beliefs, I do understand how one could come to these conclusions IF they study the bible with a reformed teacher.
What I find interesting is that if a person (or at least the ones I've known) goes through the N.T. on their own, they come to the belief that God loves them, that they need forgiving and that God is willing to forgive them.
This seems to me to be a basic concept found in the N.T. and all theology should derive from this.
Now, you seem to be a smart fella to me and I find it almost impossible to believe that you think the above of me....!
" God must love ALL BEINGS WITHOUT EXCEPTION IN THE SAME WAY. So, I suppose the most stunning example would be: God loves Satan. Similarly, God must offer everyone mercy or He is not merciful and He is not just."
1. I DO NOT qualify the words LOVE, MERCY, JUSTICE. YOU do.
I've posted verses stating that God is loving, merciful and just. There are plenty more.
But please explain the following to me:
HOW is God loving if He does not give me an opportunity to gain heaven by following a set of known rules but just let's me die in the pit, headed straight for hell.
HOW does God show any mercy to a person who may WANT to be saved, but HE has decided will not be receiving any grace from Him.
HOW is God just in your theology? Justice means to give to each one what that person deserves.
We are all lost and deserve to be separated from God at our birth.
God sets rules for how we could become saved.
If the rules are not for everyone....how is it justice?
If I'm damned because God damned me...how is that justice?
If I pay an eternal price because GOD never gave me the opportunity to be redeemed, how is this justice?
2. You say my belief would lead God to love satan.
God loves HIS CREATION. Satan is an enemy of God.
When God said all is good in Genesis 1:31 was satan present in that statement? Or was satan already an enemy?
God loves all His creation (us) but only those that believe in Him and follow Him will be His children.
Have you not read
Galatians 5:19-21 ??
19Now the deeds of the flesh are evident, which are: immorality, impurity, sensuality,
20idolatry, sorcery, enmities, strife, jealousy, outbursts of anger, disputes, dissensions, factions,
21envying, drunkenness, carousing, and things like these, of which I forewarn you, just as I have forewarned you, that those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.
Only the children of God will enter into the Kingdom of heaven.
(aside: Since God does not offer Satan and the fallen angels mercy and therefore is not just via your definition as I understand it, God must not be 'loving', 'merciful', and 'just'. Hmmm... I guess one could ask if you love Satan ... no insult meant ... just acedemic pondering of possibilities and logical consistancies ... anyways ... )
Jesus did not die to redeem the angels and satan...they are lost forever and will burn in hell.
2 Peter 2:4 the only time the bible mentions hell. (tartarus)
And yes, you asking if I love satan is rather insulting. This is not consistant with anything I've posted. And rather a morbid thought on your part.
Let's stick to discussing this seriously.
Calvinists do not restrict the definition of God's attribute of 'love', 'mercy', and 'justice' in such a way that He is obligated to there all people the same. Calvinists (I will speak for them, hopefully correctly) find it repugnant to think that a Holy God can love that which is abhorrent to Him.
How do you get the above idea?
Where is it stated in the bible that God treats everyone the same in the way that you mean it?
The rain falls on the just and the unjust. Matthew 5:45
God reconciled man to Himself while man was still a sinner. Romans 5:8
The grace of God can bring salvation to all people. Titus 2:11
and this explains it the best:
John 3:36
36“He who believes in the Son has eternal life; but he who does not obey the Son will not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him.”
As I've said,,,,God is a JUST God...
He loves His creation....but will be just with each person individually.
It is also an error to interpret “God is love” to mean God is only love…using love as a paring knife to cut away his power, justice, and wrath against sin, leaving only unconditional acceptance and positive regard, what Arthur Pink rightly disdained as “amiable weakness” and mere “sentiment.” Evangelical theologians do not eliminate divine justice, but they still become imbalanced if they teach that God is primarily love, as if love trumped all other attributes of God. Joel Beeke
I never said God is primarily love...although, yes, I'd say His main attribute is love.
I've always included mercy and justice.
... and as I said before, God is not obligated to have mercy on all without exception (evidence: Satan and his fallen angels) for it would be a mercy by obligation as opposed to freedom of choice.
... and calvinists feel God gives everyone justice ... His justice is not predicated on offering mercy to all without exception in our view.
God's justice is not predicated on offering mercy to all without exception???
Again....what does JUSTICE mean???
And how is it justice if different persons have different conditions through no fault of their own?
Final thought: Since the definitions of "love", "mercy" and "justice" do not contain a qualifying need that these attributes be equally distributied to everyone without exception you have distorted the definition of these words. This distortion resulted in you stating that you believe Calvinists do not believe God is a God of "love", "mercy" and "justice".
Example: I love my dog and I love my wife. Since I don't treat them the same, it cannot be love. I deny this understanding. You won't find it in the dictionary.
I have distorted nothing.
Read my statements carefully before you come to conclusions as to what others outside of calvinism believe.
I don't think it does. I am saying that your statements would lead to the following:
Premise 1: God loves everyone without exception (you probably use John 3:16)
Premise 2: Some people of premise 1 are the sons of Satan John 8:44
Conclusion: If premise 1 and 2 be true, then God love the sons of Satan.
Again, Calvinists (IMO) do not agree. The would say God loves everyone without exception with the love of benevolence (the rain from on the good and the bad). God loves those He choose before the foundation of the earth with the love of complacency as they are IN CHRIST via imputation.
Please provide scripture supporting your belief that God chose those He loves before the foundation of the earth.
Hmmm ... I would need an explicit definition of CALL to comment ... aside: You're wearing me out woman.... glad I took typing in high school. (I was good for a boy)
This is an important topic...it never wears me out....?
page 1 of 2