if someone comes around tonight and has a go at your wife, knocks you in the head with a ball bat and loads all of your valuables up and leaves with them, have they sinned?
First, this is a very ungodly way to try and make a point. You should be ashamed that you can not think apart from such base thoughts and reasoning.
A "believer" according to the gospel is not under the law of moses, but a sinner is very much under the law. Now if a "believer" is doing such things? Then they are for sure not walking in the truth, nor in the love of God. In fact they are under the law, for it is the law that produces sinful desires and is the strength of sin.
Ro 7:5 For when we were in the flesh,
the motions of sins, which were by the law, did work in our members to bring forth fruit unto death.
6 But now we are delivered from the law, that being dead wherein we were held; that we should serve in newness of spirit, and not in the oldness of the letter.
7 ¶ What shall we say then? Is the law sin? God forbid. Nay, I had not known sin, but by the law: for I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.
8 But sin, taking occasion by
the commandment, wrought in me all manner of concupiscence. For without the law sin was dead.
Just as the pharisees who claimed to uphold the law, yet inwardly were full of murder and evil lust, those who seek to murder others in the name of God, always do it while claiming to uphold the law of moses.
The example that John makes is just and most logical. It requires analytical thinking. It is mostly technical and not meant to be offensive. The point is illustrated very well due to its graphical nature. I use these examples all the time with believers.
I asked things like, can I take your TV set? Or, your car? Can I take your home? If I really want to drive the point, I get more personal with the subject of adultery. I ask can I take your ______ on a date? Of course by now the person is livid.
And that is exactly the point. No level headed believer will support the breaking of those commandments, especially when it is so close to home. Yet and still they say, I'm free, I'm not in bondage, I'm under grace, I'm not under the Law, Jesus fulfills the Law for me, all these are excuses!
The fact of the matter is that no believer will want me to violate them by breaking these commandments. If I invite them to bow down to an idol and worship it - they look at me like I'm crazy! lol
I go through this procedure for all 9 commandments and they all pass my test with flying colors. Hence, they believe by their reactions in keeping 9 commandments. But when I bring up the Sabbath things come back full circle - I'm free, I'm not in bondage, I'm under grace, I'm not under the Law, Jesus fulfills the Law for me! LOL
I have to roll on the floor.